Book of Heroes

Idea: Server Disconnect/ Server Lag (Brainstorm)

Bj_Knows

ModeratorSat Jul 14, 2012 6:46 pm
Subject:
Idea: Raids Mechanics: Server Disconnect/ Server Lag (Brainstorm)

Sometimes you have problems with 3G/WiFi or server lag. These are some suggestions/ brainstorms for improving the Raid In Game Mechanic to help deal with these issues:

Staying in Raid
I think it would help, if characters stayed in Raids when disconnected instead of having to reenter the Raid. If you were disconnected, your RPP bonus would be capped at +140 RPP. Ex: If your RPP bonus was +150 RPP, and you were disconnected, you would remain in the Raid, but with a +140 RPP when you reconnected.

Pausing Raid
Since there is already a cancel button for Raids, perhaps a pause button. Above the pause button would be listed the total number of pauses left in the Raid and the time remaining on the pause. I would recommend a total of 1 pause lasting no more than 24 hours. This should be sufficient for local 3G/WiFi to be repaired, or for excessive server lag to be resolved.

Maybe 1 pause for each Phase of the Raid lasting ( 24 Hours/ Number of Phases ). Ex: Each of the 3 pauses in a 3 Phase Raid could last up to 8 hours for a total of 24 hours.

Retry- Guild Officers
If a Raid fails, the Guild Master or Guild Officers, would have two options for that Raid, New Raid or Retry.

Retry- Guild Master
If a Raid fails, the Guild Master would have two options for that Raid, New Raid or Retry. Guild Officers would only have the option of New Raid.

Retry- Guild Master Choice
If a Raid fails, the Guild Master would pick "Wait for Retry" or "Wait for New Raid". When the Raid had cooled down, the Guild Master or Guild Officer could start the Raid, but the type of Raid, Retry or New, would already have been selected by the Guild Master.

Retry- Save Point
If the Guild picked Retry, it would start at the beginning of the last phase it completed 100%. Ex: Helion is 4 Phases, if the Guild completed Phase 3 for 100%, when retrying, it would start at the beginning of Phase 3 for 0%.

The time to complete the Raid would be a percentage of the time based on the percentage of the total Raid. Ex: If the three phases of a Raid were 30%, 40% & 30% of the total Raid, then skipping Phase 1 would reduce the time of the Raid by 30%, while skipping Phase 1-2 would reduce the time by 70% of normal. However, the Raid cool down would be increased by the missing time. Ex: if the Retry Raid was 60 minutes shorter that the New Raid, then 60 minutes would be added to the Raid's cool down.

Retry- Forward Motion
If the Guild picked Retry, it would start at the end of the last phase it completed 100%. Ex: Helion is 4 Phases, if the Guild completed Phase 2 for 100%, when retrying, it would start at the beginning of Phase 3 for 0%.

Retry- Total Raid
If the Guild picked Retry, the current attempt would start at 50% of the last attempt's total Raid. Ex: If the last Raid got to a total of 80% of the Raid, then the Retry would start at 40% of the total Raid.

Retry- Total Raids, Last 3
If the Guild picked Retry, the current attempt would start at the average of the last three failed attempts. Ex: If the last four Raids were 30%, 75%, 100%, 80% Total completion, then the average of the failed Raids would be 62% (30 + 75 + 80). The Retry Raid would start at 62% of Total Raid.
BjofCJandBj wrote:I think it would help, if characters stayed in Raids when disconnected instead of having to reenter the Raid.
Agreed so far.
BjofCJandBj wrote:If you were disconnected, your RPP bonus would be capped at +140 RPP. Ex: If your RPP bonus was +150 RPP, and you were disconnected, you would remain in the Raid, but with a +140 RPP when you reconnected.
No. Currently, Venan has a problem with a "process drop," as I understand it, when people are disconnected; the same applies to the fact that one may switch characters without repercussions within a raid as long as one is in combat and not at a victory screen. This is an unintended technical byproduct and not a deliberate design decision. What you are proposing is an enshrinement of a penalty to people with faulty connexions as a design decision. I prefer a technical glitch that may ultimately be solved, even if it results in lower RPP at present.
BjofCJandBj wrote:Pausing Raid
...and everything that follows: no. The ability to pause a raid is directly contrary to the purpose of raids: measuring a guild's ability to get a certain number of people, of a certain level of ability, online at once, for a fixed period of time. You can disagree with the purpose or its implementation, but you can't directly undermine it per se and pretend it's a solution.
BjofCJandBj wrote:Retry
...and everything that follows: again, no. We already have a retry button; it's called a new raid following cooldown after failure or cancellation. You haven't even addressed the fact that you'd be ameliorating penalties (time lost or power reduction) already in place.

This is remarkably ill-considered.
There's something bothering me, Marney. I've been looking over ur posts, & while some are considerate (even if they're not kind) & answer player's questions, other posts are cutting, ostentatious, snotty, condescending, vitriolic, and flat-out disagreeable. It's as if u were LOOKING for posts to disagree with so u can cut them to pieces - is this what u do in ur free time? How u get ur kicks?
Even IF I were to disagree w/BJof BJandCJ, I would do so with more decorum & less brusqueness. Being polite is not an ancient art no longer in use. I'm sure u could accomplish it if u were to try.
U seem knowledgable about the game, but are lacking in forum protocol (or common courtesy). Allow me to correct ur ignorance - anyone may post on any subject at any time so long as they're not overtly rude (as u usually are) or profane. How can Venan expect people to post their views about anything with u attacking them? U act as if ur opinions (that's right, they're opinions, not FACTS ur spewing) are the Holy Grail for The Book of Heroes.
The only things ill-considered are ur stenchy comments, which have left a bad taste in my mouth - essence a la Marney. Blech!!
Also, it seems u are awfully adamant ab other people's rightful opinions regarding the game for someone with a Real Life.
So, the thing I want to ask u (& I really don't care about ur answer) is: do u even HAVE a real life??
If not, leave others be & go get one (or at least a friend. If u can't find a friend because people (wisely) steer clear of u, then perhaps u could find a well-compensated sycophant to boss around). If u actually HAVE a life, then improve upon it as it is sorely lacking. Otherwise, I doubt u'd find u must put others under ur stench-ridden foot.
I'm posting this onto one of ur replies in the hope (albeit a slim one) that u'll think before cutting people down in ur attempt at showcasing ur non-dazzling intellect. Or, that u'll at least be a tad more considerate WHILE u do it. I know it's a tall order, but then, I'm known for thinking the most unlikely people have a shred of decency hidden within them. Including those who hide it really, really well...
Yours,
Christa
Christa_Crisp1 wrote:Being polite is not an ancient art no longer in use. I'm sure u could accomplish it if u were to try.
I appreciate the way you lead by example.
Christa_Crisp1 wrote:U seem knowledgable about the game, but are lacking in forum protocol (or common courtesy). Allow me to correct ur ignorance - anyone may post on any subject at any time so long as they're not overtly rude (as u usually are) or profane. How can Venan expect people to post their views about anything with u attacking them? U act as if ur opinions (that's right, they're opinions, not FACTS ur spewing) are the Holy Grail for The Book of Heroes.
The only things ill-considered are ur stenchy comments, which have left a bad taste in my mouth - essence a la Marney. Blech!!
Also, it seems u are awfully adamant ab other people's rightful opinions regarding the game for someone with a Real Life.
So, the thing I want to ask u (& I really don't care about ur answer) is: do u even HAVE a real life??
If not, leave others be & go get one (or at least a friend. If u can't find a friend because people (wisely) steer clear of u, then perhaps u could find a well-compensated sycophant to boss around). If u actually HAVE a life, then improve upon it as it is sorely lacking. Otherwise, I doubt u'd find u must put others under ur stench-ridden foot.
I'm posting this onto one of ur replies in the hope (albeit a slim one) that u'll think before cutting people down in ur attempt at showcasing ur non-dazzling intellect. Or, that u'll at least be a tad more considerate WHILE u do it. I know it's a tall order, but then, I'm known for thinking the most unlikely people have a shred of decency hidden within them. Including those who hide it really, really well...
I'll let the rest of this stand without much comment, but note that I didn't talk about anyone's feet, or body odor, or offline life, or lack of friends. You did.

My post addressed only my opinion of proposed game mechanics, as will any subsequent posts I make. Your opinion of me, my life, and my manners will remain entirely irrelevant. :)

But I do find it rather amusing that you took the time to write half a dozen paragraphs of insults telling me what an awful person I am for supposedly insulting someone else (I didn't; I disagreed and said why). Do you have a sense of irony? - and if so, did it tingle at any point?
Christa,
You are doing exactly what you are arguing against. It comes off a bit asinine. She at least was critiquing a post and not attacking an individual. Troller alert.
Ok this is crazy, christa I have also read all of marney's posts and think they are all good. Seriously she doesn't insult anyone's feelings, she is just saying what she thinks about the game, and it's dynamics. You talk about real life, but in real life the blunt truth is what is usually given, and if you can't take it then you really need to grow up. Everyone has their own life, and preferences and it is not for you to judge others. Keep the talk about the game (since it is a game and not an etiquette conference) and generally just chill out.

Getting back to the original post, I also think retry and pause are unnecessary because it would take away the challenge of completing the raid in that certain amount of time with the amount of players that can be online, with the enough might. Like marney, I've been playing for a long while now (not all the time btw but since it was created) and have watched the game progress and be molded, and it is still being changed and rejigged which I think is a great thing. New ideas are great, but ones that will not benefit the advancement of the game should be argued against. And that is in effect the purpose of a forum. To put forth ideas and have them critisized or added to to potentially make te game better for everyone. Marney, you are a great player and I think you are intelligent and say things how they are. Direct ad to the point, which I admire and if others don't I wouldn't worry too much about it.
I admit, I got too personal. I was rude, nasty & mean.
Marney's comments DID leave a bad taste in my mouth, & u guys might want to double-check her knowledge of the underlying mechanics of the game before accepting her posts as good or correct.
Note that the moderators have utilized one of BJ's posts as a resource, whereas I see no such use of any of Marney's posts.
When I see someone being so critical of another's work (which takes a lot of time, effort, consideration & knowledge), I get agitated & it raises my ire.
Rereading my post in the light of day, I find that perhaps I was too critical, insulting & unkind. For THAT I apologize.
Enjoy the rest of the forums, everyone!
;-)
Christa_Crisp1 wrote:Rereading my post in the light of day, I find that perhaps I was too critical, insulting & unkind. For THAT I apologize.
"Perhaps?" Where do you think you went wrong, your speculation about my "stench-ridden" feet or the sneering aspersions you cast on my life, about which you don't know anything?

Your entire post was nothing but a series of crude personal attacks; you didn't discuss game mechanics at all, not in the context of BJ's original post, nor my subsequent criticism of it.
Christa_Crisp1 wrote:Marney's comments DID leave a bad taste in my mouth, & u guys might want to double-check her knowledge of the underlying mechanics of the game before accepting her posts as good or correct.
Well, here's a novel idea that doesn't seem to have occurred to you yet: why don't you point out where I'm wrong, and why? Everything you've said so far has been an empty generality. I prefer to talk specifics.
Christa_Crisp1 wrote:Note that the moderators have utilized one of BJ's posts as a resource, whereas I see no such use of any of Marney's posts.
Even if this were true, it'd be completely irrelevant. It isn't, as you'd know if you'd read the replies by various devs to some of my posts, but that's neither here nor there; the fact that one of BJ's posts has been used as a resource doesn't make all his subsequent posts immune to criticism. I doubt he, or most other people, would make that argument. It's curious that you do.
Christa_Crisp1 wrote:When I see someone being so critical of another's work (which takes a lot of time, effort, consideration & knowledge), I get agitated & it raises my ire.
You get so upset over a forum post over a technical aspect of a computer game that you lose control of your temper and feel the need to ascribe negative traits, moral, mental, and physical, to a perfect stranger. And yet, supposedly, I'm the one who lacks a "real life."
Christa_Crisp1 wrote:Enjoy the rest of the forums, everyone!
Since you've only made two posts so far, I think that might indeed be possible. :)

Let me reiterate what I said in my original post:

A technical glitch that may be solved is preferable to a design decision that would punish people for having network problems. Do you disagree with this? If so, why?

A pause function would defeat the manifest purpose of a raid, which is to measure the ability of a guild to get a number of good players online for a length of time. Do you disagree with this? If so, why?

A retry function is unnecessary and would lessen the penalties that are in place for failing a raid or cancelling it. These penalties are obviously a design decision. BJ didn't make an argument for why they should be ameliorated; he just proposed a mechanic that would ameliorate them. Do you wish to make an argument for such an amelioration?

Or are you just here to talk about other people's feet? There are probably specialized forums for that somewhere, but I don't think this is supposed to be one of them.