Book of Heroes

Raid Passwords


Putting a password on a raid, or on a guild is something no one likes. .... If we password protect raids, no one will join either cause they have no clue who to whisper for the password.

This was in a locked thread, but had nothing to do with locking. I completely disagree with this statement. There are many good reasons to password protect raids:

1. At Kingdom, when we have a password, it is to let members bring in their alts and not mercs.
2. Some guilds have fixed passwords. Many of us know what the password is because we were given it as a trusted party with the understanding to not give it out to bad mercs. As long as the guild gets decent mercs, the password stays the same. This works much better than you would expect and the passwords are rarely changed. To expose one that doesn't matter anymore, the Spoons password was frequently "shadow" for a long time.
3. For those of us who are regular mercs, we usually know who to whisper. That's sort of the point.

I think most of your objections have more to do with KOTOR running mostly closed raids for so long and being disconnected from the community at large. You don't have the social connections to deal with password protected raids.

Final thought: what is a closed raid but a password protected raid where nobody knows the password?

Doctor_Love_Money_Shot

Tue Mar 31, 2015 1:04 am
Bbbb wrote:

Putting a password on a raid, or on a guild is something no one likes. .... If we password protect raids, no one will join either cause they have no clue who to whisper for the password.

This was in a locked thread, but had nothing to do with locking. I completely disagree with this statement. There are many good reasons to password protect raids:

1. At Kingdom, when we have a password, it is to let members bring in their alts and not mercs.
2. Some guilds have fixed passwords. Many of us know what the password is because we were given it as a trusted party with the understanding to not give it out to bad mercs. As long as the guild gets decent mercs, the password stays the same. This works much better than you would expect and the passwords are rarely changed. To expose one that doesn't matter anymore, the Spoons password was frequently "shadow" for a long time.
3. For those of us who are regular mercs, we usually know who to whisper. That's sort of the point.

I think most of your objections have more to do with KOTOR running mostly closed raids for so long and being disconnected from the community at large. You don't have the social connections to deal with password protected raids.

Final thought: what is a closed raid but a password protected raid where nobody knows the password?

The reason Kotor opens raids is to let new people experience our raids and have the reliability of a gold raid. I agree with your reasons for having a password or let in your friends and trusted mercs. That works in your situation. Our situation is to extend opportunities to new people who we don't already know so they can enjoy our raid experience. So while we want to let new people in, we also have no way of knowing who will be a Deadbeat. However, we do know of a few deadbeats we would like to keep out, hence the request for the Blacklist. Why punish everyone who might join by using a password, just to keep out the handful who have no respect or decency.
Juggernaut_Money_Shot wrote:
The reason Kotor opens raids is to let new people experience our raids and have the reliability of a gold raid.

At this stage, gold is a mixed blessing at best at the top level. Give me a bronze to milk essence any day instead. :D

You can see my support for the blacklist in other threads. However, reading between the lines, Venan is not in favor of it.
DjCleric wrote:I still have a raid report of a KOTOR's BRONZE PM. :lol:

That's one worth framing up!

Fizz likes to bronze raids for fun too sometimes :D

You know... just to keep things fresh. ;)

Doctor_Love_Money_Shot

Thu Apr 2, 2015 12:56 am
Venan has repeatedly said they don't know how to allow for booting of mercs without people getting hurt/upset and guilds abusing the privilege. This is despite the many suggestions given them, some of which sound very reasonable.

However, venan never seems to address the idea of a blacklist. They don't seem to find anything bad to say about it. And this is such a passive measure, nobody will lose rpp or burn gs before being booted. This is simply a selective password if you will, but one that favors 99.9% of the boh community, and only affects the people who have lost the privilege of raiding where they have run afoul of common decency and respect.

Venan, please tell us what you have against a blacklist. You are so quick to tell us to use the password and exclude the masses. Why will you not allow us to only exclude the very few?
EricM wrote:
DjCleric wrote:I still have a raid report of a KOTOR's BRONZE PM. :lol:

That's one worth framing up!

Fizz likes to bronze raids for fun too sometimes :D

You know... just to keep things fresh. ;)

KOTOR's one more worth framing as they uber rarely open their raids to public. :)