Book of Heroes

Rework Frost shield · page 2

BibleThump wrote:
iMerc wrote:I find it a bit unbelievable that you lost 16k hp just from the ice shield
1.2k ice shields 12-13 actions 16k hp

Gosh 1.2 ice shield even with molten on me it hits for like 800-100 max

Illy_the_Red

ModeratorTue Feb 17, 2015 1:32 pm
It has been discussed elsewhere, but it's interesting that this ability is considered ok (procs always, even on non-damaging hits) whereas a low-proc (check it) ability like Urgency is criticised. Balancing abilities takes a critical eye (no pun intended heh) and this is often from the position of other classes. The tweaks we see in abilities comes from data generated in the most part vs other classes, so it's no surprise that the most criticism of certain class abilities comes from those that don't use them.
To be getting hit for 1200 damage off ice shield, either you're facing players with t18s while having under 30% defense, or if they aren't t18s, your defense is seriously low.

I'd recommend investing in defense enchants, and possibly better gear.

While ice spike is frustratingly painful (I've lost 16k hp) from it in prolonged marches, it's possible to work around it. It penalizes you for quick attacks, so use more piercings and less reflexives while facing those enemies. You want to take them down quick before you've lost significant amounts from it.
EricM wrote:To be getting hit for 1200 damage off ice shield, either you're facing players with t18s while having under 30% defense, or if they aren't t18s, your defense is seriously low.

I'd recommend investing in defense enchants, and possibly better gear.

While ice spike is frustratingly painful (I've lost 16k hp) from it in prolonged marches, it's possible to work around it. It penalizes you for quick attacks, so use more piercings and less reflexives while facing those enemies. You want to take them down quick before you've lost significant amounts from it.
Nice idea and all, but i play a hybrid utility sw and the way war mages are designed is that they get to let loose their whole arsenal before you can do anything. so i get hit by frozen shard, magma jet, icy grasp, incinerate/shattering and then a snap casted ability and then theres nothing i can do even if i have 5k health left. i got 5 actions left to deal 12-20k damage.sorry but pvp is just stale and infuriating atm they should seriously rework all classes
I'm aware that mages unleash their whole arsenal in the beginning. That's what makes status resist enchants so paramount to stopping them. If you're hit by shard, magma, stun, shatter, and then a snap-incinerate, you're virtually dead without stat resist enchants to prevent some of those effects, defense enchants and magic resist gems to mitigate that damage, and health gems to survive long enough to counter attack.

The issue with pvp, contrary to popular belief, isn't balance. It's that winning against a particular class requires a very particular type of build and while there's infinite variety in builds, only a very small subset of those builds can actually win consistently.

And while it sounds great in theory, a hybrid-utility pvp sw struggles quite a bit. Vs wms it relies on using a whole bunch of low cast time attacks that do next to no damage - basically setting yourself up to be ice spike bait and Vs justis, its relying on the statuses which never land since jugg is up for most of the match.
EricM wrote:I'm aware that mages unleash their whole arsenal in the beginning. That's what makes status resist enchants so paramount to stopping them. If you're hit by shard, magma, stun, shatter, and then a snap-incinerate, you're virtually dead without stat resist enchants to prevent some of those effects, defense enchants and magic resist gems to mitigate that damage, and health gems to survive long enough to counter attack.

The issue with pvp, contrary to popular belief, isn't balance. It's that winning against a particular class requires a very particular type of build and while there's infinite variety in builds, only a very small subset of those builds can actually win consistently.

And while it sounds great in theory, a hybrid-utility pvp sw struggles quite a bit. Vs wms it relies on using a whole bunch of low cast time attacks that do next to no damage - basically setting yourself up to be ice spike bait and Vs justis, its relying on the statuses which never land since jugg is up for most of the match.
it has been working better than melee and those low cast time abilities can pack a punch but yes its rather weak vs full damage mages.
BibleThump wrote:
it has been working better than melee and those low cast time abilities can pack a punch but yes its rather weak vs full damage mages.

You might want to listen to Eric. He has been ranked 1st in PVP as a melee SW (with nobody boosting him) so he probably knows what he is talking about.
Bbbb wrote:
BibleThump wrote:
it has been working better than melee and those low cast time abilities can pack a punch but yes its rather weak vs full damage mages.

You might want to listen to Eric. He has been ranked 1st in PVP as a melee SW (with nobody boosting him) so he probably knows what he is talking about.
cool story

Zombie_Princess_Kenny

Wed Feb 18, 2015 1:21 pm
BibleThump wrote:
Bbbb wrote:
BibleThump wrote:
it has been working better than melee and those low cast time abilities can pack a punch but yes its rather weak vs full damage mages.

You might want to listen to Eric. He has been ranked 1st in PVP as a melee SW (with nobody boosting him) so he probably knows what he is talking about.
cool story
No wonder you lose. You don't take advice.
Yeah i dont take advice. Not like i got my build from an ex rank 1 sw that is currently rank 6. but please continue talking out of your ass