Book of Heroes

Suggestion Stub, Reboot Gem Slots

Bj_Knows

ModeratorTue Nov 3, 2015 3:17 pm
Subject
Suggestion Stub, Reboot Gem Slots

Currently there are 4 Gem Slots (A, B, C & D) for each of the 10 Item Slots. Location Multipliers range from *4 for Chest to *2 for Cloak for a total of *112 if all your Gems, and Gear, are the same Tier (Note 1).

This can be confusing for new, and experienced players, and makes the math for buying new Gear very cumbersome. Ex: Amulet and Rings have no Armor, but *4 Location, Boots and Cloak have Armor, but *2 Location. This does not even deal with Degemming, removing equipment in PvP or mixing Coliseum Gear with Seasonal Gear with Majerio Gear.

Replace the Location Multiplier with a Gem Slot Multiplier. All Gem Slots A would have the same Multiplier, all Gem Slots B, etc.

Defense would stay the same, varying by location with Chest giving best Defense rating, then Leg, Helm, etc.

Gem Slot A would already be unlocked, for all Item Slots, and give a *1 Gem Slot Multiplier (this would be the same for Chest, Amulet, Ring, etc.).
Gem Slot B would cost 10 GS, or 30,000 silver coin, for all Item Slots and give a *2 Gem Slot Multiplier.
Gem Slot C would cost 15 GS, or 45,000 silver coin, for all Item Slots and give a *3 Gem Slot Multiplier.
Gem Slot D (the White Gem Slot) would cost 30 GS, or 90,000 silver coin, for all item Slots and give a *6 Gem Slot Multiplier.
For a total of *12 for Gem Slots A through D, and *120 if all your Gems are the same Tier.

Amulet and Ring would still have no Armor, but would give the character another Gem Slot D each, which can be used for any color Gems and is a *6 Gem Slot Multiplier. Boots and Cloak would be better than Amulet and Ring, since they would offer the same Gem Slot multiplier, but also some armor. Weapon, Chest, Legs and Helm would still be the best Gear since they increase your damage and Armor the most.

Game Design Note: This deliberately increases Maximum Might Rating in the game in return for simplifying the math needed when deciding between Gear and Gem purchases. Unlocking a Gem Slot D (the White Gem Slot) would always be a cause for the player to be excited. Currently unlocking a Gem Slot D for the Cloak may do little to improve a character’s Might *but still cost 30 GS or 125,000 silver* which is very counter intuitive and anti-user friendly. This would make all Gear important for Might, instead of the heavy weight of Chest, Amulet, Ring, 2h Weapon, Helm, Legs.

MY PERSONAL OPINION
Personally, I would not mind if Gem Slots were reduced. One of the things that attracts people to one shot games like Zelda: Twilight Princess, is the wow factor when you get new Gear. MMOs suffer from grinding.

Lean War Mage Cassidy does fine with only 30 Gems due to the impact of multiple diminishing return curves on Stats. Cassidy also benefits from being less grindy since each 1.0 Valor counts as 1.33 Valor since she is only replacing 75% of the Gems. I learned with table top RPGs, then modding video games, that players like wow results. Some players will grind all the achievements (in Twilight Princess finding that hidden Bomb Bag at the bottom of the lake), but most casual players will not.

The current math is just crazy. I recently got a Tier 6 Dodge Gem drop from Caliban, it would only raise my PvP Dodge from 31% to 31.98%, but the *Tier 2* Magic Resist Gem it would replace, increased my Magic Mitigation (Fire, Ice, Nature, Spirit) by 1.5%. Dodge increase of +0.98% will not win me many more PvP Bouts, but +1.5% reduction versus Frozen Shard, Fiery Lash, Neurotoxic Stab, or Radiant Light, might win me the Bout. I am keeping the Tier 2 Magic Resist Gem and selling the Tier 6 Dodge Gem for silver coin.

While I agree that the more you put into BoH, the better your character should be, locking players into dead ends sucks. Whether the dead end is not understanding Weapon selection, Gem purchasing, Gem placement, Gear Purchasing, Enchant selection, Hero Token Spending, or selecting the wrong class abilities. This can all be less of a burden on new and experienced players. Add a Swap Meet for Gems (2 GS to swap a Gem for the same Tier) and Weapons (2 GS to swap a Weapon for the same Tier Weapon), Keystone Enchants (2 GS to swap the Recipe on an Enchant for another Recipe, Empowering an Enchant Slot increases the power of the rune you choose for it), Retraining (2 GS to swap any two Tomes) and Respecing (2 GS for, oops, that one is now free, and wildly popular). End game players could spend years experimenting with all the combinations of Weapon, Gems and Enchants, if only selecting the wrong one was not so costly and burdensome.

Note 1)
Chest, Amulet, Ring *4
Helm, Leg *3
Gauntlet, Boots, Cloak, Main Hand Weapon, Off Hand Item *2
= 28
*4 Gem Slots
= 112