Book of Heroes

Justicar 1h vs 2h. Play Nice.

New Subject
Justicar 1h versus 2h. Play Nice

Mod Note: Moved to Requests & Suggestions

OLD Subject
Justicar 1h versus 2h. Need dev answer

Hello. I am pretty sure most of player dont care about this since most of justicar in pvp are 2 hands... And you are right, 2h is far better than 1h.

Thats why im probably the last justicar 1h in top ranking pvp... And yeah im going to complain and i want an explanation because i dont understand some things. So please dont come to write something if you know nothing about justicar 1h.

Im going to compare 1h and 2h with same rotation gem. Basically whats the différence between these 2 build?
1/ damage weapon and haste weapon.
2/ in tree skill stagger (for 1h) versus elder fury (2h)

First différence:
Sword 1h = 1.0 haste
Sword 2h = 1.3 haste with elder fury that becomes 1.15...
So sword 1h is 15% faster.
Damage: sword 2h do 65% damage more than 1h.

Conclusion: 2h lost 15% haste but have +65% damage.


2nd différence:
Elder fury give 3 boost: possibility to block- resist knock back- increase haste

Stagger: possibility to reduce 60% damage during 1 sec if u block.

A jc 1h with heavy shield has 24% block so basically u have 24% to put stagger. There is nothing else....

Now compare 2 justicar with combo seismic...

If justicar 2h seismic a justicar 1h: he can do wound-brutal-wound....
If justicar 1h seismic a justicar 2h: he can do brutal-wound...
So even with a faster attack u do less damage and less hit... Justicar 2h can do 3 hits with +65% damage.... Whats the point to do a jc 1h then? The fast attack its just an illusion. 1h is so weak compare to a 2h.

So i want to ask to a dev why u dont put too a resist knock back for 1h too? 1h suffer already a lot with his weak damage.

Zombie_Princess_Kenny

Fri Jan 30, 2015 3:55 pm
Ceka wrote:Hello. I am pretty sure most of player dont care about this since most of justicar in pvp are 2 hands... And you are right, 2h is far better than 1h.

Thats why im probably the last justicar 1h in top ranking pvp... And yeah im going to complain and i want an explanation because i dont understand some things. So please dont come to write something if you know nothing about justicar 1h.

Im going to compare 1h and 2h with same rotation gem. Basically whats the différence between these 2 build?
1/ damage weapon and haste weapon.
2/ in tree skill stagger (for 1h) versus elder fury (2h)

First différence:
Sword 1h = 1.0 haste
Sword 2h = 1.3 haste with elder fury that becomes 1.15...
So sword 1h is 15% faster.
Damage: sword 2h do 65% damage more than 1h.

Conclusion: 2h lost 15% haste but have +65% damage.


2nd différence:
Elder fury give 3 boost: possibility to block- resist knock back- increase haste

Stagger: possibility to reduce 60% damage during 1 sec if u block.

A jc 1h with heavy shield has 24% block so basically u have 24% to put stagger. There is nothing else....

Now compare 2 justicar with combo seismic...

If justicar 2h seismic a justicar 1h: he can do wound-brutal-wound....
If justicar 1h seismic a justicar 2h: he can do brutal-wound...
So even with a faster attack u do less damage and less hit... Justicar 2h can do 3 hits with +65% damage.... Whats the point to do a jc 1h then? The fast attack its just an illusion. 1h is so weak compare to a 2h.

So i want to ask to a dev why u dont put too a resist knock back for 1h too? 1h suffer already a lot with his weak damage.
They do. It's called Knockback Resist.

Bj_Knows

ModeratorSun Feb 1, 2015 10:42 am
People, play nice.

This might actually get an Dev answer if you discuss it in a rational manner.

Bj_Knows

ModeratorTue Feb 3, 2015 1:14 pm
Ceka wrote:
Im going to compare 1h and 2h with same rotation gem. Basically whats the différence between these 2 build?
1/ damage weapon and haste weapon.
2/ in tree skill stagger (for 1h) versus elder fury (2h)

First différence:
Sword 1h = 1.0 haste
Sword 2h = 1.3 haste with elder fury that becomes 1.15...
So sword 1h is 15% faster.
Damage: sword 2h do 65% damage more than 1h.

Conclusion: 2h lost 15% haste but have +65% damage.


2nd différence:
Elder fury give 3 boost: possibility to block- resist knock back- increase haste

Stagger: possibility to reduce 60% damage during 1 sec if u block.

A jc 1h with heavy shield has 24% block so basically u have 24% to put stagger. There is nothing else....

MY PERSONAL OPINION
I do not work for Venan.

Devs apparently want 1h Weapon plus Heavy Shield to be very defensive in PvP (Note 1).

In my experience it is currently it is impossible to Tank in PvP. This goes back to the problem of Monster Health/ Defense versus Player Health/ Defense that hurts the Shadow Walker (Note 2). The problem is most easily seen in the Health Multiplier for PvP versus PvE combat.

The situation is further aggravated by all the Enchants that enhance damage (1H, 2H, Fire, Ice, Spirit, Nature, AP, Initiative, Accuracy, etc) and the three Enchants that enhance Defense (Defense, Block & Block Power). Block Power is pretty useless by itself, since Block has the better numbers (Note 3). Even the Coliseum Gear set give the equivalent of a +20% 1H or 2H Enchant.

I no longer use Stagger in PvP since you cannot Tank. I use Neurotoxic Stab rank 1 for its Damage Per Second, so I never use rank 2- 3. I use Blight Runes to finish off a group of Mobs with low Health, not to reduce their damage, so I only buy Spirit, Frost and Fire Runes (depending on character).

Current version of BoH appears to be all about the DPS (see Elixir of Speed popularity).

Note 1)
Darkhorse wrote:
Dave basically pegged it. Stagger was doing the opposite of what we wanted 1H justicar's to do, which is massive hits. It wasn't the original intended design.

As for low level Justicars, they were overwhelmingly winning PVP matches prior to 2.0. By an extremely large margin (almost 2:1 wins to losses sub level 30).
justicar 2.0

Note 2)
Bj_Knows wrote:
Shadow Walkers are at a huge disadvantage hunting Potion Elites. A lot of their Ability Set draws out the combat (Quickness rank 3, Caltrops rank 3, Poison Cloud rank 3, Sticky Grenade rank 3, Acid Spray rank 3, Smoke Bomb rank 3, Off Hand Dagger is 0.0 Speed, Off Hand Dagger + Corrosive Blades rank 3p, etc.). Where War Mages and Justicars get 2h Weapons which do a lot of damage per hit (Weapon Damage + [ Weapon Speed * Bonus Damage from Gems ] ). So a lot of Shadow Walker's best abilities are *hindered* by Elixir of Speed
Min Gems or Geometric Diminishing Returns (R=Exp+)

Note 3)
Checking Math or Block, Block Power & Defense Enchants

Thë_Täxmän_Cän

Wed Feb 4, 2015 2:31 am
I'd love to see more of a focus on defense. Makes for a longer figjt and a longer fight makes for more strategy/options. It is a shame that most fight sequences in masters dont vary that much. I'd really love to switch to a 1h justi but it is clear the hierarchy for jcs is melee>magic>shield. I think that could rectified by an increased defense buff or shield stats, or a kb talent for 1h... and a backswing for magic jcs(less damage of course as our melee isnt nearly as strong,or letting mag jcs equip staffs. But basically weak spell dodged damage is nowhere near an equivalent to hitting a 10k backswing... assuming you only backswing once in a fight, and stagger(with its short duration) is laughable versus backswing and smite.
I think taxi has gotten it right in general, not just for justies. No matter the class, the damage is way too huge. Too much fluke involved and no skill involved. I don't think any attack should be able to drain 60% of the enemy's health. My mage is hitting top ranking players with 24k crits.

Having said that, I enjoyed the old pvp (pre-insane damage, pre t18pvp gear) where different builds had their merits. I remember playing Ceka's 1h justie and having the match last 2 snapcasts. there was way more strategy. Basically now Whoever gets the first dodge or resist or huge crit wins....seems pretty lame.

My fights used to be 12 or more moves, now they are like 3-5

Illy_the_Red

ModeratorWed Feb 4, 2015 4:13 pm
Thë_Täxmän_Cän wrote:I'd love to see more of a focus on defense. Makes for a longer figjt and a longer fight makes for more strategy/options. It is a shame that most fight sequences in masters dont vary that much. I'd really love to switch to a 1h justi but it is clear the hierarchy for jcs is melee>magic>shield. I think that could rectified by an increased defense buff or shield stats, or a kb talent for 1h... and a backswing for magic jcs(less damage of course as our melee isnt nearly as strong,or letting mag jcs equip staffs. But basically weak spell dodged damage is nowhere near an equivalent to hitting a 10k backswing... assuming you only backswing once in a fight, and stagger(with its short duration) is laughable versus backswing and smite.

Backswing was pegged as not working properly a good while ago. The damage appears to calculate differently from other abilities. The official response was 'its working as intended' (i.e. we didn't check).

Stagger was nerfed out of use once things were switched around allowing 2H builds to be viable. I've seen some good 1H players but they are an exception. Don't recall them even using Stagger actually.

Bj_Knows

ModeratorFri Feb 6, 2015 8:45 am
Bj_Knows wrote:
I no longer use Stagger in PvP since you cannot Tank. I use Neurotoxic Stab rank 1 for its Damage Per Second, so I never use rank 2- 3. I use Blight Runes to finish off a group of Mobs with low Health, not to reduce their damage, so I only buy Spirit, Frost and Fire Runes (depending on character).

Current version of BoH appears to be all about the DPS (see Elixir of Speed popularity).

Since PvP, and PvE, combat is so short, Haste is the single most important Stat in BoH. Reducing Attacks does little to help this. But an outright Miss can turn a killing blow into a chance for the opponent surviving. This is especially true with Tier 18 Weapons versus lower Tier Armor.
Bj_Knows wrote:
Change Minor Blight Runes, Major Blight Runes and Neurotoxic Stab. Instead of reducing the Magic & Melee Rating, it causes a chance to Miss. Ex: Minor Blight Runes would not reduce Rating by 20%, instead causing a 10% chance to Miss. Neurotoxic Stab rank 2 would not reduce Rating by 10%, instead causing 5% chance to Miss.
v1.5.2 Blight Rune

Give Stagger, Neurotoxic Stab and Minor/ Major Blight Runes a Miss Debuff for the Target or reduce the Target's Accuracy or give the player a Dodge Buff. I would prefer the Miss Debuff, but any of the three would be better than the current situation.