Book of Heroes

Would you like a red whine with that? · page 2

2 observations:

1. The game is complex and developing the game, including events, requires trade offs and decisions. Not every decision will favor you, your style of play, or your conception of how things ought to be done. And less than all of those decisions warrant detailed forum threads.

2. Ouch. Hit that straw man again! I never suggested that all negative commentary was whining.

A side bit of humor: A man goes out for a drive on a beautiful day. The traffic is moving quickly and everything is fine until he sees flashing red lights behind him. He pulls over and a policeman says "Did you know you were going 85 in a 65 zone?" The driver replies "Why pick on me? I was just going with the flow of traffic." The officer responds "I just turned on my lights. You're the one who pulled over."

Illy_the_Red

ModeratorSun Mar 1, 2015 4:14 pm
People already realise those things. Criticism is what drives dynamic development of any product or service. That's why so many companies ask you to rate their service. What a lot of them don't do well is take on board any criticism and treat it as valuable as the favourable comments. If anything, the criticism is more valuable. Being told you're great and everything is awesome may feel good, but it doesn't fuel improvements where they're needed.
Derrin_Watson wrote:2 observations:

1. The game is complex and developing the game, including events, requires trade offs and decisions. Not every decision will favor you, your style of play, or your conception of how things ought to be done. And less than all of those decisions warrant detailed forum threads.

2. Ouch. Hit that straw man again! I never suggested that all negative commentary was whining.

Observations on your observations... ;)

1. Yes it is complex, very, very much so. Most players realise that. Many things that are an awesome concept on the drawing board fail miserably in practice. Many ideas that seem crazy work really well. As a software dev, I can attest to the difficulty of developing and managing a complex piece of software where every user has different (and usually competing...) priorities.
However. Feedback is VITAL. Especially the things that don't work / aren't liked / don't quite work as you envisaged they would. Sure, it's a gutpunch when that great idea you had, that everyone bought into, that you spent all that time on, is universally reviled following deployment - but it's better to know that than to remain in blissful ignorance that all is rosy.
I don't agree at all that "detailed forum threads" aren't necessary. It's the mark of a vibrant, passionate, and involved community that people do this. It's also far better that people don't say "This sucks" on Global, but instead say "This sucks, and this is why..." on a forum where it can be discussed by anyone who cares to weigh in, and is on permanent record for the devs to see.

2. The title for the thread uses "whining", and the OP uses the phrase "whining" in conjunction with what many players consider valid concerns, judging by the responses to existing threads. There is no differentiation between whining and valid negative feedback. I certainly don't feel that any straw man argument was advanced in the responses.
Derrin,

1. If I spent the time, I could dig up a couple of threads where you whined a bunch. I believe one of them was related to the pirate event. I've noticed when you don't like things you whine with the best of them (excluding b rad - he is in another league than the rest of us :lol: ). If things are to your liking or neutral but others are unhappy, you take it out on the other players (like this thread and this isn't the first time either).

2. The BoH forum are minor league as far as whining goes. You should have been on the Zynga forums back in their heyday.
Bbbb wrote:

2. The BoH forum are minor league as far as whining goes. You should have been on the Zynga forums back in their heyday.

The Uken ones were pretty special too. The company even went so far as to remove the forums from the web and incoporate them purely into the apps, so nobody apart from players could access, and thus avoid potential revenue, I mean players, from seeing the bad press ahead of paying, I mean playing.