Book of Heroes

RNG- PvP · page 4

Bj_Knows

ModeratorThu Mar 26, 2015 12:12 pm
_ACID_ wrote:
Jumper wrote:
I'm not exactly sure how you figure they are "making" the win rate 50%. It is simply a consequence of how ranking systems work. There is no ELO making you lose!
Beeks admitted it in pvp chat, I have a screenshot of it... When I can get to a pc or laptop I'll upload it here and show you

I don't know how this BoH Urban Legend persists. This is from more than six months ago:

I Quit- PvP Bad

Illy_the_Red

ModeratorThu Mar 26, 2015 2:29 pm
It persists because of lack of information. I've seen enough to know 'it's just Elo' is not a sufficient explanation. The way losing streaks and (the lack of) winning streaks to compensate work makes people believe this. Dev responses on this were all over the place at first and then suddenly were all on the same line. It's Elo. Don't delve any further. I remember seeing what Acid mentioned in multiple chats.

Some players in masters have good enough gear/gems/enchants/skill, in combination, to pull their win rates up to crazy levels and become the genuine best. Other masters bounce in and out of the league with regularity. So most people are still at the mercy of the '50/50' Elo effect and don't have sufficiently high enchants/gems etc to mostly eliminate RNG from their matches. We would all love to be like you Ceka but most people find PvP incredibly challenging (or frustrating).

Like Amy said, it's not that RNG exists per se, it's that it has such a huge effect on matches for the majority of people. PvP is not about masters or even platinum only. It's about the experience for the whole community.

Personally the best suggestion made to combat RNG I remember hearing was that enchants such as stat resist should work as a percentage, rather than a resist/don't resist in the same way defence and knockback resist work now. For example if a Justicar doesn't have jugg up and his opponent throws caltrops, his SR deducts a large percentage of the effect if he has it high. If he responds with jugg, he ignores 100% of it and is therefore unaffected.

Can't remember whose idea this was, but kudos to them as it had genuine promise (not sure how the details would work, but that's not for us to worry about).
Ilyana wrote:

Personally the best suggestion made to combat RNG I remember hearing was that enchants such as stat resist should work as a percentage, rather than a resist/don't resist in the same way defence and knockback resist work now. For example if a Justicar doesn't have jugg up and his opponent throws caltrops, his SR deducts a large percentage of the effect if he has it high. If he responds with jugg, he ignores 100% of it and is therefore unaffected.

Can't remember whose idea this was, but kudos to them as it had genuine promise (not sure how the details would work, but that's not for us to worry about).

That suggestion came from BibleThumper, in a thread that got deleted.
I did a proper response at the time but that got deleted along with the thread and I can't be arsed writing it all out again!
Synopsis was that a casting player would have no idea what impact a status attack would have (Will my Stun last 1s or 0.19s? Will my Caltrops slow 20% or 5%?) unless they knew the player, and at higher levels with high SR, status attacks would be a mere irritant rather than a danger.
Whether any of that would be a good or bad thing is up to the people who PvP - I see it as putting power firmly on the side of the defender against statuses, and relegating such attacks to near-irrelevance. It'd certainly change things.
Ilyana wrote:It persists because of lack of information. I've seen enough to know 'it's just Elo' is not a sufficient explanation. The way losing streaks and (the lack of) winning streaks to compensate work makes people believe this.



Wrong....people just don't comment on their winning streaks.

I'll use Garic just as an example...only because he is one of the few that I have watched....he is exactly in the same range as he has been for the last 2 months...between rank 15-50 (give or take). He regularly complains about how it it's broken and he only loses...yet he has massive number of fights and is still in the range. People just don't complain when they are on a winning streak.
What its trully make the pvp more random its the double enchant. Before most of player got defense enchant with no resist enchant. But now all the player have defense+ resist so... Maybe just come back to 1 enchant.... But with 1 enchant and no resist enchant , wm will be too op. -_-

Hard for a dev to balance everything and make everyone happy ... :/
Just come back to pvp beta i guess :D no elo, no double enchant, no ranking, no title. I saw many ppl complain about the ratings too :D
Garic..it could only comment on you, amy & hansreudi..your the only.ones I watch. I would have preferred to use illyana as she had actually commented on this post..though I wouldn't have a clue of her toons progress and I didn't want the thread deleted.
Sàlád_ wrote:....Campers in masters

*In my very best Macho Man Randy Savage voice*
Its time to quit roasting your wienies around the camp fire like a gaggle of girl scouts. Time to meet Tapzilla on the arena floor where I will body slam you like I did to Hulk Hogan back in the 80's. OOOOOOOOH YEEEEAAAAA!! SNAP INTO A SLIM JIM!"