Mercs or open raids should not be abused. They are both a privilege and a necessity for the game. We must take multiple factors into consideration and still exerecise a fair justice system. We do not know what is going on the other side of the screen. Mercs could be single parents, emergency workers, on-call workers, have busy schedules, something unexpected happens, WiFi goes out, etc. We all understand and accept those RL instances. We need to truly differentiate them from the people who ruin the fun of this great game.
For some, they don't care what happens. It's a casual game. For others, however, they invest time and money into this game. We have encountered people here whom we have become personal or friendly with over the years. For some people, this casual game is much more than casual. That is more so the truth for GMs who have a long-standing or thriving guild full of people depending on them.
Sure we could argue that Venan does not care about our plight because they want us to spend more GS to burn e-pots in raids. On the flip side, many of us have quit the game for an extended period of time, or permanently for some players, because of our frustration over certain unresolved matters. That offers no financial benefit for Venan.
Perhaps an easier solution would be to set an RPP minimum per non-OS raids AND phases after the first phase of each raid. If the minimum is not met, the toon's name will appear in a different color. If a player becomes the ominous color x-amount of times for the same guild, then they are automatically disallowed from joining that guild's raids for a certain period of time. If a merc earns that color from multiple guilds, then they earn a 'special' color ... Maybe even one that appears in chats. So other players can teach them better, and GMs can see which of their own members are causing trouble in the community. The GM or an Officer could remove a tainted merc from the raid, or the guild, so another player can take their place.
That way (1) weaker players are not penalized if they cannot score a massive RPP like some players can in OS; (2) guild leadership cannot arbitrarily remove mercs; (3) mercs securing a spot in P1 for a later OS phase cannot be removed; (4) deadbeat mercs can no longer hide in a sea of grayed-out names; (5) RL comes first, so mercs who suddenly stop hitting or do not meet the minimum RPP, will not lose everything for their contributions- they can still receive what they would have earned at the raid's end; and (6) some mercs burn heavily early in a raid because they know they cannot stay for the duration of the raid. They can be removed from a struggling raid to allow for more help to enter, but they lose no raid benefits, and they do not change color because they met the overall raid RPP requirement. It could be set up that guilds lose a nominal amount of prestige, too, to prevent wonton misuse of removal rights.
Criteria on both ends will have to be established. Guildmates do not mind putting forth extra effort to help their guild, but not everybody can burn or burn a lot, especially the minor children who play. All of us, however, who are "here to stay" have the obligation to make this a great game. Game reviews and what is said in chat can ultimately impact the players and the devs. It is up to the community as a whole to help make it a positive and beneficial impact. If players' names change colors, it because of what they did to themselves, not what the game or another player did to them.
For some, they don't care what happens. It's a casual game. For others, however, they invest time and money into this game. We have encountered people here whom we have become personal or friendly with over the years. For some people, this casual game is much more than casual. That is more so the truth for GMs who have a long-standing or thriving guild full of people depending on them.
Sure we could argue that Venan does not care about our plight because they want us to spend more GS to burn e-pots in raids. On the flip side, many of us have quit the game for an extended period of time, or permanently for some players, because of our frustration over certain unresolved matters. That offers no financial benefit for Venan.
Perhaps an easier solution would be to set an RPP minimum per non-OS raids AND phases after the first phase of each raid. If the minimum is not met, the toon's name will appear in a different color. If a player becomes the ominous color x-amount of times for the same guild, then they are automatically disallowed from joining that guild's raids for a certain period of time. If a merc earns that color from multiple guilds, then they earn a 'special' color ... Maybe even one that appears in chats. So other players can teach them better, and GMs can see which of their own members are causing trouble in the community. The GM or an Officer could remove a tainted merc from the raid, or the guild, so another player can take their place.
That way (1) weaker players are not penalized if they cannot score a massive RPP like some players can in OS; (2) guild leadership cannot arbitrarily remove mercs; (3) mercs securing a spot in P1 for a later OS phase cannot be removed; (4) deadbeat mercs can no longer hide in a sea of grayed-out names; (5) RL comes first, so mercs who suddenly stop hitting or do not meet the minimum RPP, will not lose everything for their contributions- they can still receive what they would have earned at the raid's end; and (6) some mercs burn heavily early in a raid because they know they cannot stay for the duration of the raid. They can be removed from a struggling raid to allow for more help to enter, but they lose no raid benefits, and they do not change color because they met the overall raid RPP requirement. It could be set up that guilds lose a nominal amount of prestige, too, to prevent wonton misuse of removal rights.
Criteria on both ends will have to be established. Guildmates do not mind putting forth extra effort to help their guild, but not everybody can burn or burn a lot, especially the minor children who play. All of us, however, who are "here to stay" have the obligation to make this a great game. Game reviews and what is said in chat can ultimately impact the players and the devs. It is up to the community as a whole to help make it a positive and beneficial impact. If players' names change colors, it because of what they did to themselves, not what the game or another player did to them.