Book of Heroes

PvP, Throwing a Bout- Win based Rewards

I have a suggestion. Won match would give 150% of marks, lost match would give 50% of marks.
Most of the players have 50/50 win/loss ratio so basicaly it wont do any harm and it would prevent people to just loose quickly to get marks(it wont be worth it), making PvP a bit more realistic...

I dont expect this to happen, just wanted to say my opinion. Its stupid to let people that dont like pvp(and play it only for marks with quick looses) to get same amount of marks as people who actualy enjoy it and play it for fun too. No offence to anyone, this is just how i feel it.

Illy_the_Red

ModeratorThu Feb 19, 2015 4:31 am
svako wrote:I have a suggestion. Won match would give 150% of marks, lost match would give 50% of marks.
Most of the players have 50/50 win/loss ratio so basicaly it wont do any harm and it would prevent people to just loose quickly to get marks(it wont be worth it), making PvP a bit more realistic...

I dont expect this to happen, just wanted to say my opinion. Its stupid to let people that dont like pvp(and play it only for marks with quick looses) to get same amount of marks as people who actualy enjoy it and play it for fun too. No offence to anyone, this is just how i feel it.

Why? It's their choice to farm PvP as a source of marks for gems or later on for materials. Sounds like you just want to drive these people away from the PvP minigame entirely simply because they don't like it but want to use the rewards. Practically the only marked improvement made to PvP in the switch from beta to...what we have now, is that the rewards were evened out. In beta it became all about the rewards and by extension the W-L ratio. Venan wisely wanted to focus on the positive sides of PvP while losing the emphasis on that ratio. So you can see your wins by class, but not your losses.
These guys are ruining PvP for those who still likes it :)

Example:
Player with 65+k might from masters/p1 decides to just farm the marks, which drops him to p3(giving someone free rating). In p3 he needs to get back up, so he starts playing normal, meeting someone who have to work hard to get to p1(lets say me ;) ). He beats him like a dog and take away lots of rating from him.
With 150%/50% he can do the same ofc, but will loose 50% rating in high league and gets it back in lower league. He dont have to leave pvp because of it, he can just play normal and stay in p1/masters. It should motivate people who cares... I have no problem meeting this dude is league where he belongs, have a fair fight and loose normal amount of rating if i loose the match. But meeting him 2 leagues below is not fair, cause i play uneven match with even more uneven rating change(met one of these guys yesterday, 4 games in a row, won one time cause i got lucky and get -27, -25, +6, -23).

Result of this suggestion is not to make people leave pvp, but to motivate them to play it normaly. As i said, they can still do it like they do it now, but at a slight cost of marks(loose 50% rating in high league and gets it back in lower league). I think its fair to put people who take pvp seriosly to a slight mark gain advantage.

If someone like PvE and is good at OS raids(no top tier raid for it now, but that will change soon imho), gets higher RPP than someone who dont pay attention to it, getting PvE rewards more quickly, so why dont do the same for people that like PvP?

Illy_the_Red

ModeratorThu Feb 19, 2015 4:12 pm
svako wrote:These guys are ruining PvP for those who still likes it :)

Example:
Player with 65+k might from masters/p1 decides to just farm the marks, which drops him to p3(giving someone free rating). In p3 he needs to get back up, so he starts playing normal, meeting someone who have to work hard to get to p1(lets say me ;) ). He beats him like a dog and take away lots of rating from him.
With 150%/50% he can do the same ofc, but will loose 50% rating in high league and gets it back in lower league. He dont have to leave pvp because of it, he can just play normal and stay in p1/masters. It should motivate people who cares... I have no problem meeting this dude is league where he belongs, have a fair fight and loose normal amount of rating if i loose the match. But meeting him 2 leagues below is not fair, cause i play uneven match with even more uneven rating change(met one of these guys yesterday, 4 games in a row, won one time cause i got lucky and get -27, -25, +6, -23).

Result of this suggestion is not to make people leave pvp, but to motivate them to play it normaly. As i said, they can still do it like they do it now, but at a slight cost of marks(loose 50% rating in high league and gets it back in lower league). I think its fair to put people who take pvp seriosly to a slight mark gain advantage.

If someone like PvE and is good at OS raids(no top tier raid for it now, but that will change soon imho), gets higher RPP than someone who dont pay attention to it, getting PvE rewards more quickly, so why dont do the same for people that like PvP?

They've already tried in beta. It wasn't favourable because winning (and not the fun of dueling) became the absolute in PvP. Everything became about maintaining precious win/loss ratios which could then be used to justify any claim they chose to make. I remember asking a question of the devs and getting the response that they didn't want people fixating on their losses or ratios any more. So they evened out rewards and switched to a different approach. People who play regularly earn more marks and you don't get penalised for having a poor build, gear or strategy. You get the same rewards based on completing the match, win or lose. Can't really get more fair. The current way provides impetus to complete more matches to push your rating up and also doesn't penalise your rewards should you choose to test new builds, gems or rotations.

Bj_Knows

ModeratorThu Feb 19, 2015 4:58 pm
svako wrote:
I dont expect this to happen, just wanted to say my opinion. Its stupid to let people that dont like pvp(and play it only for marks with quick looses) to get same amount of marks as people who actualy enjoy it and play it for fun too.

There are many, many ways Venan can encourage PvP for the Win (Note 1), but they have so far declined to comment on any of them.

However, no matter what Venan does I will always throw PvP Bouts. For two examples, I fought a character with 1 Win, so I threw the Bout so they could get 1 Win against a War Mage, and complete their PvP Quests (requires 14+ wins). Another time I fought the same character three times in a row, they had zero chance of winning, but I threw the third Bout to give them a Win.

Note 1)
Suggestion Stub, PvP Max Gear Stat & Bonus

Bj_Knows

ModeratorThu Feb 19, 2015 5:08 pm
svako wrote:
He beats him like a dog and take away lots of rating from him.
With 150%/50% he can do the same ofc, but will loose 50% rating in high league and gets it back in lower league. He dont have to leave pvp because of it, he can just play normal and stay in p1/masters. It should motivate people who cares... I have no problem meeting this dude is league where he belongs, have a fair fight and loose normal amount of rating if i loose the match. But meeting him 2 leagues below is not fair, cause i play uneven match with even more uneven rating change(met one of these guys yesterday, 4 games in a row, won one time cause i got lucky and get -27, -25, +6, -23).

That is *not* how PvP Rating works.

Example:
Character A has a Highest Rating of 3000,
Loses, until his current Rating is 1000,
Beats Character B, who has a Rating of 1000,
Elo *does not care*, it sees a Rating 1000 fighting a Rating 1000 and adjusts the Ratings the same as if both were fighting at maximum Rating.

You care confusing this will Elo *MATCHING*, if Character A with current Rating of 3000 cannot find a match, the matching eventually pairs him with Character B with current Rating of 1000. Character B loses little because they are not expected to win. If Character A with a *current* Rating of 500 is eventually matched with Character B with current Rating of 1000, then Character B loses a whole bunch because of Character A having the wrong rating.

*This* situation is caused by too few players PvPing. The more people who PvP, the closer the Ratings will be for matching. I tend to get more even matches in the morning before school, during lunch, and after school then during the work day. In the US, many schools ban the use of mobile phones except for those times.
Good to know this, was never sure how this works.

Didn't know it was like that back there in beta, started playing right before beta end, so i only fought few matches on low levels :)

Thanks guys :)
svako wrote:
If someone like PvE and is good at OS raids(no top tier raid for it now, but that will change soon imho), gets higher RPP than someone who dont pay attention to it, getting PvE rewards more quickly, so why dont do the same for people that like PvP?

For starters, I'm a PvP hater (I was against it while they were developing it and the implementation did not change my opinion). When I used to PvP for rewards, I wanted the battles to be as quick as possible. I never gave more than 2 seconds to planning out an attack and I never invested in gems for PvP or bought PvP gear. In fact, I often had PvP up on a second device while I was raiding on the first one.

I managed to get the recipes I needed and some gems for my 4th toon so it could get into the ChV raids. While I technically might have achieved could have gotten the rewards quicker if I tried, I minimized my effort for the rewards. It's kinda like when I used to run CoC with my SW by just spamming the basic attack over and over. It wasn't the best RPP but was really good given the effort I put into it.

Once I reached the point that the PvP rewards were about the same amount of work (even if you tried) as PvE, I quit doing it. I'm undefeated in 2.0. :lol: