Book of Heroes

Speed run idea to increase fairness

After looking at some numbers it sees that the latest drops run challenges could have been more fair to the general population. One guild has dominated the last two top tier runs. In all fairness they are brilliant to only recruit people with 9000+ might, but that leads to people one-shot or may e two-shot killing each monster. Over the period of the raid they are of course going to have less time on each encounter and thus the win every time. Why not set some sort of bar? I stead of allowing the fastest single guild winning, ANY guild with a certain time or lower can win? Reduce the prize to say 1000 valor and maybe 5-10 gold shields and let more people have a fighting chance?

beekeo

Site AdminWed Jul 25, 2012 8:48 pm
Part of it is sheer speed per combat, the other part is total guild involvement. From our (Black Lotus) CK run only a few gold shields were spent per person and that was a 26 minute run with 26 people participating. If we had more players able to run it each person would have had fewer combats, no one would have spent any shields and we would have had a faster time. Combat speed/One-Hitting matters more when each person sees more combats.

So in that respect, the speed run is not broken and does not need to be fixed.

I think a target speed with a set reward for all that achieve it is more egalitarian but also less special (my opinion, not saying we might not ever do some kind of consolation prize).

If we were to do a speed run again, we could consider balancing it differently among the guild levels. There IS a huge Power Rating swing amongst the guilds competing in Cursed Keep.

But I expect it might be awhile before that happens since we'll likely do some sort of Onslaught competition while it's still new and shiny. :)
You must realize that the clan that dominated twice has a minimum might of 9000 per member. If you can one hit or two hit and end each encounter in .5 seconds the of course you will win every time
Might somewhat takes into account but not completely. We did GD/SK in 14:22 minutes with 33 members on. If any top 10 Guilds that had maybe 45+ members online they could beat us. KGW did it in 15:02 minutes with 42 members according to mercs they hired. So if they got 3 or more members on they could score the win

beekeo

Site AdminThu Jul 26, 2012 10:22 am
For what it's worth, the majority of the 26 BL members in our 26 min can kill the pirate and beast mobs before they get a turn. For my 8000-might SW, it's Smoke/Vanish/Poison and done (unless I miss a crit). Cerebrus and the GD are only a little longer. Then I'm sitting there watching victory rewards and loading the next mob.

It's all about having a large army. The more members in the fight, the fewer combats they'll see and the fewer sequential Victory/Load next transitions.
@ jherskow-
You would not be complaining if it was your guild that had won would you? I highly doubt it.
I'm not going to waste time in explaining how to get a good speed run, but might is only a part of the equation and not even the biggest part at that.
Maybe you didn't intend to, but you making this thread just makes you come across as a sore loser and bit of a crybaby.
Next time work harder, coordinate better, and kill faster. Or just step aside and let the big boys add to the trophy case ;)
It seems to me that currently the raids are energy based. Can't wait till the next update! So if the battles are energy based, it doesn't matter how much might you have, just how much energy and how many people participate.
Our guild kinda got screwed on how it was set up. We have just recently started running Cursed Keep, so we had to do that one for the contest, but only about a third of our guild qualified. Even with heavy gold shield expenditure it took us about 40 minutes. Granted, we eased off when we knew we weren't going to beat the top score, but we didn't even have a chance.
Ansguard wrote:It seems to me that currently the raids are energy based. Can't wait till the next update! So if the battles are energy based, it doesn't matter how much might you have, just how much energy and how many people participate.

Yes! The current raid mechanic is quite poorly designed, since the only thing that matters is the number of guild members you can coordinate (keeping in mind that time zones are real), and how much gold they're willing to spend to buy extra Energy, with initial Energy having only a small effect, especially for the 4-hour and 6-hour raids.

So I'm really looking forward to the Onslaught mode, because it's a good idea - I suggested it myself to Venan, very shortly after 1.3 came out.