Book of Heroes

Suggestion Stub, Elixir of Intensity & Void replace Power

Bj_Knows

ModeratorThu Sep 22, 2016 12:51 pm
Subject
Suggestion Stub, Elixir of Intensity & Void replace Power

Remove Elixir of Power

add

Elixir of Precision* (Crit percentage +20%, not crit rating but actual crit percentage, like Potion of Critical Strike 20%)

Elixir of the Void** (+25% speed of periodic damage, +25% ability cool downs including initial cool down)

Elixir of Intensity (+25% amount of periodic damage like Turmoil or Favor of Intensity)

Elixir of Avoidance (Dodge percentage +20%, not dodge rating but actual dodge percentage, like Potion of Dodge 20%)

Elixir of Status (Status Resist +30%, Crit Resist +30%, Knockback Resist +30%)

*Instead of Elixir of Precision could be Elixir of Deadly Precision (Crit +20% and Crit Power +20%, not ratings but actual percentage, like Chocolate)

**Instead of Elixir of the Void, or in addition to, Haste Buffs could be changed to affect speed of periodic damage and initial cool downs.

MY PERSONAL OPINION
Ever since they nerfed Elixir of Power from percentage (like Spinach) to rating percentage (like Weapon Focus), Elixir of Power is worthless for 98% of all characters.

Shadow Walker BarbSpice is almost 5 years old and I cannot get myself to switch her to Death Wish rank 3 with all Defense enchants. I like playing a dodgy shadow walker with insane levels of health instead of the Health Bar 25% required to run Death Wish 3 all the time (Note 1). So she depends on Poison Cloud and Smoke Bomb. She cannot use Elixir of Speed, because her rotation depends heavily on periodic damage and knockback. If she uses Elixir of Speed, the periodic damage from Poison Cloud never happens and her Smoke Bomb 3 never comes out of initial cool down for her to knockback the monsters. She ends up substituting a lot of basic attacks which do little damage compared to Poison Cloud rank 3, Acid Spray rank 3, Smoke Bomb rank 3 and Poison Cloud rank 3 of her normal rotation.

I have also nicknamed my character Crystal a "Slow Knight" (Note 2), with the Frost Knight's slow, weak ice attack reducing dodge and haste, while Devastate and Flurry add periodic damage, Crystal could greatly benefit from Elixir of Void, Intensity and *Dodge* while she waits for her periodic damage to kill the monsters.

Note 1)
I make an exception for the Crypt of Corruption Raid

Note 2)
Bj_Knows wrote:
FK are the class that could really use a 0.5s periodic damage tick or a knockback group ability or a 1.0s Defend.

Both SW & FK would be helped if Haste Buffs affected periodic damage ticks. Ex: Ekixir of Speed would reduce periodic damage tick to 0.85s .
Frost Knight

Illy_the_Red

ModeratorThu Sep 22, 2016 4:59 pm
Elixir of Power aside (tried it on my Frost Knight and it seemed to make very little difference - surprising on a little toon below 10k)...

Without Death Wish, SW powers lack any punch. The 50% damage buff brings you up to roughly the same damage as 2H weapons while retaining the speed. If you're using a poison build, you should rarely run out of attacks even with speed elixirs/haste potions. With Poison Cloud, Toxic Blade, Acid Spray, the neurotoxin one (can't remember the name), and maybe one melee ability (I use reflexive - helps finish if you don't have a quick ability to hand), you should be able to handle SQ and TSR P2 easily provided you have Defence enchants levelled well. If you don't have Defence enchanted...why?! TSR P3 is trickier but doable, at least at level 36. From what I've heard as you level it gets crazy and nobody wants to do it until Venan rebalance the dodgy enemy scaling.

For Karnak and LoB, poison will work but I prefer melee. With speed elixirs and death wish you rip through it, or should. Death Wish is integral to onslaught for SWs, without it you're literally sacrificing 50% damage.

Outside of OS you can easily manage with poison or melee builds whether on DW or not, it just takes a little longer (more button presses) with melee.
Illy_the_Red wrote:Elixir of Power aside (tried it on my Frost Knight and it seemed to make very little difference .

My Frost Knight with elixir of power struggled more and took longer than my 1 hand inquisitor to clear a pirate wave using the same weapon.
Alienigen wrote:
Illy_the_Red wrote:Elixir of Power aside (tried it on my Frost Knight and it seemed to make very little difference .

My Frost Knight with elixir of power struggled more and took longer than my 1 hand inquisitor to clear a pirate wave using the same weapon.
Elixer of power works great as long as your magic/melee rating is lower than 80% of the soft cap. Nobody actually runs so few magic/melee rating so all rating you gain is rating above the soft cap meaning it is more like increasing your damage by 5%. This value will go up a bit when you reach insane magic/melee ratings of 15k+.