I've seen this before, but today was especially brutal. Nobody raids because they spent all their e on dungeon farming.... Of course, Werechef is probably be just as fatal - last thing guilds needs right now.....
Dungeon Destroyer = Raid Destroyer
DELETED
If all the guilds die there won't be any pm raids to merc... It's not guild power we care about, but instead, being able to raid when we have some time to play. If you belong to a strong guild it allows many raids to be run throughout the day. When we all belong to a dead guild the game will officially be dead.
DELETED
You keep raids closed because a gold closed raid pays the best return of valor. Kingdom would run closed, like any guild, if they could assure gold in house. I'd be fine with abolishing guilds so long as the alternative works better. We saw the success (by that I mean fail) of public higher level raids. Perhaps with no guilds that wouldn't be a problem. While guilds aren't perfect at least they enable people to be part of something with a common purpose, whether that's guild power, chasing valor, or whatever. In the current environment, my original statement stands, if we all belong to dead guilds the game will be dead.
Bimbosigliere wrote: Take Kingdom, they have no allusions, they run PM full open from the start. And even though their raids fluctuate wildly between gold and sometimes even a fail,
Actually, almost fail.... Usually, someone (e.g. Derrin and Amy) will bail us out near the end.
Personally I think the dungeon destroyer quests are great. It's not forcing us into PvP and isn't just another quest that can be done while raiding. We get to see dungeons we haven't seen for a long while.
It doesn't matter what the event/weekend is, unless it invoices valour or essence it will hurt raids to a greater or lesser extent.
It doesn't matter what the event/weekend is, unless it invoices valour or essence it will hurt raids to a greater or lesser extent.
Simple fix...take away the closed raid bonus, and remove the merc caps. (Just have and overall cap on the number of people in a raid of 100). Simple fix. Leave the guild power gain calculations alone, and just allow a raid to be "open" or "closed."
B I don't mean to only turn up at the end, my schedule just makes it that way 
OMG!!! I totally agree with Ilyana!!