Book of Heroes

Melee for War Mages · page 2

Bj_Knows

ModeratorTue Jan 20, 2015 11:59 am
EricM wrote:
Yup, you can actually purchase it, enchant it, and gain a bonus from it. We had a certain member who unfortunately enchanted her mage with phys damage without realizing how useless it was :p

At least he was not a SW who purchased the 2h Damage Enchant (or in the old days, got the Loot Drop), thinking it would help with Off Hand Dagger.
Jumper wrote:lol b!

yes I'm sure about the 1h. I argued it wasn't true, but go read the attack description again.

2h: magic attack dealing physical damage
1h: physical attack dealing physical damage

who the hell knows why.

I tested and that is correct. I really think a long time ago it wasn't that way.

Long ago, I used to play an early Internet multi-player space battle game called Galactic Bloodshed. I had an entire fleet that used completely wrong builds (heavily armored shuttles, tankers that were all guns, etc) and it was the insanely effective because nobody expected it. Too bad that doesn't work in BoH PvP.....

Derp_looks_like_a_Lady

Wed Jan 21, 2015 12:41 pm
Bj_Knows wrote:
MacCormick wrote:So basically your answers are that Venan screwed up their text on staff attack as well as messed up the overall game in giving WM the melee stat and even making it increase per level. I would expect more like 25 magic /5 melee increase per level since only magic really matters.

No, Venan did not screw up.

It is just complicated.

In the *current* version of BoH, equipping a Staff gives you Staff Attack with zero cool down. Staff Attack is a magical attack (uses character's Magic Bonus * Weapon Speed), that does physical damage (resisted with opponent's Physical Mitigation).

There is no reason for a War Mage to get Melee Gems or the Physical Damage Bonus Enchant.
Note: I said that they said Venan screwed up...

The Melee rating says "increases physical damage by X".

Staff Attack says "spell attack that deals 100% physical damage".

Therefore Staff Attack damage ought to be modified by the Melee rating as well as the Physical Damage enchant.
MacDeamon wrote:
Bj_Knows wrote:
MacCormick wrote:So basically your answers are that Venan screwed up their text on staff attack as well as messed up the overall game in giving WM the melee stat and even making it increase per level. I would expect more like 25 magic /5 melee increase per level since only magic really matters.

No, Venan did not screw up.

It is just complicated.

In the *current* version of BoH, equipping a Staff gives you Staff Attack with zero cool down. Staff Attack is a magical attack (uses character's Magic Bonus * Weapon Speed), that does physical damage (resisted with opponent's Physical Mitigation).

There is no reason for a War Mage to get Melee Gems or the Physical Damage Bonus Enchant.
Note: I said that they said Venan screwed up...

The Melee rating says "increases physical damage by X".

Staff Attack says "spell attack that deals 100% physical damage".

Therefore Staff Attack damage ought to be modified by the Melee rating as well as the Physical Damage enchant.

No. They say it's a magic attack. melee rating and phys damage enchant only improve physical attacks. This magic attack is then delivered as physical damage (I see how there is an ambiguity in the title "physical damage enchant" but the description is clear and the attacks do behave as described.

Derp_looks_like_a_Lady

Wed Jan 21, 2015 3:09 pm
Jumper wrote:
MacDeamon wrote:
The Melee rating says "increases physical damage by X".

Staff Attack says "spell attack that deals 100% physical damage".

Therefore Staff Attack damage ought to be modified by the Melee rating as well as the Physical Damage enchant.

No. They say it's a magic attack. melee rating and phys damage enchant only improve physical attacks. This magic attack is then delivered as physical damage (I see how there is an ambiguity in the title "physical damage enchant" but the description is clear and the attacks do behave as described.

Technically they say that it's a "spell attack" ;0p but anyway it appears that the Melee rating description is wrong because what you're saying is that it doesn't increase physical DAMAGE but rather increases physical ATTACKS or the likelihood that those attacks will hit. :0)
MacDeamon wrote:

Technically they say that it's a "spell attack" ;0p but anyway it appears that the Melee rating description is wrong because what you're saying is that it doesn't increase physical DAMAGE but rather increases physical ATTACKS or the likelihood that those attacks will hit. :0)

I think ya'll are confusing the issue.


Physical damage done = (Base Weapon Damage + Melee Stat Bonus Damage) * Offensive Enchant Boosts and then modified by the skill used, debuffs placed, etc.

Magic damage done = (Base Weapon Damage + Magic Stat Bonus Damage) * Offensive Enchant Boosts and then modified by the skill used, debuffs placed, etc.

Chance to hit = 100% - (opponent dodge + opponent block) for physical attacks and 100% for magic attacks (since magic attacks land even if dodged or blocked).

Derp_looks_like_a_Lady

Wed Jan 21, 2015 8:07 pm
EricM wrote:
MacDeamon wrote:

Technically they say that it's a "spell attack" ;0p but anyway it appears that the Melee rating description is wrong because what you're saying is that it doesn't increase physical DAMAGE but rather increases physical ATTACKS or the likelihood that those attacks will hit. :0)

I think ya'll are confusing the issue.


Physical damage done = (Base Weapon Damage + Melee Stat Bonus Damage) * Offensive Enchant Boosts and then modified by the skill used, debuffs placed, etc.

Magic damage done = (Base Weapon Damage + Magic Stat Bonus Damage) * Offensive Enchant Boosts and then modified by the skill used, debuffs placed, etc.

Chance to hit = 100% - (opponent dodge + opponent block) for physical attacks and 100% for magic attacks (since magic attacks land even if dodged or blocked).
Now we return to my original confusion... since it's physical damage, why doesn't melee affect the damage range?
MacDeamon wrote:
Now we return to my original confusion... since it's physical damage, why doesn't melee affect the damage range?

I believe its a typo. A few updates ago, mage's staff attack was switched to do magic damage I believe. The flavor text is a bit confusing and wasn't completely changed.

Basically the staff attack is a magic attack. If you add a magic gem and check the parameters, you'll see it do more damage. Reason why adding hero training doesn't always increase damage parameters is because after 2000 melee or magic stat, diminishing returns cut in so that every 12.5 stat addition only adds +1 to bonus damage. So when you upgrade hero training once to +8 stat, you may not see the +0.66 bonus damage due to rounding error.

Hope that answers everything.
MacDeamon wrote:So we're all in agreement that the text needs to be fixed.


Yup yup though honestly, how often do you need to use staff attack as a wm? Feels like a low priority fix.