Book of Heroes

Feature Request - ban mercs from joining guild raids · page 2

Recently I have applauded the devs, they've made excellent decisions, great events, sorted things quickly... HOWEVER, this is one issue every player will not be happy with regarding your decision. If you played the game more, you'd understand a lot of our frustrations. I personally find it infuriating having people one or two hits. I've had warnings from people about my use of language in guild because of deadbeats. The password DOES NOT WORK. I hope you take that on board. Sort it out please
I think 99% of GMs, officers and good players are supportive of adding this feature.

The password is effective for letting alts or trusted regular mercs in, but is a failure for the skunk merc problem. Run a few raids where you have to hand out the password to every merc - you'll discover how bad that solution is especially if your guild is running 4-6 raids a day.
Juggernaut_Money_Shot wrote:Why did bj have to ruin this post by changing the title so no one knows what it is really about? Put it back heavy handed bj.


In a response to the current thread title, this feature has already been included in the game. Please set your mercenary slots to 0 for every raid that you are running in your guild. 8-)

Doctor_Love_Money_Shot

Sun Apr 5, 2015 8:31 am
CheMClarc wrote:
DreamingDæmon wrote:

The reason being, 99.9% of the mercs out there are of a good quality. Sure, every now and again, one will score low due to circumstances happening, but those are rare occasions for each, and they do not a skunk merc make.

The problem is that 0.1% of mercs who deliberately and repeatedly target other guilds' raids, take up one or more limited places, and deliberately do precisely nothing.
This is the main reason why you have not seen a feature implemented to remove or prevent players from joining your raid. Password protecting your raids prevents most of the issues you are concerned with. It might not be something that some players are a fan of but it is effective if used. If you do not want to use the feature than you may get players that do not perform to your standards in your raid.

That being said, there is always room for improvement on how to prevent this type of behavior and give Guilds more control in future updates. For the time being, please put your raid schedule in your guild description for players to view and be aware of, post ads during the raids to attract players and password protect them to avoid troublemakers.

So what you're saying is that you want us to do what we already do, posting our schedule in our description, and you want us all to ADD SPAM TO GLOBAL by regularly posting about our raids with paswords instead of just letting them fill quickly with quality mercs. You admit there is room for improvement, but you have not made a change to this issue for several years, despite the repeated complaints in the forums and in game chats. You persist in telling us to use passwords when we have all told you REPEATEDLY that passwords are a TERRIBLE way to manage our raids. But you don't seem to understand that we actually know what we are talking about, because we actually play the game AND manage guilds in the game. I'm sure you probably play a toon in the game every now and then, but you clearly haven't experienced the immense frustration the rest of us keep dealing with on a daily basis. We are blatantly telling you, THE PASSWORD IS NOT THE SOLUTION. Please stop treating us like idiots and telling us to use passowrds over and over again.

Blacklist is the solution. Give us a timeline for implementation please.

Shë_Wølf_Ãrî

Mon Apr 6, 2015 1:57 pm
Example: I had a merc that constantly came to raids, to both cause trouble in guild chat as well as tried to skunk a few raids. I did as suggested to me and passworded the raids that he would most commonly join, or if I saw him on global.

Point one: If I would have iggied this person along with my guild, we wouldn't have known to pw some raids.
Point two: Passwording the raids we got less mercs, even with having schedule on guild wall and posting raid ads in global channels.We also went from having gold raids on these raids to silver raids. And a few times had to ask for help from friends and burn to make sure we at least silvered the raid.

Main point: Guilds have no way to defend themselves from mouthy rude mercs, or from mercs that purposely try to skunk their raids or are just bad mercs.

Note: I'm all for putting people on iggy, it can solve many problems of annoyance. And I'm proud of my guild that they would not respond to this particular merc, or others that in the past tried to cause problems. But iggy is not always a viable solution in some cases when some would bad mouth other people in merc chat as well as global c h annels. You can't report them if you can't see them. And you can't make everyone in your guild iggy someone. And then hope they do it.

And for growing guilds I think it is unfair to ask them to close or password raids and to punish the good mercs that might otherwise join the raid
Shë_Wølf_Ãrî wrote:Example: I had a merc that constantly came to raids, to both cause trouble in guild chat as well as tried to skunk a few raids. I did as suggested to me and passworded the raids that he would most commonly join, or if I saw him on global.

Point one: If I would have iggied this person along with my guild, we wouldn't have known to pw some raids.
Point two: Passwording the raids we got less mercs, even with having schedule on guild wall and posting raid ads in global channels.We also went from having gold raids on these raids to silver raids. And a few times had to ask for help from friends and burn to make sure we at least silvered the raid.

Main point: Guilds have no way to defend themselves from mouthy rude mercs, or from mercs that purposely try to skunk their raids or are just bad mercs.

Note: I'm all for putting people on iggy, it can solve many problems of annoyance. And I'm proud of my guild that they would not respond to this particular merc, or others that in the past tried to cause problems. But iggy is not always a viable solution in some cases when some would bad mouth other people in merc chat as well as global c h annels. You can't report them if you can't see them. And you can't make everyone in your guild iggy someone. And then hope they do it.

And for growing guilds I think it is unfair to ask them to close or password raids and to punish the good mercs that might otherwise join the raid
+ 1 billion

Doctor_Love_Money_Shot

Mon Apr 6, 2015 6:09 pm
Shë_Wølf_Ãrî wrote:Example: I had a merc that constantly came to raids, to both cause trouble in guild chat as well as tried to skunk a few raids. I did as suggested to me and passworded the raids that he would most commonly join, or if I saw him on global.

Point one: If I would have iggied this person along with my guild, we wouldn't have known to pw some raids.
Point two: Passwording the raids we got less mercs, even with having schedule on guild wall and posting raid ads in global channels.We also went from having gold raids on these raids to silver raids. And a few times had to ask for help from friends and burn to make sure we at least silvered the raid.

Main point: Guilds have no way to defend themselves from mouthy rude mercs, or from mercs that purposely try to skunk their raids or are just bad mercs.

Note: I'm all for putting people on iggy, it can solve many problems of annoyance. And I'm proud of my guild that they would not respond to this particular merc, or others that in the past tried to cause problems. But iggy is not always a viable solution in some cases when some would bad mouth other people in merc chat as well as global c h annels. You can't report them if you can't see them. And you can't make everyone in your guild iggy someone. And then hope they do it.

And for growing guilds I think it is unfair to ask them to close or password raids and to punish the good mercs that might otherwise join the raid

I couldn't have said it any better. But venan still doesn't comprehend these points, and understand that passwording raids and guilds is NOT the solution.
I am completely offended my guild has been mentioned by name. Please lock this thread immediately!

Oh have you guys seen there is now a Nutella milkshake available at Steak n' Shake?