Book of Heroes

Guild Alliance · page 4

Illy_the_Red

ModeratorThu Sep 3, 2015 4:41 am
Burglar wrote:Depending on how implemented could be a great addition. Love the idea of the alliance loyalty/perks to give the guilds something to cooperate on together. Think it also is a good thing for those that have members across many time zones.

Would wonder how many alliances is appropriate though? Possibly only a couple.

If concern is that it would make it too easy could make it something like a set number of "alliance" slots per raid just like current merc slots...let's say 25. So 60 member, 25 allies and 15 mercs. Anytime you raid as an ally you could earn your guild the alliance points. Power could be given: half goes to the originating guild, the remainder is split as a percentage of rpp contributed by each guild including the originating guild.


Just throwing out some ideas... Again love the concept.

Agree about limits on slots being needed - two guilds completing the same raid would find raids suddenly very easy. It would potentially lead to them having an excuse for increasing wave counts if not carefully thought out.
I agree with this instead of posting and whispering to others, you would have a push of a button, and help that was needed!
Sàlád_ wrote:I have always wished I could have all chat toons from all my toons guilds open at the same time so If I have a toon in NBW and one in Kink I could have both chats on all toons
THANKS... FOR... SUGGESTING THIS!

Also, i think the members and veterans suggest an alliance, then officers vote, then if officers vote yes the GM decides
While this is definitely a good idea, especially at the lower raid levels where new player retention could be helped with alliances, I think this has become far too complicated. Yes a set number of allowed alliances per guild should be set and other small things would need to be figured, this could be simplified to a "join alliance" button similar to "join guild" button and approved individually by all GMs in that alliance. Add an alliance chat that's accessible by officers of all guilds and some sort of raid alert button that can be pressed that goes to all guilds in the alliance when a raid has been started would be sufficient.
This isn't going to happen, what you are describing/asking for is the first few steps towards super-guilds. Super-guilds will kill the game quicker than not having a top tier onslaught raid and only bringing out new content for pvp.

If alliances are allowed, raids be will opened to guild members then guild allies and only to mercs when it becomes clear that they don't have the numbers to finish in gold time.

It will mean that the guilds in the alliance can run the same raid without having to wait for the cool down to finish.

Both of these would be bad things.

If the KoToR, fizz and NWB decided to form an alliance everyone else would be up in arms about it. Sorry to say that in the long run it can only be a bad thing for the game. I can understand why guilds on captain valor or below would wish for this but not the top end guilds.

AXIOM and The Kingdom are doing something similar to this anyway (see Bbbb's earlier post) and that is probably the closest Venan will allow to this idea, if that isn't something you would like to try then merge with your prospected allies.

In all seriousness is needing to merge into another guild to continue playing with your friends such a bad thing? Especially when the alternative seems to be to stop playing altogether?
Rezel wrote:
If the KoToR, fizz and NWB decided to form an alliance everyone else would be up in arms about it.

Those guilds are not going to work together. But if they do, so be it. Those guilds are about power ranking. I'd prefer to stay with guilds that put player development first (there is a reason why a lowly guild like Kingdom has more top might players than KOTOR). Note: I'm not saying anything is wrong with KOTOR's approach if you are into that. I tried it for 5 months and it wasn't for me.

In all seriousness is needing to merge into another guild to continue playing with your friends such a bad thing?

Almost all mergers eventually end up as failures. To paraphase Saraa from Axiom, most mergers give a boost for a week or so and then the players that moved tend to fall away. True, the HJ merger has been wildly successful but it is the only one that I am aware of.

Illy_the_Red

ModeratorFri Sep 4, 2015 3:54 pm
Fizz merged with several guilds including Last Hope and Spoons, only got stronger. I think mergers got bad press after several mergers between top 10 or formerly top 10 guilds went bad a while ago. Some people are inherently hostile to mergers for some reason.

Guild alliances like the Kingdom and Axiom one are a great idea, surprised it doesn't happen more. It's probably the closest we'll get to anything like the topic of this thread.

Rurik_the_Captain

Fri Sep 4, 2015 11:11 pm
Rezel is right about the complications of this happening. However, keeping all the same mechanics in place, and simply allowing a one-way notification from the hosting guild to all allied guilds (Max say, 3) that a raid is starting would not be out of line. It would only simplify what some guilds are already doing. A nice-to-have would be to include the raid password (if placed) in the message.

-Rurik
Bbbb wrote:
Rezel wrote:
If the KoToR, fizz and NWB decided to form an alliance everyone else would be up in arms about it.

Those guilds are not going to work together. But if they do, so be it. Those guilds are about power ranking. I'd prefer to stay with guilds that put player development first (there is a reason why a lowly guild like Kingdom has more top might players than KOTOR). Note: I'm not saying anything is wrong with KOTOR's approach if you are into that. I tried it for 5 months and it wasn't for me.

In all seriousness is needing to merge into another guild to continue playing with your friends such a bad thing?

Almost all mergers eventually end up as failures. To paraphase Saraa from Axiom, most mergers give a boost for a week or so and then the players that moved tend to fall away. True, the HJ merger has been wildly successful but it is the only one that I am aware of.

So I have a seemingly workable solution to these concerns; #1 When your guild is allied with other guilds and a raid is run the cooldown applies to the participating guilds in that raid. I.E. Soul Reaper and VC were to run Goblin King that raid would be on cooldown for both guilds; Yet if like Rires Raiders are also an ally and didn't participate in the raid then they could still run it but the ally guilds that are on cooldown could not enter. #2 There should be a cap in place of no more than 4-5 allies in order to prevent super guilds from forming. I feel that with the proper safeguards in place it should make the game stronger and more fun! This will pretty much just make it easier for all guilds to do what they are all doing to varying degrees.
I have come up with workable solutions for most every concern I have heard voiced. But I will re-iterate the entire idea with contingency plans in place. #1 Guild alliance would allow for other guilds to receive push notifications along with members for allies raids. #2 Alliance points with boosts similar to guild loyalty points. #3 A cap on how many allies are allowed. #4 When allies run a raid together that raid is on cooldown for all participating guilds but if an ally don't participate then the raid would still be open for that guild but any allies still on cooldown can't enter the raid. #5 Use common sense and ally your guilds with guilds that are running similar valor raids as your guild. It's not hard to know that a guild only running knights valor raids aren't going to be much help to a guild doing guardian valor raids. #6 Alliance would also have a chat channel like guild officer has its own channel because I truly hate it when I am mercing with a guild and we're all chatting and get cut off because the chat window for mercs expire shortly after the raid ends. I firmly believe that with the proper safeguards in place making Guild Alliance possible would definitely increase the quality of the game. If there is anything I have missed please feel free to say something I am pretty sure that I can come up with feasible solutions for most every concern. I love this game and want it to be a great time for all players in BoH!Thanks Devlyn out!