Disclaimer: Your Mileage May Vary.
New Abilities
Note: I'm not in favour of Healing abilities, especially in PvP (some matches are already very long). Our toons are more than healthy enough at the minute and hard to kill as it is (outside of SR P3)
Shadow Walker
- Group Melee attack. Sticky Grenade is only really useful in PvP - it has marginal usefulness elsewhere because of a high delay. A high-tier addition could be a knife flurry attack, an AoE instant grenade or a multi-hit dart attack.
- Poison Darts - group Nature attack that applies increased Nature crit chance or additional DoT damage.
- Dual Wield - allows SW to equip dual 1H weapons, increasing damage to parity with 2H. Overall this should remove the need for Death Wish (all DW does is bring damage up to where it should be).
- Flash Bomb - an interrupt attack like Time Void that throws the enemy off guard, making them lose their action.
- Vanish - return this ability, possibly replacing Shadow Veil.
- Off-Hand Parry - allows the SW to parry attacks like a shield, reducing damage.
Justicar
- Brutality. Though something may have to be taken out (possibly Vengeance) to allow it to return to prevent damage getting too high.
- Wrath - change to a DoT Spirit effect that works in a similar way to bleed.
- Juggernaut - not sure how this would balance overall, but this could be reimagined as a buff to armour (making them a true tanky class) rather than a Status Resist buff.
- Cripple Limb - rather than a slow, the Justicar strikes his foe on the weapon arm causing outgoing damage to drop briefly.
- Shield Bash - An offensive version of Stagger and another possibility to improve 1H damage output. The Justicar smashes his shield into the opponent, causing damage. If the opponent is unlucky enough to hit the Justicar during the bash, it has a much higher chance of being blocked.
War Mage
- Elemental Weaponry - the mage charges his weapon with Fire or Ice magic, slightly increasing damage for one element at the expense of reduced damage for the other.
- Staff Strike - melee mages! A fairly basic hit over the head with a stick.
- Mass Strike - mob attack with the staff.
- Throw Staff - much like throwing a lightsabre, the mage throws his staff magically. It hits and comes back to his hand. Each level allows it to hit one enemy.
- Summon Elemental - this PvE only long-cast effect summons a little elemental critter that buffs you/attacks your enemies.
Balance/Ability Changes
- Spell Dodges should be actual dodges, or at least further reduce the damage/make it incapable of applying any debuff.
- All stuns should have the same base speed, or their effects should scale to their throwing speed.
- Increase Status Resist buff from Defend. Otherwise leave it as it is - it's a crucial part of PvP strategy.
- Redesign DoTs so the damage values are more in line with each other, and tick at the same rate.
- Seismic Slash could be changed to a Spirit attack.
- Fix the broken Backswing damage calculation (it's been wrong for some time, and pointed out to Venan before).
- Remove ice spike armour, or at least change the ability so it doesn't proc on abilities that do zero damage when applied.
- Remove Arcane Shield - Snap Cast randomness is fun. Random procs that reduce damage by 75%, at an apparent much higher proc rate than listed, is not good. Mages are not tanks. If anything this ability would be much more appropriate on Justicars.
- Change Snap Cast back to being random, it was so much fun
- Snap Cast changing would reopen the possibility of Mages having an actual Knockback. As it is, a full Seismic/Smoke style Knockback would be OP in combination with Snap. It would also be OP to have a full Knockback effect applied by a very damaging ability. The new mage Knockback could be similar to Seismic in terms of damage, but in line with the other KBs in terms of time added to the opponent's action.
- Smite - the damage capability of this attack should be remodelled along the lines of Brutal Strike and the cooldown made to match. It should still do slightly more damage as opposed to Knockback.
- Heavenly Wave - this ability should not remove Sticky Grenades as mentioned by devs at the time it was last rebalanced.
- Rebalance 1H Justicar builds. As with SW, the Haste benefit of using 1H does not compensate for the drop in overall damage output.
- Increase the effectiveness of shields. At the minute it's not a very high chance to block. Possibly just explain how the mechanic works, so that we have all the info. As it is, not too many use shields in either form of the game because of 1H damage sucking and shield enchants being expensive to try out.
- Justicars equip Plate armour, SWs leather and Mages Cloth armour. Currently there is no observable difference in the amount of damage each class takes at high mights. Justicars are slow and tanky but don't seem to take reduced damage from thicker armour, SWs are already the 'high dodge' class and Mages don't take slightly more damage to make up for their already very high damage output.
- Rebalance War Mage damage output vs the Haste of their attacks. Mages should be the 'glass cannon' trope: capable of very high damage but also taking plenty when they are hit. Mages use 2H weapons yet most of their single-target abilities (Magma, Shard, Fiery Lash, Icy Grasp, Fire Blast) are much faster than expected 2H-speed. Only Incinerate and Ice Lance are as slow as you would expect for a 2H weapon. They should be a little faster than Justicars, but not to this extent, especially when every attack is applying debuffs that make the next fast attack hit harder.
New Events
I'd love to see a 'world' event. This wouldn't necessarily have spawns in cycles (though that format is fairly effective), but would involve some great threat to Glenfort, such as a renewed Vile invasion, an attack from Stonehelm (remember that?), Alador raising an army of dragons and Valdenians to assault Glenfort, or the return (again) of Lord Helion from his watery grave. The event would involve cooperation across the game - each guild would have to enter a portal (like a raid) and assault the enemy, with each kill on the boss within the spawn/raid timer knocking one kill off the
overall boss kill count, which would be very high. The goal would be to kill that boss within the timer, or in a more ambitious event, kill the boss a required number of times within the overall event time. Imagine the challenge of a boss with thousands or hundreds of thousands of kills to be chipped away at for days...
To offset the effect on raids, this event would also reward guild power and prestige. It would also drop valour at the highest Tier the guild has unlocked, plus essence in line with the top raids. The boss could also spawn within regular raids for those that can't (or really don't want to) hit the event...even Skar!
Raids
New raid: The Tower of Ironhaven
This raid would be a (sort of) revival of Forgotten Sentinels, once upon a time my favourite raid in the game. This would be a four-phase (or five, what the hell) Onslaught raid at whatever tier is top at the time.
Phase 1: This would be similar to the mob OS phases in WoF, with a relatively low wave count. This is the phase lower toons or alts could be thrown at, or for OS practice at high valour level. The enemies would be reanimated Rath'een and regular sentinel constructs.
[Optional Phase: The Bogworm Queen Returns! Would it feel like FS if it didn't have the Queen?]
Phase 2: OS boss phase - Reanimated Sentinel. This is a chance to fight the old Sentinel boss from the Ironhaven Tower, albeit a revived and buffed version. But who is doing the buffing?
Phase 3: OS boss phase - Alador. This is the chance to finally fight your old nemesis, corrupted by something into a true Dark Mage.
Phase 4: OS boss phase - Keepers. The culprits behind Alador's mutation, the Keepers have decided to lure you back to the site of your victory in Fellmarsh so they can kill you. This would be a challenging (within reason!) OS phase. Each time you hit the '10e' and enter, you do not know which Keeper you will face. Each would have different challenges (high physical resist, high magic resist, high status resist etc). Alternatively this could be a normal 2e boss phase, with each hit being a standard PvE Keeper as they appear in the Vile Realm.
Crafting/Enchants
- Reduce the prices of Diamond Gravers and/or add a way we could craft them from the piles of random ingredients we've built up. When you work it out, the amount of silver/GS is eye-watering for maxing or transferring.
- Alternatively, make it free to transfer enchantments to plates. I would try so many different ones if I could take them off without having to pay for the privilege.
- Reduce the number of critical ingredients in potions (such as Grizzly Teeth or Alpha Wolf Paws), or radically increase the rate at which they both drop in the new raids and spawn in the miniboss areas.
- New craftable food - allow us to craft seasonal items like the chocolate crit buff in a similar way to bacon.
- Craftable Elixirs.
- Rework Enchantments. Currently there are many that simply are not used (Healing) aren't worth it (Block/Block Chance/Crit Resist) or rubbish (Accuracy). Make all of these worth using in some regard, in PvE or PvP. Currently the majority of toons use the same enchantments.
- Change Status Resist so it reduces debuffs by a percentage effect, rather than the all/nothing model used now. It would make a massive difference to PvP, which currently only has one winner: the RNG.
- Add a way to break down gems into component shards, I wouldn't mind sacrificing 4-5 gems for a
guarantee of one of the type I need.
- Add an energy regen and luck slot to the toon so we can have these enchants without sacrificing damage.
- Craftable weapons - more items of higher tiers that are only acquired via quests, and not in-raid quests either. It would've been great if the Pristine Sword of the Vile had been a T19/20 item, for example.
- Blessings - crafting recipes that allow you to create 'Blessing' enchantments only applicable to PvE in a special unlockable slot. These Blessings would allow you to make your armour far more resistant to critical hits from Vile enemies, or your weapon do more damage to only Vile enemies. You could Bless your boots to give you 10% Haste, or make your Cloak give you more Defence. These recipes would be as varied as existing enchantments, without the downsides of half of them being rubbish
- Increase the buying limit on materials...buying Refining and Purifying salts is boringggggg...
- Make the additional workbenches unlockable like our additional builds are (but not as freaking expensive).
- While you're at it, reduce the costs of additional builds.
Guilds
- Change the toon count so that each
account takes up one slot, rather than each toon.
- Get rid of guild loyalty. I'm sure not many would lament the end of this very unpopular feature. The perks of being in a guild should stay whether I've just joined or not. Yes, this means we do want to keep the +8 energy and raid bonuses and be able to leave/join whichever guild we so choose. It's not fully appreciated by Venan just how good the game was during 1.5.
- New guild challenges and favours.
- A guild bank so I can throw other toons a bone. Once you've crafted the ring of eternity it would be nice to be able to toss the Impure Shadows to your friend who is trying to get it too. We should have the choice.
- Venan-set minimum RPP limit for each raid to address skunking. If you join a raid, you must average a certain RPP in (for example) the first ten minutes, or you are automatically removed from the raid and may not rejoin. What RPP you did do still counts towards the raid, but you receive no rewards.
Misc
- Transfer of unwanted items to your other toons. We've earned the right to be able to give our lower toons a leg up if we've done the main questline three times already.
- Gifting - I want to be able to give a friend's toon my old equipment and gems if I so wish.
- If that's not acceptable, an auction house. I can post any item, gem, material or enchant plate as a listed item, set a time limit, and charge whatever I want for it. The 'House' would get a cut, much like the wager system in PvP.
- A Diablo-style storage chest in your house for tossing currently unwanted items into when your inventory gets too high.
- Fair resell prices in the store. Majerio is a thief. Only 60,000 silver for Karnak's ring?! Does he know how much effort that took to make?! It's worth a Diamond Graver at the very least!
- Reduce the penalties on Tragick gems. It was fairly pointless getting them.
- T7 white crit gems have almost no effect. Have dedicated slots for these gems that make them worthwhile.
- Please add T14 physical resist gems and T7 physical crit gems.
- Rebalance phase 3 of Shadow Returns so it's fair to all classes.
- Either add more levels of Hero Training, add more Tomes, or allow us to use stockpiled HT for something else. I personally like the idea of using them to craft Diamond Gravers.
- Remove PvP gear. Double enchants was enough, we don't need additional gear types in PvP.
- An easier way to switch between toons than logging out and back in again.
- An easier way to see which of the guilds you are in are currently running raids when within the app (if a raid starts in another guild while you're on another toon, you don't know).
- More character slots, in anticipation of the addition of the Archer class

too tired to write that one up, will do it in another post.
- More PvE sigils - we need a Captain's, Champion's and Guardian's Sigil!
- PvP sigil(s). Not a big fan of Resolve potions either, half the time you lose out by using them if you aren't completely empty.
- Please name something in the game 'the Bimbosigliere'. I suggest 100,000 kills of Skar.
- Create pets that buff your toon and help them fight and stuff.
Edits
- I don't want to see constant DLC. Having played two games that seem to do it a lot, I much prefer a measured, 'big update' approach every few months than constant tiny little DLCs that eat your data unannounced. At the very least, you'd have to make these optional and still allow play if the person can't apply them at that current time.
PvP
System - The whole system needs a rework. Venan chose the Elo system used in chess, ironic because the competitive chess game has been agitating for a move away from this system as it is actually biased against the higher-rated player. Even so, chess players play multiple-round matches, whereas in this game every match is a one-off. Wizards of the Coast apparently abandoned Elo for Magic: The Gathering because of players protecting their rating. Even with rating decay for absent players, you need only play one match to maintain your rating. If you're protecting a rating bracket of 200-300 points, this isn't a deterrent. If you choose your time carefully, a Masters toon will get a much lower ranked player. The primary problem though is RNG - it's widely thought that the skill of the player has approximately a 10-20% effect on a match, with the rest coming down to gear, gems, enchants and luck. Elo is designed to rate a player's skill and adjust that rating based on performance. In chess there is nothing that involves rolling a dice and hoping you get the result. After playing it for a while, the system used in DragonSoul seemed much more logical and fair - players are ranked within each league, with non-fighters unranked and therefore receiving no rewards. If you fight 4th in the league and win, you go 4th and they drop to 5th. They could of course try to fight you back and regain their spot, but that would only switch your rankings back to 5th/4th. After a period of time, everyone gets some rewards and the top few toons promoted to the next league up. Even after a few days of playing this, I liked this system more than anything Venan has done in BoH. The game itself didn't hold my interest like BoH does (what does?), but the PvP system really seemed logical. It couldn't be identical, as in DragonSoul you can fight someone in PvP while they're offline.
Matching - Rather than gaining points for time spent queuing, if this system must stay then a rework of the rating gain/loss system would help. Elo is modifiable. Gains or losses from a given match should be obvious and understandable, rather than leaving players scratching their heads. It's also difficult to understand if the Elo system is designed to modify your rating so you have a 50/50 chance of a win/loss, why it's possible to get huge winning/losing streaks - and more importantly why this happens to so many players. Statistically a run of 10-15 wins or losses should be rare, but they aren't. BJ once described rating like a tide - you ebb up and down with your max rating potentially pushing up as you get better gear and enchants. This is something you don't want in a league system. In most professional Football (real football, not handegg) leagues, good (ie skilled) teams have the consistency to win large groups of matches. They 'go on a run' of good results much more often than average or weak teams. In a league system the skilled players should move to the top and then on to the next league, while the average players stay somewhere in the middle of their current league. This might be better achieved by a different system as above, and more leagues, with each league having a max player count.