Book of Heroes

Overhaul of raid timers

In the past, I've noticed that one poor raid that runs past gold time can screw up regen for following raids and cause a chain reaction resulting in either cancellation of a future raid or just a day full of back to back slow raids. That's when I came up with a brilliant idea (in my opinion - ha).

Currently, raids have x amount of waves that needed to be completed in a certain amount of time for gold, silver, bronze. What if, instead, the raids lasted for x amount of time, and needed a certain amount of waves to be complete for gold, silver, bronze?

Example:
In the current system, LoB has 1800 waves. Gold is 125 min. Silver is 180 min. Bronze is 270 min. Failure is >270 min.

Under my proposed system, LoB would automatically end at 125 min (or when all 1800 waves were complete). Gold would be if the guild reaches all 1800 waves in the allotted time. Silver would be if the guild completes at least 1250 waves in the allotted time. Bronze would be if the guild completes 833 waves in the allotted time. Failure would be if the guild fails to complete >833 waves.


So what is the proposed benefit of such a system? For starters, this wouldn't screw up a guild's scheduling. An active guild could happily schedule raids every 2-4 hours, and be content that raids wouldn't push into one another. But by far the largest benefit of this system, one that would warrant the difficulty in switching over - would be that high tier raids would no longer require 50-60+ people dumping full bars to COMPLETE. They would still require the same waves in gold time to get GOLD rewards, but by making things based off wave count and not time, smaller guilds could access higher level raids (if they are content with a guaranteed silver/bronze) while decreasing the effect skunk mercs have on them.

Too often now I've seen lower ranked guilds over-extend to attempt a LoB... and even with full mercs, they'll be nearly four hours in, 10 min from failure, with 10% left in the raid... by this point everyone is utterly dejected as gold and silver time went by, 50 people are in the raid, and no one is going to get any rewards.

Thoughts?
+1

I like this idea. There can also be a wave count so you can see how many waves have been hit and how much more you need for gold/silver/bronze completion.
EricM wrote:In the past, I've noticed that one poor raid that runs past gold time can screw up regen for following raids and cause a chain reaction resulting in either cancellation of a future raid or just a day full of back to back slow raids. That's when I came up with a brilliant idea (in my opinion - ha).

Currently, raids have x amount of waves that needed to be completed in a certain amount of time for gold, silver, bronze. What if, instead, the raids lasted for x amount of time, and needed a certain amount of waves to be complete for gold, silver, bronze?

Example:
In the current system, LoB has 1800 waves. Gold is 125 min. Silver is 180 min. Bronze is 270 min. Failure is >270 min.

Under my proposed system, LoB would automatically end at 125 min (or when all 1800 waves were complete). Gold would be if the guild reaches all 1800 waves in the allotted time. Silver would be if the guild completes at least 1250 waves in the allotted time. Bronze would be if the guild completes 833 waves in the allotted time. Failure would be if the guild fails to complete >833 waves.


So what is the proposed benefit of such a system? For starters, this wouldn't screw up a guild's scheduling. An active guild could happily schedule raids every 2-4 hours, and be content that raids wouldn't push into one another. But by far the largest benefit of this system, one that would warrant the difficulty in switching over - would be that high tier raids would no longer require 50-60+ people dumping full bars to COMPLETE. They would still require the same waves in gold time to get GOLD rewards, but by making things based off wave count and not time, smaller guilds could access higher level raids (if they are content with a guaranteed silver/bronze) while decreasing the effect skunk mercs have on them.

Too often now I've seen lower ranked guilds over-extend to attempt a LoB... and even with full mercs, they'll be nearly four hours in, 10 min from failure, with 10% left in the raid... by this point everyone is utterly dejected as gold and silver time went by, 50 people are in the raid, and no one is going to get any rewards.

Thoughts?


I see one con. Farming LoB os was a good way to earn cheap essence/flux/HS. So with a bunch of alts, and a deadish guild, we could power through p1 and then slowly plow away at OS. These were also great to test builds, try most kills per 10e....etc. Plus with your proposed system, solo LoB is impossible ;p

On a more serious level. As it stands, the later phases of raids (KFS, LoB, CV, and PM) payout more than p1. So the "silver" guilds wouldn't get the benefit of getting the full essence potential from that raid. I never mind joining a bronze raid cause really all the game depends on is Essence farming in the endgame. As for a guild like fizz.... come on eric! as if you just can't cancel a CV and carry on schedule as usual after that if a PM goes long :)
Jumper wrote: As for a guild like fizz.... come on eric! as if you just can't cancel a CV and carry on schedule as usual after that if a PM goes long :)

:lol: :lol: :lol:
Maybe just an option to run raids in either wave mode or time mode as I understand both sides of this. The time limit would prevent burnout of a neverending raid.
Bbbb wrote:Maybe just an option to run raids in either wave mode or time mode as I understand both sides of this. The time limit would prevent burnout of a neverending raid.
Great idea Eric! It would really help make the game better for many guilds, but as b4 says, giving it as an option when you start a raid would give the best of both worlds. Chop chop Venan :-)