Book of Heroes

Ideas for New Types of OS

Ok, so my guild was brainstorming new types of OS and I came up with a twist on the current version. Don't know how plausible it is to implement with Venans current system but here it goes.
(Some credit here must go to DJ for an idea he posted in a previous thread)

How about an OS phase where you are no allowed to heal at all throughout the round but the round is timeless as long as you have health? You could either just kill until you get killed then get credit for your kills exactly like the same way the current system works or implement a "surrender" button you would use before your life totally expires as I know RPP resets when you die and I don't know if there's a way around that.

This would make a lot of elixirs and health gems relevant as well as cause all sorts of new discussions on best build types and balancing melee/magic gems with health. Hey! Maybe it might even allow Justis to hit similar RPP numbers as WM and SW...maybe.

I realize that there are ways to abuse this type of OS but implementing a max might for the raid wouldn't be too difficult, right?

Would love to hear any other ideas anyone else has thought of!

Illy_the_Red

ModeratorFri Feb 6, 2015 1:18 pm
Main snag with this one is that SWs rely on Death Wish to be at all competitive, which only kicks in at below 25% health. You really need that damage boost to get into the same ballpark as Mages. There's also the problem that Justicars can't get near either of those because of Venan nerfs and general dodgy balance. Only Mages would do well at this type of raid (and I'm sure the devs don't want that....hmm)

Let's have a 'pure onslaught' raid where we can really test builds and challenge our toons rather than the poor GV raids we have at the moment. I don't see why we can't have a longer but OS-only raid, perhaps with mixed 4e/10e phases or with different energy reqs. If the whole raid is OS then there would be no reason to skunk, raiding could become constructive and social again. LoB and PM in particular have encouraged poor behaviours from mercs and players in general. I hope the devs have learned from these raids that we want something that's a challenge without killing player cooperation stone dead along with chats.

I'd like a challenge function though, where you can choose an enemy/enemies and then give yourself handicaps, like no healing or no runes. Fight old monsters and bosses but at your own might/level.
A pure OS raid won't work. You could use it as pure farming without ever having to complete the raid. for example, find a dead guild, solo said new raid (even if you don't finish...lol) the rewards would be huge.

As for Sara's Idea I'd love to see a new twist to os!!!!

I don't think justies and sw would be at a huge disadvantage given their kb, and dodges (mages have neither) Assuming of course the bosses aren't OHK on every attack.
Justis aren't too bad at OS, if melee, but definitely not in the same area as wm or sw... OS MUST be revised for all 3 toons for it to be brought it. Don't know about anyone else, but I'm bored of third fiddle after 3 updates
I'm more than willing to give it a shot. Anything for a change of pace.

I'd also like a no heal infinite dungeon. Pay whatever e it takes. You go as many rounds as you can till you die. The number of rounds determines the payout.
Until Justis can even remotely compete in OS, it's sitting firmly in the "Don't Care" bucket alongside PVP.

I'm all for new PvP content, and new raids, but if I'm at an immediate disadvantage due to the class I selected 2 years ago, it'll be greeted with an almighty "meh". A pure onslaught raid would actually be worse than an LoB-style - at least in LoB I could help clearance in p1, leave the WMs and SWs to fill their boots in 2-3, and come back for p4 with regenned e.
Bbbb wrote:
I'd also like a no heal infinite dungeon. Pay whatever e it takes. You go as many rounds as you can till you die. The number of rounds determines the payout.

This idea I like. The mechanic exists already (portals) and it'd make a nice change from farming Caliban for essence ^_^
Guys remember that I'm talking about killing until you die...Justis do poor in OS because they are slow and only have a couple of very strong attacks and there is a time limit. This style of play would not reward quick, thoughtless killing as well as strategy. If you put a boss with moderate resist it requires the WM to more carefully select atks as resisting debuffs is the fastest way to make a WM ineffective. As for SW not being able to use DW, again they have the fastest group of moves in the game as well as incredibly high dodge rates and urgency/rispote. This type of OS is pure strategy and simply being the strongest isn't going to get you very far so I don't see a huge disadvantage with no DW. And again, like I said, it MIGHT help balance the Justi OS issue some, who knows.
I agree with Sara. And like she says, different strategies might become more important than "all power no defense" seems interesting.

But more importantly something NEW! When Venan brought in KFS they changed the whole mentality for the game. With LoB it was the second try and I think overall it was a success. But the GV raids have simply regressed the game to gk/VG days.

Unfortunately I am not creative enough to think of good ideas but something new and different needs to happen.
Fair point Saraa, I'd be happy to see something like that, though I think the SW / Deathwish issue might have some validity. Without DW, SWs struggle on damage output, but without access to smaller health pots, they won't last long using it.
As a sw I would be happy to do a raid where survival is key. Sure DW wouldn't be a good option but trying to figure out the best build for performance could be fun. No healing means less silver used. Something new means less boredom. The fact, that if done right , defense and strategy could be as important as speed and damage output means different builds could be equally effective. If you kept the revive feature you could burn your way to a high score. Seems like it could potentially have something for everyone.