Putting a password on a raid, or on a guild is something no one likes. .... If we password protect raids, no one will join either cause they have no clue who to whisper for the password.
This was in a locked thread, but had nothing to do with locking. I completely disagree with this statement. There are many good reasons to password protect raids:
1. At Kingdom, when we have a password, it is to let members bring in their alts and not mercs.
2. Some guilds have fixed passwords. Many of us know what the password is because we were given it as a trusted party with the understanding to not give it out to bad mercs. As long as the guild gets decent mercs, the password stays the same. This works much better than you would expect and the passwords are rarely changed. To expose one that doesn't matter anymore, the Spoons password was frequently "shadow" for a long time.
3. For those of us who are regular mercs, we usually know who to whisper. That's sort of the point.
I think most of your objections have more to do with KOTOR running mostly closed raids for so long and being disconnected from the community at large. You don't have the social connections to deal with password protected raids.
Final thought: what is a closed raid but a password protected raid where nobody knows the password?