svako wrote:EricM wrote:
Not to be that guy... but...
If the Justi has 25% dodge, 12% block, and 61% knockback...
Seismic has a 63% (100%-25%-12%) of landing when not defended, and if it does, it'll only knockback the enemy 0.55s (39% of 1.4).
oopsie, a little mistake occured in the simpliest part of the math(the knockback one)... but still, you see the point 
and this: Seismic has a 63% (100%-25%-12%) is wrong, my math is right in this part. You can't just + the chances. If you have 25% dodge and 12% block its not 25+12=37% chance to avoid by using any of it. Its 25%(dodge chance)+(12%(block chance) * 75%(chance you dont proc dodge)) = 34%(chance to avoid by dodging or blocking). I'm 100% sure with this. Simple prove, if you would have 50% dodge and 50% block, it would bring you to 100% chance to avoid it by one of these using your math, while the true chance is 50% + (50% * 50%)=75%
In every other game, you'd be correct. The chance to dodge would be rolled first, and then on a failed dodge, the game would roll a block. But not in boh

To not undervalue block, it actually is additive. So with 50% block and dodge, you can't get hit (but you can still be crit - which is a different roll altogether). I'm 100% sure on this - been confirmed multiple times. They treat it like a d100 roll. If you have 20% dodge and 40% block, 1-20 is a dodge, 21-60 is a block, 61-100 is a hit.
It's actually why, for a while, my pvp strategy centered around 55-57% dodge + 12% block (So that on a defend, seismic has a 1-3% of actually hitting me). It's not as great as it sounds however because keep in mind - warmages and shadow walkers both have skills that can lower dodge/block, and additionally warmages' attacks always do damage despite being dodged/blocked.
One thing I always wanted to try was a SW with 58% dodge through gems, 68% damage mitigation through enchants and 10 resist gems, and 33.6% block through shield + block enchants. Even without defending, any attack would only land 8.4% of the time, and even if it landed, it would only do 32% damage... Too bad block enchants are useless for pve and would require a whole new set with exorbitant transfer costs :p That and this past year's updates have started making defense more and more useless (defense enchant nerf, creation of magma jet and fracture stacks, pvp gear bonuses, etc.) to the point where even attempting the above build would end up being useless vs a wm or sw.