Book of Heroes

Thank You

Thank you for listening to concerns of your player base and responding. The Valentine event is much improved.
The t20 upgraded sword DOES require you to transfer enchants. It also looks exactly like the old one when worn. My understanding is that before the fix it simply replaced the old one. Not any more. I just put an old T19 axe back on as the transfer cost is not worth it to me (2 diamond gravers).
Dnillik wrote:Thank you for listening to concerns of your player base and responding. The Valentine event is much improved.

+1

Fluxing_Lucky_Phåse

Sun Feb 19, 2017 11:45 pm
De_Gallis wrote:The t20 upgraded sword DOES require you to transfer enchants. It also looks exactly like the old one when worn. My understanding is that before the fix it simply replaced the old one. Not any more. I just put an old T19 axe back on as the transfer cost is not worth it to me (2 diamond gravers).

The upgraded sword is stronger than the axe and faster. Just an FYI ;)

Also the "replacement" was a bug. It consumed the sword and the enchants on it, meaning you lost the enchants. So to prevent losing the enchants you still had to remove them before crafting the upgraded sword.

Either way, have fun.

JasmynthTheEldest

Mon Feb 20, 2017 9:52 am
The point of the complaint now, which I am not making, only explaining my understanding of it, is that an upgrade from t19 to t20 is worth it ONLY if is an actual upgrade, not a new weapon. That is, the enchants need to be automatically transfered -- or rather, that the stats for the weapon as you currently wield it should be changed from t19 to t20. We are, after all, buying the original weapon, buying the recipe, earning the Despair, crafting the Liquid Misery, then EMPOWERING the old weapon to make it better. The point is that there should be no transfer costs because we aren't making/buying a new weapon, we are improving an old one. The secondary part of this argument is that the improvement in the weapon stats from t19 to t20 is insufficient to justify the expense of the transfer. The assumption of that part of the argument is that an upgrade from t19 to t21 would be worth it, and effort/time/expense of working on the upgrade from t19 to t20 is all we should be asked to spend for the single digit improvement.
Again, this is my understanding of an argument that I am not myself making -- I happen to think the improvement is worth the cost of the transfer, but those costs aren't really an issue for me ATM, and they are for some. It is an argument I can understand and sympathize with, however. I think making this event an any-time raid is more than enough of an improvement over the timed window dungeon fest -- especially with the goodie drops thrown in -- to make me more than willing to part with some of my hoarded resources for the increased efficacy of my preferred weapon type. If you'd rather use an axe, or you happen to be strapped for upgrade resources, you likely feel differently. The gripe comes because of the feeling that an upgrade to a already existing weapon should indeed upgrade the already existing weapon, not create a new one -- after all, Venan didn't really create a new one, or invest resources in creating a new weapon; why should we?
JasmynthTheEldest wrote:the upgrade from t19 to t20 is all we should be asked to spend for the single digit improvement.

I didn't calculate it out, but the min damage of the 1H increased for 15xx to 18xx as I recall. That's around 20% - not even close to single digit.

JasmynthTheEldest

Mon Feb 20, 2017 10:09 pm
Last I checked, 19 was one (single) number removed from 20. That's the single digit improvement to which I referred -- the tiers. I admit I did not express myself as clearly as I could have.

You make an excellent, point, the increase in combat effectiveness is measurable, and not in "single digit" range. In fact, as you'll note, I believe the costs of the transfer to be worth it and reasonable. My point is that others do not -- and they have a legitimate point, since other upgrades requiring transfers are usually two tier jumps, not single tier steps.

Illy_the_Red

ModeratorTue Feb 21, 2017 7:29 am
JasmynthTheEldest wrote:Last I checked, 19 was one (single) number removed from 20. That's the single digit improvement to which I referred -- the tiers. I admit I did not express myself as clearly as I could have.

You make an excellent, point, the increase in combat effectiveness is measurable, and not in "single digit" range. In fact, as you'll note, I believe the costs of the transfer to be worth it and reasonable. My point is that others do not -- and they have a legitimate point, since other upgrades requiring transfers are usually two tier jumps, not single tier steps.

Which in turn leads to the question of why this new weapon is T20 instead of 21, when all of the previous new event gear was 21. Clearly there's a reason for holding the weapons back, I'd just like to hear it.
I obviously have no clue, but I do believe the PvPers would have gone crazy with more imbalance issues. And likely would be correct. I wish it had gone to T21 just to keep the consistency.