Book of Heroes

Warmage quota in pvp · page 3

Most OP class is played the most :)
I would love to see more JC and SW opponents is P2/P1 tbh... tired of fighting WMs mostly, not because of win/loss ratio, but it takes away the diversity of game...
Kwennie_Mew_Mew wrote:Think it's cause Sw pretty meh early and middle game they are very good late game( max toon) but maybe most don't make it to that cause it's like uphill all the way kinda? That being said i it's like I hate my Sw but love it maybe cause my first toon so all I really know xD I dunno would rather be sw then justi or mage anyday tho

SWs can be very strong in mid game, provided they are spec-ed to either pure melee or pure magic from start.
However, brand new players won't know which path to choose and that results in a weaker SW in mid game.

Take my baby Graviton for an example, i created him in Nov 2013 and decided to make him pure melee. By about 10k might, without much enchantments and elixirs, he was able to get 10 waves in the old CoC p1.
Now he's PM eligible might, he still can kill decently and still get 10 waves at the new CoC p1 and p2.

japster

ModeratorTue Mar 10, 2015 2:58 pm
If they tone WM damage down, we'll never stand a chance against JC at end game pvp.

The problem with the PvP balance right now is that the matchup between classes change across might. WM are undoubtedly strong early and mid, but once everyone gets their status resist and defence up, it becomes a fairly even game of RNG. Which is fine. I have lost to plenty of WM/SW at high might. It's generally even.

But then, you have the JC problem that WMs have, with their 100% resist juggernaut. Without the ability to land any negative statuses on a justicar reliably, end-game JC can gain a HUGE edge over the WM after 2 juggernauts (and end the fight by the time the 3rd juggernaut comes about). At low and mid might, because hp and defence is low, WM can still bulldoze through the enemy JC regardless of juggernaut. At high might (over 60k), it's simply impossible. Often fights are over with the JC barely even scratched because we only get to put some negative statuses only late in the fight after most of the JC has utilised their cooldowns. It's downright depressing and one-sided. I've PvPed long enough at my bracket to know that WM are simply powerless against JC 7 out of 10 fights. And even if we do win, it's usually really close.

Venan needs to look at this carefully. IMO the JC is the problematic class in terms of balance, both for PvP and PvE (all the onslaught complains). To elaborate the PvP aspect, simply put, they are a class that has no slows but relies on knockbacks instead. However, the other 2 classes rely on status resist slows. Therefore an enchanting disparity arises where a JC can adequately protect himself against most other opponents by enchanting defence + status resist (and coupled with their juggernaut), and they gain an upper hand against the other two classes through gearing. Not to forget, JC have inherent class kb resist from Elder Fury. In other words, a JC literally has perfect defensive answers/options. On the other hand, WM and SW do not have that luxury to enchant kb resist without losing either status resist or defence (both of which are equally key in current PvP meta). The opportunity cost to go for kb resist is twice greater because only 1 class is knockback-based. This is obviously an issue of high-might mechanics. SWs aren't as badly hit by this issue because JC knockback attacks are physical, and SWs have an an inherent class ability to dodge (and capitalise on dodges via riposte). WMs on the other hand aren't so fortunate to be able to "avoid"/"mitigate" the knockback-cc of a JC.

IMO, Venan ought to just allow triple enchants and the problem will be resolved at end-game PvP. Alternatively, change Staff Mastery to grant 12% knockback resist instead of giving 12% crit resist.

Illy_the_Red

ModeratorTue Mar 10, 2015 3:57 pm
japster wrote:If they tone WM damage down, we'll never stand a chance against JC at end game pvp.

The problem with the PvP balance right now is that the matchup between classes change across might. WM are undoubtedly strong early and mid, but once everyone gets their status resist and defence up, it becomes a fairly even game of RNG. Which is fine. I have lost to plenty of WM/SW at high might. It's generally even.

But then, you have the JC problem that WMs have, with their 100% resist juggernaut. Without the ability to land any negative statuses on a justicar reliably, end-game JC can gain a HUGE edge over the WM after 2 juggernauts (and end the fight by the time the 3rd juggernaut comes about). At low and mid might, because hp and defence is low, WM can still bulldoze through the enemy JC regardless of juggernaut. At high might (over 60k), it's simply impossible. Often fights are over with the JC barely even scratched because we only get to put some negative statuses only late in the fight after most of the JC has utilised their cooldowns. It's downright depressing and one-sided. I've PvPed long enough at my bracket to know that WM are simply powerless against JC 7 out of 10 fights. And even if we do win, it's usually really close.

Venan needs to look at this carefully. IMO the JC is the problematic class in terms of balance, both for PvP and PvE (all the onslaught complains). To elaborate the PvP aspect, simply put, they are a class that has no slows but relies on knockbacks instead. However, the other 2 classes rely on status resist slows. Therefore an enchanting disparity arises where a JC can adequately protect himself against most other opponents by enchanting defence + status resist (and coupled with their juggernaut), and they gain an upper hand against the other two classes through gearing. Not to forget, JC have inherent class kb resist from Elder Fury. In other words, a JC literally has perfect defensive answers/options. On the other hand, WM and SW do not have that luxury to enchant kb resist without losing either status resist or defence (both of which are equally key in current PvP meta). The opportunity cost to go for kb resist is twice greater because only 1 class is knockback-based. This is obviously an issue of high-might mechanics. SWs aren't as badly hit by this issue because JC knockback attacks are physical, and SWs have an an inherent class ability to dodge (and capitalise on dodges via riposte). WMs on the other hand aren't so fortunate to be able to "avoid"/"mitigate" the knockback-cc of a JC.

IMO, Venan ought to just allow triple enchants and the problem will be resolved at end-game PvP. Alternatively, change Staff Mastery to grant 12% knockback resist instead of giving 12% crit resist.

Triple enchants would be insane unless they dropped transfer costs entirely. Only cash players would bother with PvP in an even worse situation than is current. Plus, not all Justicars are using all-physical attacks, with more and more spirit builds appearing.

SWs suffer inherent class weaknesses vs mages - with a dodge-reliant class, facing enemies with attacks that cannot be fully dodged (spell dodge doesn't even grant you avoidance of status effects, it just reduces damage) is a problem from the outset. SWs need dodge-riposte double procs and resists to really bring the fight to a Mage, otherwise you are sitting waiting for a turn and have lost half your health before you can land a single debuff. With 2H, mages can lay down a lot of damage even if all their debuffs are resisted, which usually keeps them in the fight even if it's going badly.

Essentially you have to hope that the RNG provides you with enough to make the match fair. SWs rely on RNG proc abilities and 'active' debuffs (abilities that have to be cast, that don't do simultaneous damage). This too can be downright depressing and one-sided. Balance issues don't all lie with the class WMs are weakest against, they need to be looked at across the game in an overall rework of PvP. They need to finally separate PvP and PvE abilities so that PvP tweaks (or even throwing out the lot and creating new ones) can be possible without breaking the game elsewhere. PvE issues exist too, Justicars face disadvantages in OS while SWs need to be nearly dead to be competitive. Moot until they being back OS but still an issue.

Capricorn_Rainbucket

Tue Mar 10, 2015 4:33 pm
I'm kinda lost on how a thread about 60% Mages in pvp results in justi being a problem class....I don't get it also if they do 3 enchants atm I throw in the white flag xD
ajusti is more or less fine. its also luck. if you can reaist stunnig and dodge seismic and gain initative you win but the problem with war mage us their randomness. as a sw i can beat 2000 ratig warmages with 10k might on me.and at the same time lose to a random 1600 war mage because he resisted my caltrops crit his frozen crit his incin gg game over. its annoying that playing vs wm is all about surviving and that needs to change. both classes should have equal capability to (in the hands of a good player) recieve and deliver. thats probably also the reason why there are so many wm. id rather cadt 3 moves and win that cast nade caltrops neurotixin garotte, smoke bomb then time an ensnare to drop in a poison blade etc. like i.already said you should remove damage from wm and give them a shitton of utility, that would at the same time fix their problem with justicars. change arcane shield to flat physicial and magical resist, change time void to a spell that delays all opponents buffs for 1 second. change snap cast to 50% less cast time on every x move. i have a heap of ideas that good easily get tested but for some reason nobody wants change
Dayumm, Ily!!
Ilyana wrote:
Triple enchants would be insane unless they dropped transfer costs entirely. Only cash players would bother with PvP in an even worse situation than is current.
This. Triple enchants sound great, until you think about the fact that you're going to need to transfer 27 enchants on average every year with new gear - IF you're already on top tier gear and ignore seasonal Top-tier+1 items like the Tragick T19 swords AND don't use PVP gear. Tfr costs are crippling as it is with a single set of gear, increasing by 50% will cost a lot of players out. Even before double-enchants, many players didn't enchant past lvl 3 until they had top tier, because the rapid gear turnover saw the tfr costs too high. This issue would be exacerbated with triple enchants - who would enchant anything worthwhile before they hit top tier, just to replace it in a few weeks.
Ilyana wrote:
SWs suffer inherent class weaknesses vs mages - with a dodge-reliant class, facing enemies with attacks that cannot be fully dodged (spell dodge doesn't even grant you avoidance of status effects, it just reduces damage) is a problem from the outset.

Yep.
Ilyana wrote:
Balance issues don't all lie with the class WMs are weakest against, they need to be looked at across the game in an overall rework of PvP. They need to finally separate PvP and PvE abilities so that PvP tweaks (or even throwing out the lot and creating new ones) can be possible without breaking the game elsewhere. PvE issues exist too, Justicars face disadvantages in OS while SWs need to be nearly dead to be competitive. Moot until they being back OS but still an issue.
Yes, yes,yes. For the sake of both pvp and pve. Every tweak for the sake of pvp sees more players who don't pvp get pissed off with the changes for something they don't care about, so separating would make pve players happier. And this would allow a specific set of pvp-specific skills to be developed, so pvpers would be happier. And it would allow for easier tweaks when necessary which would make the devs happier.

I give the final word to Arnold.

http://tinyurl.com/k4adla8
Although Tripple enchanting does sound interesting, it sounds very daunting (morefarming...yay)!!!! I do think that triple enchants would actually homogenize the PvP spectrum with everyclass having the same (pretty much) enchants. As it stands there are some KB people, some defense people, some initiative people and some arm pen people. Those little differences do make it a little more interesting. You need to chose who you want to beat.

Now statistically speaking, if people are facing so many mages why aren't people going full magic resist, and defence to counter them. Some people have a bunch of physical resist gems and KB resist and complain they can't beat WM. What happens in a scenario like this should in fact be a disadvantage to the WM as people will be more likely to build in order to beat the WM and sacrifice wins against other classes (effectively weakening the WM class).

As I see it, I don't focus my build on beating melee justies since they are too hard (I do get my lucky wins) I focus more on magic builds (either SW or WM or Spircar) as they do appear more than physical builds. The problem is I suck against physical builds and I live with it.

As an endnote, Beekeo, you don't need to lock this thread just cause Ilyanna and I are here ;)
BibleThump wrote:ajusti is more or less fine. its also luck. if you can reaist stunnig and dodge seismic and gain initative you win but the problem with war mage us their randomness. as a sw i can beat 2000 ratig warmages with 10k might on me.and at the same time lose to a random 1600 war mage because he resisted my caltrops crit his frozen crit his incin gg game over. its annoying that playing vs wm is all about surviving and that needs to change. both classes should have equal capability to (in the hands of a good player) recieve and deliver. thats probably also the reason why there are so many wm. id rather cadt 3 moves and win that cast nade caltrops neurotixin garotte, smoke bomb then time an ensnare to drop in a poison blade etc. like i.already said you should remove damage from wm and give them a shitton of utility, that would at the same time fix their problem with justicars. change arcane shield to flat physicial and magical resist, change time void to a spell that delays all opponents buffs for 1 second. change snap cast to 50% less cast time on every x move. i have a heap of ideas that good easily get tested but for some reason nobody wants change

First of all, there are more WM's than any other class currently due to the fact that when 2.0 came out there were not only the most OP class but they were also the easiest/fastest to might up at the time. It's cute you think that there are more WM due to PvP but that's not the case. PvP is still a "mini game" compared to the grand scheme of BoH.

Secondly, please quit trying to make the WM more like a SW, it's not necessary. I really enjoy readying your and Ily's comments but it's clear that either A, you don't play or have very minimal experience playing with a WM or, B, you don't care to take into consideration other people's ideas/considerations/comments as you think that your opinion is the only one that matters. PvP is about adapting to your opponents. It's impossible to build a spec that works equally across all classes and types, you have to pick a build that works out for the majority of fights(reread jumpers post). WM has been the most nerfed class, for PvE and PvP since 2.0 was released and currently SW is the only class that hasn't received a nerf. I'm not against further "balancing" but it needs to be justified.
Changing one thing about how an ability works changes the entire scheme of the game and will bring further unbalancing to the game and even more problems. What you're upset about sounds more like an RNG problem than an unbalanced class issue. Each class has its strengths and weaknesses, learn how to take advantage of your classes strengths and exploit your opponents weaknesses.

As an aside, if SW were really UP compared to WM we wouldn't see a fairly balanced top 25 and would likely see actual complaining from top tier SW, which we havent, because they have learned to adapt. Take the advice of some long time BoH SW players, try it out, maybe even grow in might some, then come back and tell us how things are going.