Book of Heroes

T7 white crit gems , venan please advise · page 2

T8 gems I used 3 replacing tier 7 gems and didn't not see much of a difference in any increase ! Put them in same piece of equipment and seen a reduction in might ! The only good increase I got from using the gems is it gave me 3 T7 gems not being used anymore for lower T 6 and T 5 ! I can see maybe replacing T 8 for T 4 or T 5 gems but they really didn't help me out !

Now I don't have any white gems but I have the T8 gems placed were they are just effecting one gem anyways and the increase value is very small example haste went up .02 is all / my might for three gems only increased 53,839 to 54,045! Magic 13,675 to 13,732 ! Crit p went .32 to .40 Not what I expected for adding magic/haste/crit P gems. Maybe I'm using them wrong not sure !

Now that said after this I replaced the three T7 gems for T6 them for T5 gems and seen a big increase so would of seen almost the same increase if I would of just got 3 new T7 gems anyways ! Except the very small .02 average increase for a higher T8 gem :(
Fræk wrote:T8 gems I used 3 replacing tier 7 gems and didn't not see much of a difference in any increase ! Put them in same piece of equipment and seen a reduction in might !

These numbers will explain the issue. When you add a T8 over T7, you get a 14% increase in might but then if you back out the 10% reduction on T8, each gem only gets you a 2.85% increase in might. So on those 3 gems, you end up gaining 3 x 2.85% for 8.55%. However, you still have to pay the 10% penalty on the white slot. So you end up -1.45%.

To offset this, you must equip a white gem in the white slot. Unfortunately, the choices for that slot are bad (at least for PvE).

My recommendation if you have a red, yellow and blue, spread them out across 2 or 3 pieces of equipment and make sure that the 4th slot does not suffer from reduction.

Based on your post, I can see no case where getting more than 18 (20 if 1H) gems (red and yellow) for PvE makes sense and that's all offensive build. Realistically, the gains on 2x equipment are so trivial 12 gem is the max useful I see. For the tank build needed for Hunter P3, getting T8 blue melee resist will make a trivial gain in defense but you have to give up damage or health for it. Also, you give up the ability to put a red gem in the 4th slot.

Venan originally had 20% reduction until I argued that it was insane and no reason to even get those unstable gems. Now after this analysis, I think the penalty should be more like 5%.

Alternatively, if we get an announcement of T14 melee resistence or white health, magic, or melee gems, I would be interested in more than 12 gems.

I hope someone can debunk my theory and show me a useful way to use more T8 in PvE but I'm not seeing it. I am not making any statements about PvP needs as I have never built a toon for that.
Bbbb wrote:
Nextlite wrote:
Good post. Im confused though about why you arent willing to degrade blues for sw. Need the resist to run dw?

I wasn't making a statement about them one way or another. Yes, I have a 63K might one (with cobwebs all over it), but I hate that class and definitely suck at using them as melee (I do think I used to be good at poison). I don't know how much resist you need for dw.

Aaah that makes sense. Its a smart play actually as your useless sw has just become even more useless. Melee is unusable in the new raids and dw has been nerfed. Its a tough time to be a sw. We essentially have to give up damage output to add resist and health to survive. Not saying it's impossible to find a decent balance, just that its going to take a lot more adjusting than the other classes. My prediction is the end result will make us a poor man's poison mage.

All that being said, adding red & yellow to sw may be slightly beneficial depending on your play style. It may make a small difference, and sometimes in this game a small difference means all the difference. The problem is you wont know until you spend the gs to find out.

Illy_the_Red

ModeratorSat Feb 13, 2016 11:19 am
Nextlite wrote:
Bbbb wrote:
Nextlite wrote:
Good post. Im confused though about why you arent willing to degrade blues for sw. Need the resist to run dw?

I wasn't making a statement about them one way or another. Yes, I have a 63K might one (with cobwebs all over it), but I hate that class and definitely suck at using them as melee (I do think I used to be good at poison). I don't know how much resist you need for dw.

Aaah that makes sense. Its a smart play actually as your useless sw has just become even more useless. Melee is unusable in the new raids and dw has been nerfed. Its a tough time to be a sw. We essentially have to give up damage output to add resist and health to survive. Not saying it's impossible to find a decent balance, just that its going to take a lot more adjusting than the other classes. My prediction is the end result will make us a poor man's poison mage.

All that being said, adding red & yellow to sw may be slightly beneficial depending on your play style. It may make a small difference, and sometimes in this game a small difference means all the difference. The problem is you wont know until you spend the gs to find out.

Yep, DW has now been nerfed out of existence in terms of Hunter P3. Because there are (probably deliberately, considering most of his attacks melee) no melee boosting or resist gems, nobody has any way of building a better than 'standard' phys resist build that will help in that raid phase. It doesn't matter too much to classes that just dump heal when off cool down. But the addition of DW in 2.0 was the only thing that kept physical damage output with 1H high enough to compete. In the hunter raid the only class with zero imposed penalties are now mages - they have no inherent OS problems and don't have an issue with healing affecting damage output. Everyone has had problems being killed, but this update is really affecting PvE balance, contrary to Venan claims.
Ilyana wrote:In the hunter raid the only class with zero imposed penalties are now mages - they have no inherent OS problems

That's not true. Mages in OS are all about stacking debuffs. With focus on so long, the debuffs can't hit. That makes mage damage go way down and also reduces the amount of time Hunter is on slow. In normal OS, a Mage can keep up to 5 debuffs plus a DOT going from start to finish pretty much. It's impossible with Hunter. A mage without debuffs is like a SW without DW.

Note I recognized that SW has the most Hunter problems right now. But I would argue that the Justi was the least effected by this phase. I ran my one size fits all melee Justi setup on P3 w no elixir. I was doing about as well as my Mage with her original OS setup and haste elixir.

Illy_the_Red

ModeratorSat Feb 13, 2016 12:41 pm
Bbbb wrote:
Ilyana wrote:In the hunter raid the only class with zero imposed penalties are now mages - they have no inherent OS problems

That's not true. Mages in OS are all about stacking debuffs. With focus on so long, the debuffs can't hit. That makes mage damage go way down and also reduces the amount of time Hunter is on slow. In normal OS, a Mage can keep up to 5 debuffs plus a DOT going from start to finish pretty much. It's impossible with Hunter. A mage without debuffs is like a SW without DW.

Note I recognized that SW has the most Hunter problems right now. But I would argue that the Justi was the least effected by this phase. I ran my one size fits all melee Justi setup on P3 w no elixir. I was doing about as well as my Mage with her original OS setup and haste elixir.

You mean mages have P3 Hunter problems, which is true. In general, outside of that phase, they have no OS issues, which justicars have had for years. That's pretty well known.

Agree about the debuffs though. You need debuffs and DW on SW to do well. In that phase you can do neither very effectively. You need pretty constant defence reductions from spirit tunes, DW boost, and the ability to avoid enough damage. I don't see getting physical resist gems making much headway against those issues. Already have 23% defence enchants, so can gain only 4% protection from defence even by maxing those. If I didn't pvp I'd consider pulling off SR enchants just to be able to afford the VIII/IX enchants, but even then it's 4% plus whatever can be got from phys resist.
In response to Bbbb reply on T8 gems and since I don't know how to take part of a message repost and rely to it lol ! I do wish I would of got a physical resist gem instead of a critic power T8 since I do run both resists in Pve utilizing gems for Pve and pvp . Personally I think the 10% penalty should only come into play 20% percent of the time not 100% hence making the name Unstable more efficient :) but would agree with a lower 5% effect for 100% time . As it stands right now from what I seen I prob won't get more T8 gems for the very small increase were I'm not worried about having a topped out might toon ! Also I can see a struggle for SW in shadow P3 were I myself struggle (prob cause of me lol) with my SW that's not yet PM might !
Fræk wrote:were I'm not worried about having a topped out might toon !

To get all the T8s w a 2H toon, you would need 1080 hearts without commerce elixir. I was on pace to do that until earlier today when I decided to quit using e pots on the event as I think the ROI beyond 12 unstable gems is virtually nil. I can't find any PvE use for blue unstable.

Then you do all the T14s. Sadly, that would not be that good a toon when you are done.
Ilyana wrote:


Yep, DW has now been nerfed out of existence in terms of Hunter P3.

The "out of existence" goes slightly too far. Im running poison DW ok. Not very efficiently but I'm not dying. Now if you were talking about melee being nerfed out of existence for the new raids, I would be inclined to agree. I'm not sure if this is by design to level the playing field or if the physical resist needs to be lowered on these monsters to match the output of the magic builds.

Personally, I'm calling this the Eric nerf.
Bbbb wrote:
Fræk wrote:were I'm not worried about having a topped out might toon !

To get all the T8s w a 2H toon, you would need 1080 hearts without commerce elixir. I was on pace to do that until earlier today when I decided to quit using e pots on the event as I think the ROI beyond 12 unstable gems is virtually nil. I can't find any PvE use for blue unstable.

Then you do all the T14s. Sadly, that would not be that good a toon when you are done.

That about sums it up for pve. For all classes.

Ive heard do all yellow and decrease blue but how much are you really going to gain with dim returns? Something like .01 seconds and 1-2% crit?

Ive heard go heavy red with yellow haste and add a couple white crit gems. How much extra damage are you going to get for all that work?