Book of Heroes

200 guild members · page 2

BP_got_smashed_on_3_toons_by_

Sun Apr 12, 2015 11:42 am
Rezel wrote:The pm raid is hard for guilds to do in gold time even with 35 mercs spaces open, if we could have 200 members in a guild at one time it would encourage merges and strengthen guilds from the top downwards. More raids would be finish gold, I can't see a down side but I'm sure someone will point one out.

Yep its a very hard raid to do - 10 mins 8 seconds!!!!
Why? There's not a single guild in the top 60 that's full. And scaling the raids for 200 members will make them even more tedious than they are now.
The top however many guilds have 200+ "toons" officers have to "clean house" several times a day.

Illy_the_Red

ModeratorSun Apr 12, 2015 6:09 pm
People said expanding guilds from 60 to 100 would be bad, and it seems fine (guild loyalty a downside to the changes at the time). A lot of guilds ended then and yet everyone continued somehow. I suspect expanding guilds again would lead to less guilds like it did before. With some at the top now covering 200ish toons, it might be time to look at it again.
How many guilds actually have the 200 toons? There are only 2 I'm sure about. To be honest, I don't understand why players put up with all that hassle and the resulting loss of energy. It's extra work on the officers too.

At Kingdom since all we pretty run is PM, we just have a second guild were players can park extra toons. You all have your full 50e that way all the time. Sure we are taking an enormous power hit in the standings, but it is better for the players.

If it was increased, those same guilds would just then try to have 300 toons. The pro-increase side will keep arguing for more and more increases until we end up with one guild......
I agree that's a problem. Megaguilds are not the way to go. As b4 mentioned less opportunity to merc and less raids overall. The variety of different guilds keeps the game interesting.

WAIT!!! Lets make BoH one big guild!

Wølfÿ_Thè_Lïttlè_Føx

Mon Apr 13, 2015 1:38 pm
Jumper wrote:
WAIT!!! Lets make BoH one big guild!






May I ask, Who would be the owner of this guild and who would be officers and veterans?

Illy_the_Red

ModeratorMon Apr 13, 2015 2:25 pm
There are plenty that have well over 100 toons that are regularly being rotated in/out, or being used to hit from other lower guilds.

Most don't want to hit their Power only running PM. There are toons below 36,200k that want in on good raids. Yet more guilds don't have a full 100 roster but struggle with the newest raids which seem deliberately very difficult challenges for your average guild. Without OS the two GV raids need 50 toons ish to even finish with a middling result, and usually need some kind of burning to get good results. I know some don't need valour so aren't bothered by silver/bronze, but most do.