Book of Heroes

Flame warden

Bbbb wrote:Mostly physical. You have to take Flame Net though.

Don't forget the high physical resistance of end game monsters. But for PvP I think physical is best
Kenner wrote:
Don't forget the high physical resistance of end game monsters.

That is way overstated (maybe by SWs since that class just sucks). My justicar slices and dices them just fine.

Illy_the_Red

ModeratorThu Sep 29, 2016 5:05 pm
Bbbb wrote:
Kenner wrote:
Don't forget the high physical resistance of end game monsters.

That is way overstated (maybe by SWs since that class just sucks). My justicar slices and dices them just fine.

It's pure experience and I suspect he meant certain phases. Since TSR's inception the final boss in particular has had very high phys resist. p3 boss in SQ does too. You can do great damage in both of those with SW poison builds, but with melee, you suck even on DW. The way it used to be (before Venan realised it was OP), it was very difficult to use melee vs the TSR bosses (mainly P3, the P2 just required more hits rather than being dangerous). You needed multiple elixirs just to make it possible.

Justicars I'm sure have their ways with melee. Completely different class with different abilities, doubt I'll try it as my high might justicar is Magic like the majority these days.
To lly I've been doing os in tsr on p2 I get somewhere around 650 with my max justicar which is pretty great but that's also always using a haste pot and a max spirit build. Now my physical sw with lvl 7/8 offense enchants gets over 500 with a physical build and almost full pvp gear. So I actually think sw at low levels are better than justicar.

Illy_the_Red

ModeratorFri Sep 30, 2016 5:22 am
BBQ_Salad wrote:To lly I've been doing os in tsr on p2 I get somewhere around 650 with my max justicar which is pretty great but that's also always using a haste pot and a max spirit build. Now my physical sw with lvl 7/8 offense enchants gets over 500 with a physical build and almost full pvp gear. So I actually think sw at low levels are better than justicar.

Maybe so. It's not however worth whacking away with physical SW builds when an equal poison one will always be better. Things were worse when the raid first dropped but it still isn't equal. It doesn't make sense to have boss enemies built to be anti-melee when that hasn't happened anywhere else in the game. I certainly can't see them dropping a raid where they have obscene magic resist. They'd never make their favourite class suck at a raid.
Illy_the_Red wrote:I certainly can't see them dropping a raid where they have obscene magic resist.

There is no such thing as magic resist. There are fire, ice, nature and spirit. There are raids where they come into play.
Illy_the_Red wrote:It doesn't make sense to have boss enemies built to be anti-melee when that hasn't happened anywhere else in the game.

I'm pretty sure that Man Bear Pig is anti-melee. I'm sure having a lot more trouble against it with melee at the moment.

Illy_the_Red

ModeratorFri Sep 30, 2016 6:00 pm
Bbbb wrote:
Illy_the_Red wrote:I certainly can't see them dropping a raid where they have obscene magic resist.

There is no such thing as magic resist. There are fire, ice, nature and spirit. There are raids where they come into play.
Illy_the_Red wrote:It doesn't make sense to have boss enemies built to be anti-melee when that hasn't happened anywhere else in the game.

I'm pretty sure that Man Bear Pig is anti-melee. I'm sure having a lot more trouble against it with melee at the moment.

Except the magic and physical resist gems? There are bosses with very high resistance to physical damage - SQ P3 and TSR P2-3.

Never had any issue with the bearpig taking damage. It was the damage he did to you that made him very hard. Don't think any of my magic or melee based builds on any class struggled with him though. New classes probably will because people massively over-levelled them, so the scaling will have you fighting way tougher enemies than you should.