Book of Heroes

icy grasp and avoid · page 2

It's a question of choices. It's a wm advantage, just like JC has some advantages and SW has some advantages. I honestly am not sure what you are getting at.... If you can't win change your strategy. Ceka has three toons in top 5 all different classes.... it can be done.

Illy_the_Red

ModeratorMon Mar 2, 2015 1:16 pm
Jumper wrote:It's a question of choices. It's a wm advantage, just like JC has some advantages and SW has some advantages. I honestly am not sure what you are getting at.... If you can't win change your strategy. Ceka has three toons in top 5 all different classes.... it can be done.

You're assuming I can't win because I choose to ask for explanations...as it stands it's an inexplicable WM advantage, not OP per se but curious as to why it is how it is. Explanation from devs is not an unreasonable request I'm sure you'll agree.

So I'm honestly not sure what you're getting at either. Jumping (heh) to the defensive is a little rash considering the conversation. Citing Ceka is common in the forums but doesn't support any argument. It just means Ceka has figured out what most of us probably can't (time/resources) or won't figure out: how to beat all three classes with all three.
Ilyana wrote:
Jumper wrote:It's a question of choices. It's a wm advantage, just like JC has some advantages and SW has some advantages. I honestly am not sure what you are getting at.... If you can't win change your strategy. Ceka has three toons in top 5 all different classes.... it can be done.

You're assuming I can't win because I choose to ask for explanations...as it stands it's an inexplicable WM advantage, not OP per se but curious as to why it is how it is. Explanation from devs is not an unreasonable request I'm sure you'll agree.

So I'm honestly not sure what you're getting at either. Jumping (heh) to the defensive is a little rash considering the conversation. Citing Ceka is common in the forums but doesn't support any argument. It just means Ceka has figured out what most of us probably can't (time/resources) or won't figure out: how to beat all three classes with all three.


What I am avoiding here is jumping (heh) on the absurdities of the sw (or other classes)....that's all.... I feel that no matter what the devs will do there will be some sort of imbalance (barring making every class the same...which of course is lame). As I just pointed out above I think it's hilarious that you are picking on icy grasp (which you do ad nauseam in other posts as well) out of all the other wm abilities. (If you had been a clever lady maybe you could have taken this opportunity to jump (heh) on the fact that there are other skills that are more effective/powerful/useful to the wm and call those OP)
Jumper wrote:
Ilyana wrote:
Jumper wrote:It's a question of choices. It's a wm advantage, just like JC has some advantages and SW has some advantages. I honestly am not sure what you are getting at.... If you can't win change your strategy. Ceka has three toons in top 5 all different classes.... it can be done.

You're assuming I can't win because I choose to ask for explanations...as it stands it's an inexplicable WM advantage, not OP per se but curious as to why it is how it is. Explanation from devs is not an unreasonable request I'm sure you'll agree.

So I'm honestly not sure what you're getting at either. Jumping (heh) to the defensive is a little rash considering the conversation. Citing Ceka is common in the forums but doesn't support any argument. It just means Ceka has figured out what most of us probably can't (time/resources) or won't figure out: how to beat all three classes with all three.


What I am avoiding here is jumping (heh) on the absurdities of the sw (or other classes)....that's all.... I feel that no matter what the devs will do there will be some sort of imbalance (barring making every class the same...which of course is lame). As I just pointed out above I think it's hilarious that you are picking on icy grasp (which you do ad nauseam in other posts as well) out of all the other wm abilities. (If you had been a clever lady maybe you could have taken this opportunity to jump (heh) on the fact that there are other skills that are more effective/powerful/useful to the wm and call those OP)
The problem of the wm is much more far reaching that simple skills. just look at a war mages skill set, almost no utility skills.the only utility skill is a slow in the form of frozen shard and apart from that all they revolve around is trying to kill the enemy in 3 hits. how about we first fix that hm? all my battles vs wm as a sw boil down to wether incinerate will hit me for 6k or 16k, wether i will resist his shard and wether i can resist his icy grasp. if 2 of those 3 criteria go in my favor its a guaranteed 100% win. its boring and annoying to play against and offers no variant at all. so instead of just reworking icy grasp they should give mages more utility in form of survivability that isnt rng based (change arcane shield to flat resists) and speed (change snap cast to reduce cast times in certain situations such as low health or after taking x hits or x damage or every x move is casted so and so kuch faster) so that the mage is fun to play as and against and so we can restore some dynamics to pvp.
[quote="BibleThump]

all my battles vs wm as a sw boil down to wether incinerate will hit me for 6k or 16k, wether i will resist his shard and wether i can resist his icy grasp. if 2 of those 3 criteria go in my favor its a guaranteed 100% win.[/quote]


Ah I see.... In masters level there are no 3 hit matches.... that's a non issue . In fact most mages do not rely on one hit kill incinerate. Biblethump the question you are raising is not a overpower damage of the wm, it's a comment on a discussion EricM had relating damge in pvp vs. Hp/resists. Since that was done in another forum post I'll let you find that info for yourself. What you are suggesting is a complete overhaul?
Jump :( I got hit by a 30k might today for a 16k incinerate and two 12k shards :( I thought only Purao was allowed to do that :(
It seems that this problem does still persist in masters and yes im suggesting a complete overhaul.
EricM wrote:Jump :( I got hit by a 30k might today for a 16k incinerate and two 12k shards :( I thought only Purao was allowed to do that :(

hahaha but that was a platinum wm on lucky streak :)

Illy_the_Red

ModeratorMon Mar 2, 2015 3:33 pm
Jumper wrote:
What I am avoiding here is jumping (heh) on the absurdities of the sw (or other classes)....that's all.... I feel that no matter what the devs will do there will be some sort of imbalance (barring making every class the same...which of course is lame). As I just pointed out above I think it's hilarious that you are picking on icy grasp (which you do ad nauseam in other posts as well) out of all the other wm abilities. (If you had been a clever lady maybe you could have taken this opportunity to jump (heh) on the fact that there are other skills that are more effective/powerful/useful to the wm and call those OP)

Oh yay! Someone else who thinks that because the other person is disagreeing with them (in an argument they started) that they are stupid!

I think it's hilarious that you've hijacked the thread to try and divert things away from a simple question of why something is different that doesn't need to be. I fortunately don't reduce myself to attacking the person when the argument won't suffice. I would like to know why the stun is different in casting time, which isn't an unreadable request. Hopefully the devs and now forum mods will act and at least get it back to what the question first asked.

How defensive to assume the person is automatically talking about balance when they ask a simple question. There's a lot of balance questions that have been talked about elsewhere. Not everything is about 'x or y is OP', but then a clever person would realise that.
Are the other two stuns equal? I thought the justi stun was slightly faster than the sw stun. And wm stun is significantly faster than both.