Just adding my 2 cents, on some of the ideas and suggestions discussed earlier.
* Holiday Goblin came too close to the publish of t18 gear. That was also the reason for delayed PvP t18. understandable. now it will be more logical to include some t19 event gears.
* Raids are too long. For the heavy players, as said before, dropping a few toons becomes work and not fun.
The idea of selecting short, medium or long raids is actually brilliant (500/1000/1500 waves, for example). This way a guild can run top raids out of its "time zone" with fewer members and still enjoy it. The incremental increase of rpp actually (and already) lowers the rewards in short raids. rpp can start, maybe, a bit lower (than 100) to raise reward differential between raid lengths.
* side note on raids: if I want to PvP, why "leaving" a raid resets my rpp and quitting then logging in does not? Leaving a vile incursion portal does not reset prograssion, which is good and as should be.
There are only two logical reasons to reset raid rpp: (1) Dying in the raid and (2) Spending money. (Buying/Healing)
* Raids are too tough? recruit. Well, sorry I don't believe in it. the higher you get, guilds are small families who run multi toons and forcing the whole family to meet for a raid means unwanted pressure (well, once, twice is ok. but not all of the "family" (=guild) "works" (=plays) at the same time. RL is probably the #1 reason to quit playing.... playing becomes pressure and not fun.
Also, the higher you get, I think less and less people are moving from one guild to another and new members are to slow in coming.
* Guilds: (or attacking the raid problem from another angle) if 100 toons/guild is not enough to properly finish a raid (and not make it a job) there is the option of raising the max toons to 150 or 200.
Still another angle to attack the problem can be "sister guild pacts" that any guild can select a sister guild and when one starts a raid, the other can merc it freely (without taking merc spots) and divide the guild spoils towards the starting guild. 60/40 for example. (constant shared guild chat can be nice also, but that is for another topic)
* Fun raids vs. Boring raids (or onslaught vs. regular raids).
Some like onslaught. you need to master it, you have action all the time. Totally understandable. On the other hand, it is a full time job. Many players can only drop, leave and come back later. This doesn't work well in onslaught, and discourage players from jumping in, especially when there is currently no GV onslaught raids.
* I've been playing for approximately a year and a half and my main is just nearing +900 from hero tokens. When anyone says they are already maxxed out, remember they are only a handful. Still, they are the core of the game, they are burners ($$$) and they are top guildmasters and backbones of guilds. they need to be satisfied and there has got to be a way to do that without considerably giving a higher edge to those few. (give them an edge, they deserve it!)
* My inventory is full of strange stuff that could be traded. PLEASE, let me trade stuff. Let me make a pillow from the feathers, or just wast crafting time to make them something useful (sell pillows for silver?)
Sorry, the last is mostly a rant pointed at some players.... I hope poeple who criticize PvP will read it.
* PvP. Dear lord, thank you that you made me atheist. (

)
Thinking of it, it is unimaginable tough to think of all the factors (speeds, weapons, talents) of three classes, which in turn can be fire/ice, physical/spirit and poison/whatever and still make this mess stick (=playable).
all this even before talking about you need to match people with people who are not only near in league but also ONLINE and IN QUEUE.
Luck must be a major factor in PvP. If it wasn't, a LVL35 45K might would always win over LVL35 44K might. that would be sad and boring. so I met a master in Gold 1. It was a good loss (lost miserably, of course). People are replacing a weapon or skill and jump or drop a league or more. Examples like this only show how little is the difference between 3 sequential leagues.
Take it as a chance to learn. For heavens sake, the rewards are even the same (winning/losing).
PvE minuses in PvP gear is balanced. you can play a full t18 PvE with t7 enchants or a full t18 PvP AND PvE specs with t5-t6 enchants for the same resources. that is no huge difference.
PvP can be better, but it looks pretty solid to me.
Just for reference, I have one PvP toon, full t18 PvP gear, started PvP as a full PvE at 23k might, now at 38k might. some 1000 fights under my belt. not a lot but not a few. very quickly found a place in top gold 1 or lower Plat 3. Staying there means that for my skills and might, I'm in the correct place.
See you around, I'm still playing!