This event has been so terrible that I only attempted it one year (2014) out of three only on one toon and gave up then in disgust. I have only talked to one person who didn't outright hate the Halloween event and I think that person was trolling. The reasons:
1. The upfront purchase of the Pumpkin Basket or the whole event is completely hopeless.
2. But the event is hopeless anyway. I have calculated before. If I paid for the basket, didn't sleep, didn't work, and hit every event optimally even with max e regen enchants, I couldn't buy the top item without extra GS. The math has been bad every year.
3. It badly discriminates against lower e players since the rewards scale up based on the amount of e used.
4. It badly discriminates against players who can't schedule their life so that they can be on for a whole hour exactly when Venan says you should. The rest of the timed events you can still get 80% of the rewards if you can just dump your e in the right time frame with having to be on the whole time. I'm not running the numbers, but with this event, you get less than 50%.
Without completely throwing out the event (my personal opinion), what can you all do? The biggest are to play with the numbers so they make sense and reduce the drop scaling between the incursion portal levels.
Also, I know you are going to release another T21 piece. May I suggest it be Cloak, Boots or Gloves. I'm fearful you are going to do T21 Weapon. That will get enormous backlash for two reasons. First, the hate towards this event because it has always been completely unfarmable especially if you have any kind of lif.. Second, even though I am not a fan of PvP, I realize that a T21 event weapon with no regularly farmable T20 will completely unbalance the PvP world. The same could be said about OS raids too.
1. The upfront purchase of the Pumpkin Basket or the whole event is completely hopeless.
2. But the event is hopeless anyway. I have calculated before. If I paid for the basket, didn't sleep, didn't work, and hit every event optimally even with max e regen enchants, I couldn't buy the top item without extra GS. The math has been bad every year.
3. It badly discriminates against lower e players since the rewards scale up based on the amount of e used.
4. It badly discriminates against players who can't schedule their life so that they can be on for a whole hour exactly when Venan says you should. The rest of the timed events you can still get 80% of the rewards if you can just dump your e in the right time frame with having to be on the whole time. I'm not running the numbers, but with this event, you get less than 50%.
Without completely throwing out the event (my personal opinion), what can you all do? The biggest are to play with the numbers so they make sense and reduce the drop scaling between the incursion portal levels.
Also, I know you are going to release another T21 piece. May I suggest it be Cloak, Boots or Gloves. I'm fearful you are going to do T21 Weapon. That will get enormous backlash for two reasons. First, the hate towards this event because it has always been completely unfarmable especially if you have any kind of lif.. Second, even though I am not a fan of PvP, I realize that a T21 event weapon with no regularly farmable T20 will completely unbalance the PvP world. The same could be said about OS raids too.