As usual, Eric has it bang on. Reasons 3 - devaluing t19 as a whole - and 4 - screwing anyone who doesn't get it from this event until t20 comes out - are my own biggest concerns. PvP not so much, as it won't impact me beyond seeing everyone complain about it, but it is a very legitimate issue for those who do.
A t19 2h weapon (which is what the WMs and Justis will want) is a more powerful item than a t19 ring or amulet that were a MAJOR grind to get. Giving it away as an event item (because the predictable backlash will occur if it's available but "hard to get") makes no sense.
A t19 1h weapon, on the other hand, will pretty much only please SWs, leading to a different but no less predictable backlash. And that makes no sense.
Either way, it strikes me as a serious drop of the ball.
A t19 2h weapon (which is what the WMs and Justis will want) is a more powerful item than a t19 ring or amulet that were a MAJOR grind to get. Giving it away as an event item (because the predictable backlash will occur if it's available but "hard to get") makes no sense.
A t19 1h weapon, on the other hand, will pretty much only please SWs, leading to a different but no less predictable backlash. And that makes no sense.
Either way, it strikes me as a serious drop of the ball.