CampSoup wrote:
The Guild Loyalty in Book of Heroes does not fit either definition. Guild Loyalty should always be earned and never automatically given. Just think, how loyal you would seem to be if you quit your current sports team to join the rival team? Probably not seem like a very loyal person, right? So when you quit a guild and join a new guild, how can you automatically earn like 2,000 points of loyalty when you join a new guild? You should start on the bottom of the totem pole and have to work your way back up again.
I feel that increasing the penalty for switching guilds to at least 50% (I personally feel that a 100% penalty is the most appropriate) would greatly benefit the entire game atmosphere. Currently with such as minuscule 10% penalty, there is no motivation for people to actually be loyal to their current guild. Currently, it is a common practice for people to abandon their current guild in favor of a more powerful guild once they start to outgrow their current guild because the penalty is so small. This leads to a select few 'elite' guilds with 100 powerful characters and the rest of the guilds in the game stagnant and unable to grow.
If one's loyalty was reset back to zero (as you would expect in the real world) when you switch guilds, it would encourage players to stay with their current guilds even though they are starting to outgrow the guild, and help support the guild as a whole to be able to run stronger raids, better raids, that the guild might not otherwise be able to do if all of their members leave once they start to get bigger.
I would like to say a few things about this.
If you want loyalty from your guild, you have to give loyalty to your guild. If you have to rely on an in game mechanic to force people to stay you do not have loyalty.
This means that if your recruits want a raid, if at all possible you throw a raid. If it conflicts with a scheduled raid or if there aren't enough on the raid, then you can let them know. If you never have enough people to throw a raid then you will not keep that recruit. Never, ever, tell your new recruits to merc as a first option.
Teach your new recruits. Help them to grow. If you help build up a recruit they are more likely to stay and help you build your guild.
Set realistic goals. Setting your guild to only show at 1000 might will not get you the recruits you need. In a rebuilding guild that should be lower. Yes, you will get weaker recruits. But see above.
Figure out what kind of guild that you want and recruit that type. Don't advertise as a rp guild if you want raiders. You will most likely be disappointed. A lot of rpers don't want to raid. They like to hang out and chat and rp. And that's fine. If that's how they want to play the game then that's awesome! And sure, there are plenty of rpers who like to raid as well. But they seem to be the exception. (I could be wrong though.)
Apex has a very low turnover rate. Not because of some artificial loyalty mechanic but because we recruited what we wanted. We let everyone know what was expected of them. (Not much really. Just one raid a week. Not too hard.) We kicked those who didn't follow our simple rules. Then we recruited again. Rinse and repeat.
We are currently full. They range from toons in the teens to max level toons. And yes those max level toons have to merc the higher level raids. We just hit KFS. So we still have a ways to go. But those level 35 toons still hit everything from lockbolt on up. Because they are loyal. Not to some mechanic but to the guild and each other.
My 2 gs