Book of Heroes

Recommend an FK build · page 2

Raydem wrote:FK situation

axe mastery works like 1h bonus damage enchants, so Kenner make confusion talking about only 20%. Is 25% axe (or blade ), stop. We all agree
So, the point is FK will have the possibility to have 52% 1h bonus damage one day (passive + max chants) and SW will stay there and see like a clover.

about pve spec not counting final OS
is pretty obvious that physical builing is better thanks high crit passive. Devastate works great in normal phases
about OS piercing strike, savage slash, devastate and saver ensure a great rotation

counting final OS and obligation of magic spec
well, ice storm and shattering would be work fine in normal phases
in OS i hope there will be a good rotation of shard, ice blast, ice lance and..yeah frost blade, a physical skill not supported by red gem (and chants if you choose lucky), but essential for Cold effect. Minimum 1 phisical chant and critical eye should helps.

Didn't see that it increases 1h damage by 25%. Still if you use an offhand aswell you will see that damage increases by about 20% which means 1h damage enchant does not increase damage from the offhand sadly enough. Also this makes this skill a lot more useless at higher might than I thought. What I was actually hoping for was that this skill would just multiply your total damage done by 1.25.

Illy_the_Red

ModeratorWed Jul 20, 2016 3:45 am
Raydem wrote:FK situation

axe mastery works like 1h bonus damage enchants, so Kenner make confusion talking about only 20%. Is 25% axe (or blade ), stop. We all agree
So, the point is FK will have the possibility to have 52% 1h bonus damage one day (passive + max chants) and SW will stay there and see like a clover.

about pve spec not counting final OS
is pretty obvious that physical builing is better thanks high crit passive. Devastate works great in normal phases
about OS piercing strike, savage slash, devastate and saver ensure a great rotation

counting final OS and obligation of magic spec
well, ice storm and shattering would be work fine in normal phases
in OS i hope there will be a good rotation of shard, ice blast, ice lance and..yeah frost blade, a physical skill not supported by red gem (and chants if you choose lucky), but essential for Cold effect. Minimum 1 phisical chant and critical eye should helps.

Axe Mastery does not do 25% damage. The ability SAYS that, but when people actually tested it, like a lot of these abilities it actually doesn't do what it says.

A physical build will struggle in GV OS. Venan have indicated this was completely intentional, as was the leaving out of physical resist white gems. It's possible to use physical in these raids, but you'd be putting yourself at a severe handicap. Building a physical spec without also building a magic spec alongside it will cause someone a LOT of pain down the line as many physical-only players found out. I was lucky in that my SW already had a Nature build so it was easy to switch across to that for OS. I'd also recommend Magic builds for most other areas of the game, there doesn't seem to be anything that has high magic resist (can't have mages being bad at a raid can we?)
axe mastery has a total wrong description. First, it works with blade too. Second, it doesnt encrease the general damage by 25% but the 1h damage by 25% as you note on the second page of stats. Is normal that the skills arent increased by 25% but only the main weapon contribution. All this was already said.
nevertheless 52% 1h bonus stat is already a good thing which sunder FK from SW issues in pve.

Atm my 9k FK doesent suffer melee spec. however In view of all this i will do 70% magic/30% melee or so

Illy_the_Red

ModeratorWed Jul 20, 2016 9:19 am
Raydem wrote:axe mastery has a total wrong description. First, it works with blade too. Second, it doesnt encrease the general damage by 25% but the 1h damage by 25% as you note on the second page of stats. Is normal that the skills arent increased by 25% but only the main weapon contribution. All this was already said.
nevertheless 52% 1h bonus stat is already a good thing which sunder FK from SW issues in pve.

Atm my 9k FK doesent suffer melee spec. however In view of all this i will do 70% magic/30% melee or so

We'll see as people painstakingly grow physical builds. Axe Mastery doesn't do 25% it's more like 20%, and a more realistic enchant level is around VI-VII for the purposes of practical comparisons. Many don't have higher than that. However the comparison is flawed because SWs also used 1H and Physical damage enchants. When enchants are taken out of the equation for both, FK gain +20% (25 if fixed) versus a SW's +50% Death Wish bonus. Having run a physical build SW for a long time, that's barely enough to keep up with WM in OS. I'm not sure Bleed will recoup that 25-30% gap for Frost Knights.

Illy_the_Red

ModeratorWed Jul 20, 2016 12:46 pm
Raydem wrote:I remember someone said DW is not usable in tSR..

Very challenging (and often deadly) to use in TSR P3. In P2, it's not a problem (for my 72k SW). I have made Death Wish work with elixirs on a physical build, but it takes a lot of effort, all of the combat-related elixirs including health and damage reduction as well as dodge/haste pots. Even then, it's still possible to die. The problem with P3 is that in addition to doing very exaggerated damage and having obscene physical resist (still waiting on that being balanced Venan), some of his abilities seem to hit 99% of the time even through maxed dodge + quickness + major dodge potion + defend. Not sure what that adds up to percentage wise but it's very high, and he still scores hits conveniently frequently.
I'm pretty sure FK will be awful in OS as is. At 75k might it could be passable but it will never be good. Just trying to do well enough in OS to procure the pures needed to take chants to lvl 9 will drive most FK's crazy. It has no kb like the Justi and not enough of the tools the sw has. It's almost like they took the worst aspects of each old class to form the FK. Cold is ok but fire is much more powerful. Bleed is ok but the infinite Justi combo is the bomb when it works. The most essential OS skill for sw is death wish. The future is not bright for the FK. Good luck to those of you who try to develop it.
I think Flash Freeze was an attempt to be Assassinate. Except for LoB P4, I think it is inferior in every other situation though.

We are getting to the point that I will have to decide whether to enchant Ice, Physical or Luck. I've always gone luck and picked one. Neither path for the FK seems viable. With the OS short of pures, Luck is doubly useful. However, I have the same pathing issue for the FW. At least, the Inq is obvious (IMHO).
The thing that I have noticed is that the flamer is the best "new" class in pve it's like a tank so delete all your FK and make a flamer