M'kay this thread is just a flame war now :/ niet goed so I will leave you with this cause I got it in a fortune cookie and we all know how true they are ^^ you have the power to turn evils to Angels.... Yeah think about it xD
Let's get back on the topic here. Whole point of this thread, I think, was to highlight that SWers *may* be facing a possible disadvantage due to lack of an t19 off-hand weapon upgrade. Let me try to summarize the last ten or so posts.
Dimo raised the following concerns that SW had a couple compensatory mechanisms that offset the above:
1) Urgency, which proc's at 30%, but feels like much more often.
2) Riposte, which proc's at 60%, but also feels like much more often
3) Caltrops, which slows and lowers dodge, lasting for three full seconds
4) Smoke Bomb, which can't be dodged or blocked, and knockbacks the enemy a full 1s.
5) A very high crit rate due to critical eye, and the fastest, highest dps move in the game (reflexive strike)
6) Sticky Grenade, which does the same ability percentage (200%) damage as Justicar's Smite.
7) Deathwish, which increases outgoing damage by 50% while under 25% health
Yvys, I think you misunderstood dimo's concerns a bit. He was concerned more about pvp rather than sw's as a whole.
Yvys brought up the following responses to dimo's concerns regarding swers:
1) Caltrops is very powerful and arguably one of the largest game changers in that it slows, deals damage over time, and lowers opponent's dodge; but because its a necessary part of a SW's arsenal yet resistable, a failed caltrops hurts that much more since it doesn't do any damage on hitting.
2) Riposte may proc 60% of the time, but requires a dodge. So the proc rate is equal to Dodge % * 60%, and when dodge is modified by shard or garrote, riposte will proc very rarely.
3) Grenade might be undodgeable and unresistable, but it does the same damage as smite, except takes 2.5s to land, and while smite gets the benefit of a full justicar's damage, grenade isn't modified by death wish.
4) While deathwish used to be great, damage has gotten so high lately, that the <9k health required to be in dw, doesn't occur as much anymore since wms and justis alike routinely crit for 12-15k+ if well timed.
Also of note, he made the point that in pve, SWers suffer due to the requirement of needing death wish to even compete with justi/wm and still not having the damage dealing potential (maxed sw on dw can't one hit mobs, while justi can by 40-50k might).
So that's where we are. Let's try to keep this thread clean from further flaming and fighting, which I admit - I'm guilty of too.
Cheers.
Eric,
Thank you for the calm and very clear summary of the facts of this thread. Unfortunately, giving too much information clouds some minds and causes the attacks to commence, especially from one individual.
Thanks again! You are a True Master!!