As a SW I have always felt that I lose far more often to WMs, even WMs of far lower might, than to other SWs or JCs. However, my stats currently show that my wins vs WMs are 698, vs JCs are 661 and vs SWs are only 437. Based on my subjective impression and the fact that I have seen other people state that there are more WMs, I can only assume that us SWs are a significant minority in pvp. This, in combination with the generally accepted paper>rock>scissors nature of pvp (JC>WM>SW>JC), puts SWs at a systemic disadvantage. In other words, even assuming that as a whole, the classes are relatively balanced skillwise, it sucks to be a SW because there are many more WMs. JCs, on the other hand, enjoy an advantage because they don't run into as many SWs and there are always plenty of WMs around.
To back this up, I looked at the top 10 pvpers of each class and found the following:
avg Might avg pvp rating avg might/rating
JCs: 53915.5 2740.8 19.7
WMs: 55781 2720.7 20.5
SWs: 62334.3 2693.3 23.1
Interestly, the three classes were very evenly represented at the top of the pvp rankings. However, notice that the average might for SWs are significantly higher than that of the other two classes while at the same time, SWs had a lower average pvp rating. Based on the above admittedly small sample, SWs need on average 17.7% more might than a JC and 12.9% more might than a WM in order to achieve the same pvp rating. WMs need 4.9% more might than a JC.
Two caveats. First, as I noted above, this is a tiny sample size. Second, I obtained the might by clicking on each individual in the Top League screen. I don't know if this is accurate. For example, does Ceka at rank 4 as of the time of this post really achieve that rank with relatively crappy enchants and only 47,998 might?
Anyway, sorry for the long post but I would love to hear feed back on all this.
Great post! I've had many of the same thoughts myself!
Would be interesting to see if and how those stats change when taken on a larger scale (top 25/50/100 of each class).
Sure, the build shown may not be one's pvp build, but that would apply to all three classes, so should even out with a larger sample size and shouldn't change the overall differences significantly.
That said though, past a certain point, might stops being as huge as a factor. A maxed char with full 8s vs full 9s will see next to no difference vs each other in pvp, yet there's over 3500 might difference.
Especially since SW have the slowest stuns, unless we're init heavy, it's a question of whether we can outlast the enemy's opening salvo as to whether we win or lose. I've fought SW's half my might who put up an even fight due to the randomness of mirror matches.
i dont see that in my pvp eperience yet. i have beaten in most numbers Wm and Jus pretty much equaly. only vs other sw ive killed lesss than the other classes,cuz high level dodges and resists..
my sw was highest ranked plat 3 season 1 and 2 so far. beaten 70k wm/jus with 29k full phys build.
The only logical reason I can tell myself for your win rate against the 3 classes is that WM is the majority class and SW is the minority class. Also, my own SW's win rate against all the 3 classes follows the same trend as yours.
I don't know why they don't publish wins/losses for each class. to me that's more interesting than wins.
Jumper wrote:I don't know why they don't publish wins/losses for each class. to me that's more interesting than wins.
The more information Venan gives, the easier it will be for people to notice systemic problems and to demand fixes. Right now, since we don't have much information and due to the paper rock scissors nature of pvp, it's hard to make a strong complaint. For example, as a SW, I can complain all I want about how op WMs are due to their crits and fast casting and what not but WMs would just turn around and say you can't nerf us, we would get creamed even more by JCs with their jug and ss. It's all subjective and thus easily discounted, allowing Venan to avoid pressure to fix things.
Tyrr wrote:Jumper wrote:I don't know why they don't publish wins/losses for each class. to me that's more interesting than wins.
The more information Venan gives, the easier it will be for people to notice systemic problems and to demand fixes. Right now, since we don't have much information and due to the paper rock scissors nature of pvp, it's hard to make a strong complaint. For example, as a SW, I can complain all I want about how op WMs are due to their crits and fast casting and what not but WMs would just turn around and say you can't nerf us, we would get creamed even more by JCs with their jug and ss. It's all subjective and thus easily discounted, allowing Venan to avoid pressure to fix things.
Justi loses more vs wm than they win... Outside of masters anyway, but for the vast majority who aren't there get creamed. My wm thrashes justi and sw, I just find them overused and stupidly op
Fun I wanna do my stats
402 wm
270 justi
200 sw
Totally agree fighting double wm like one after the other trying to break through a wall it's super difficult.. And yeah mirror matches between sw are really messed so random. I like this post been thinking same things for awhile too ohhh and I asked once same thing as jumper like in beta they used to show losses and someone told me it's just more stuff people can complain about
Kwenchel wrote:Fun I wanna do my stats
402 wm
270 justi
200 sw
Totally agree fighting double wm like one after the other trying to break through a wall it's super difficult.. And yeah mirror matches between sw are really messed so random. I like this post been thinking same things for awhile too ohhh and I asked once same thing as jumper like in beta they used to show losses and someone told me it's just more stuff people can complain about
During beta all sorts of win-loss records were being pinged about in an attempt to justify anything. So I'm not surprised Venan just removed losses as a viewable number. In theory it should keep people more focused on the wins they're racking up instead of W/L ratios. In practice people know when things aren't quite right and give feedback when they see it.
When you calculate your average, did you take the pvp build? For the top 10, average might fot pvp build have to be higher...