I am quite happy with the event!
The event was raid oriented so didn't have to actually destroy the guild's raids schedules. As for the loot, sure t19 gear is nice to have, but honestly the improvement on a toon's performance is negligeable at best compared to T18 (maybe you just want to look good, but on a game level, big whoop). DISCLAIMER: HIGHER LEVEL WEAPONS ARE A DIFFERENT BALL GAME!!!!!!! I am talking boots and pants.
I did find the price a little excessive for a lockbox (as finn mentioned above, 50e for not even 1 lockbox, and you end up with 10k silver is disheartening). I did like the elixirs though! I treated the lockboxes as just bonus loot, so better than nothing. The only worthwhile drops were the T19 gear, elixirs and 500gs. The rest 10k silver, 100k silver, 1gs, were just a pittance (I didn't even get a SHAMrock this year...lol) This event was clearly not one worth burning for, but the fact that it didn't affect raids made it fine by me!
I can see as a noob player, 10k and 100k silver is great!!!! That would help tremendously (opening gem slots, buying gems and equipment, etc). Most complaints seem to come from end game players wanting the extra 100 might from the gear
I personally got the t19 kilt from a lockbox (I opened maybe 25 lockboxes, so got lucky) However, I am not wasting the mats or gs to enchant the thing. The real outrage here are transfer costs (but that's for another thread)
