Book of Heroes

Improve RNG for PvP! · page 2

Illy_the_Red

ModeratorTue Aug 11, 2015 8:03 am
It's widely known in the game that Accuracy is next to useless as an enchantment. Inspect a few people you fight in pvp to see what the commonest ones are.

Also, smoke doesn't increase any damage, so not sure which ability you meant here.
SüperSäiyan5 wrote:
On the other guys response. Note that dice things was purely for a exaple on the percentage an no one posted their rolls, an seeing how there is less than 20 attacks done in one match you dont need 10000 or whatever number you explained roll neither should the RNG.

You didnt understand me right here. 10000 is not based on number of actions or anything like that, its based on fact that percents in game are in xx.xx% format. For xx% you need to roll 1 to 100, for xx.x% you need to roll 1 to 1000.
For xx.xx% you have to roll 1 to 10000, for example if you roll 1 to 100 31,01% would be equal to 31,49%
Example: If you have 31,26% chance to do something, you roll 1 to 10000. If the result of roll is under 3126 or equal, you succeed, if over, you fail.
svako wrote:
SüperSäiyan5 wrote:
On the other guys response. Note that dice things was purely for a exaple on the percentage an no one posted their rolls, an seeing how there is less than 20 attacks done in one match you dont need 10000 or whatever number you explained roll neither should the RNG.

You didnt understand me right here. 10000 is not based on number of actions or anything like that, its based on fact that percents in game are in xx.xx% format. For xx% you need to roll 1 to 100, for xx.x% you need to roll 1 to 1000.
For xx.xx% you have to roll 1 to 10000, for example if you roll 1 to 100 31,01% would be equal to 31,49%
Example: If you have 31,26% chance to do something, you roll 1 to 10000. If the result of roll is under 3126 or equal, you succeed, if over, you fail.







No I understood you just fine.

For the last time, its not a discussion. I know how all the math works, I did not post here for opinions on the RNG nor did I ask how it works.

It is simple only post here if you think it should or should not be improved. You don't need to explain anything or try to prove anything.

Any other post here with all the extras will be reported as spamming this post.

If you want to discuss it.

(Guide)

Options/forums/forums/discussions/RNG
If there isn't one make one. Do not post it here.

Find that rude, disagree with me just on the fact of spite or that you do not like me. All I ask is take it somewhere else don't explain or discuss it here please.
Wait, do you want Venan to improve the actual odds of certain abilities?

Or do you want Venan to improve "randomness" itself? Because that's kind of just wishing for better luck.
You looked confused when you compared my 10000 to number of action per fight, thats why I explained :D

A little experiment, lets test 30% chance(roll 1 to 100) on 10 to 60 rolls:
10 rolls:
38,71,83,19,12,87,79,86,37,84 - 2/10 = 20%
20 rolls:
90,22,58,31,93,78,19,27,50,42 - 5/20 = 25%
30 rolls:
4,1,13,50,59,41,15,13,64,95 - 10/30 = 33,33%
40 rolls:
67,47,92,79,28,33,21,42,7,92 - 13/40 = 32,5
50 rolls:
96,15,48,99,64,64,28,95,47,28 - 16/50 = 32%
60 rolls:
81,48,17,52,64,50,80,68,7,14 - 19/60 = 31,66%

See? the more rolls you make, the more accurate is the result and since you dont remember all you actions and some can be more or less important, you have loosing/winning streaks. RNG can't be improved, while the actions/effects are % based, there is no way to improve it.

Illy_the_Red

ModeratorWed Aug 12, 2015 12:44 pm
One thing most don't understand is that a % chance does not change over time and that it isn't how Venan uses RNG. If you roll dodge and get (random number) 51.00% for your dodge, you don't dodge. It doesn't care whether you rolled 49, 36, 66, 75 for your previous rolls. It just works it out. Same for success - rolling 12.33% means you dodged, regardless of whether you dodged successfully the last 6 times. A probability study like those above would show that on average you do dodge as much as you should. There is also observation bias, and lots of it, to contend with.

RNG when used in this way tends to get people angry, because it does lead to streaks. The over reliance on RNG to decide everything is mainly what should be changed, but considering that it seems to be difficult to change without overhauling the way the entire system works, don't hold your breath.