Book of Heroes

The life and death of a Guild?

When the Guilds first arrived it was first come first served, so the membership was fairly random. The occasional players eventually dropped out or got booted to Guilds better suited to their laid back style, while the busy raiding Guilds recruited new members to suit their needs.

We tried to ensure over the weeks following the intial Day of Guilds (23rd May) that we had people from around the world, so we could run raids 24 hours a day. Unfortunately, not knowing how the raid system would progress, and that you need a lot of people to complete the later raids, this has ultimately worked against us, almost to the point of killing our Guild progress.

It doesn't help for speed runs or for regular raiding if 1/3 of your membership are asleep at any given time. We can only raid successfully in the early morning or late evening, to ensure that Europeans, Asians and those from the Amnericas all have a chance to contribute. Dayytime raids have failed consistently, and middle of the night raids ditto.

If I was starting a Guild from scratch now I would now recruit only from a limited timezone span, in my case the USA East to West Coast. Several newer guilds have already taken that line, with one looking for Australian players, another the Singapore/Malaysia timezone. This should lead to greater success in speed runs (which we hadn't anticipated) and regular high level raids requiring 25-30 players to complete comfortably.

Our loyal Guild Members, many having been with us since day 1, are loath to leave to find a Guild better suited to their available raid times, but it may be inevitable.
I understand this, but is it REALLY fair to ruin the whole dynamic of having people from all around the world,
just to get some extra silver and valor? I personally think this problem could be fixed by someone in your guild taking a kind of survey of who's available when, and then using the information to figure out some times when more people are playing. That is, if you really care that much about the timing.



Eowyn :D
( AKA CR_LionHeartFlame)