There are currently 2133 Guilds on the Guild list. 1989 of them have not managed a successful raid in a month or more. They are dead Guilds.
The vast majority of those have just one member, someone who started the game, got to Lvl 4, created their Guild, lost interest, and no longer plays the game.
The rest contain many Guilds which have blocked auto-accept (why would a new Guild do that???), but have no active GM or Officers (or probably players), so nobody can join to try to get the Guild going again.
The new Shield cost for creating a Guild will go some way towards reducing the continued growth of these dead guilds, but is it time to have a clear out?
I suggest to Venan that there should be a clean out of these inactive Guilds, in this order:
1) any 1 man Guilds are deleted if the GM has been inactive for a month or more.
2) Any Guild with more than 1 player, but none active for at least a month, be deleted.
3) Any Guilds with zero power (so not actively raiding in the last month) and auto-accept off has auto-accept set to on.
Possibly in addition, all lvl 4 Characters that have been inactive for 2 months be deleted. If a player wishes to return, it takes only an hour or so to get to lvl 4 with a new character.
This would reduce the Guild list to less than 200, of which about 144 are actually going somewhere, albeit at their own pace. This, combined with the new GS cost for creating a Guild under 1.4.0, should encourage players to join the existing active Guilds, not clog up the list with hopeless cases. New Guilds can still be created by existing players as 5 GS is not such a burden to an active daily player.
The vast majority of those have just one member, someone who started the game, got to Lvl 4, created their Guild, lost interest, and no longer plays the game.
The rest contain many Guilds which have blocked auto-accept (why would a new Guild do that???), but have no active GM or Officers (or probably players), so nobody can join to try to get the Guild going again.
The new Shield cost for creating a Guild will go some way towards reducing the continued growth of these dead guilds, but is it time to have a clear out?
I suggest to Venan that there should be a clean out of these inactive Guilds, in this order:
1) any 1 man Guilds are deleted if the GM has been inactive for a month or more.
2) Any Guild with more than 1 player, but none active for at least a month, be deleted.
3) Any Guilds with zero power (so not actively raiding in the last month) and auto-accept off has auto-accept set to on.
Possibly in addition, all lvl 4 Characters that have been inactive for 2 months be deleted. If a player wishes to return, it takes only an hour or so to get to lvl 4 with a new character.
This would reduce the Guild list to less than 200, of which about 144 are actually going somewhere, albeit at their own pace. This, combined with the new GS cost for creating a Guild under 1.4.0, should encourage players to join the existing active Guilds, not clog up the list with hopeless cases. New Guilds can still be created by existing players as 5 GS is not such a burden to an active daily player.