One guild member asked for my opinion on whether the unstable valentines gems are "worth it." My answer is "perhaps." It depends on the toon and your goals. I begin with a numerical analysis. Those bored with the numbers can skip to conclusion.
Let me take the gems on my ring for example. Suppose I have two magic, a crit, and a crit power, all at t7. They will add 2588 to my magic total, 1294 to my crit and 1176 to my crit power. Suppose I exchange the yellow t7 for a t8. My crit goes up to 1479 but my crit power goes down to 1059. My crit power goes down less than my crit goes up.
That number obviously translates directly to a toon's might, but it does not directly affect game play. For me, the arrangement with the t7 gems gives me a crit chance of 37.42% and crit power damage of 188.18%. Swapping to an unstable yellow gem gives me a crit chance of 37.65% and crit power damage of 188.06%. The difference is barely noticeable, because of the way the game applies the law of diminishing returns.
What happens if I replace both red gems with t8? My crit chance drops from 37.42% down to 37.08%. But my magic damage adjustment rises from 2927 to 2970. That's still a minor shift but I'll take it.
Conclusion
So, who is benefitted by these gems? I see three types of toons that benefit:
1. Toons that don't already have t7. My frost knight and inquisitor both have a lot of t5 gems, and the addition of t8 quickly boosts their abilities.
2. Toons that want to have the maximum might. The current maximum is 102,203, and it can only be achieved by toons with a 2-handed weapon who have 27 unstable t8 gems and 9 t14 resist gems. Incidentally, that build is terrible for game play. The only reason to do it is to show that you have maxed.
3. Toons trying to stretch out the last bit of performance. For those I would focus on red and yellow gems and not use blue t8 gems. The penalty to the melee/magic gems is not worth it.
Derrin_Watson wrote:
3. Toons trying to stretch out the last bit of performance. For those I would focus on red and yellow gems and not use blue t8 gems. The penalty to the melee/magic gems is not worth it.
MY PERSONAL OPINION
I agree. But I would also avoid T8 Unstable Haste Gems.
Crit and Dodge are useful because of the way Crit & Dodge react to your opponent's level, so versus a L41 Monster/ PvP Opponent T8 Unstable Gems may be of help. As a bonus, Blue Gems are reduced by Unstable Yellow, but Blue Gems Stats have the smallest reaction to reduction by Unstable Gems. So Unstable Crit and Unstable Dodge give you the best return on your spending.
Haste has very little change from T7 Gems to T8 Unstable because of its stat curve. So Unstable Haste Gems give the smallest return on your spending of the nine stats.
Bj_Knows wrote:Subject
T7.15 Tragick Dodge Gem in Black Market
Tragick Dodge gems (180 GS, +16 Dodge Multiplier, -10% to Blue gems in same gear per Yellow Tragick gem in same gear) are currently available in the Black Market (2d left, 20:05 Server Time Saturday July 30).
MY PERSONAL OPINION
I am buying one for my Inquisitor, Frost Knight & Flame Warden.
While not as good as T7 Dodge/ Luck gems from the Lucky event, Tragick Dodge gems are a good deal.
Blue gems already have an unusual stat curve, Crit Power especially, so are less effected by Tragick gems. This makes Tragick yellow gems the least penalized compared to red & blue.
Crit gems need Crit Power gems to be effective. T7 Haste Gems are already close to effective haste because haste stat curve is unaffected by level. So Tragick Dodge gems are the most effective of the Tragick yellow gems.
Deathwing Raiders(with Raid Schedule)
Bj_Knows wrote:Derrin_Watson wrote:
3. Toons trying to stretch out the last bit of performance. For those I would focus on red and yellow gems and not use blue t8 gems. The penalty to the melee/magic gems is not worth it.
MY PERSONAL OPINION
I agree. But I would also avoid T8 Unstable Haste Gems.
Crit and Dodge are useful because of the way Crit & Dodge react to your opponent's level, so versus a L41 Monster/ PvP Opponent T8 Unstable Gems may be of help. As a bonus, Blue Gems are reduced by Unstable Yellow, but Blue Gems Stats have the smallest reaction to reduction by Unstable Gems. So Unstable Crit and Unstable Dodge give you the best return on your spending.
Haste has very little change from T7 Gems to T8 Unstable because of its stat curve. So Unstable Haste Gems give the smallest return on your spending of the nine stats.Bj_Knows wrote:Subject
T7.15 Tragick Dodge Gem in Black Market
Tragick Dodge gems (180 GS, +16 Dodge Multiplier, -10% to Blue gems in same gear per Yellow Tragick gem in same gear) are currently available in the Black Market (2d left, 20:05 Server Time Saturday July 30).
MY PERSONAL OPINION
I am buying one for my Inquisitor, Frost Knight & Flame Warden.
While not as good as T7 Dodge/ Luck gems from the Lucky event, Tragick Dodge gems are a good deal.
Blue gems already have an unusual stat curve, Crit Power especially, so are less effected by Tragick gems. This makes Tragick yellow gems the least penalized compared to red & blue.
Crit gems need Crit Power gems to be effective. T7 Haste Gems are already close to effective haste because haste stat curve is unaffected by level. So Tragick Dodge gems are the most effective of the Tragick yellow gems.
Deathwing Raiders(with Raid Schedule)
Haste gem should be bought with caution, calculate wether you needed the t8s to push you right beyond the point where you want to be. In my case i use t8 so i free up a slot for crit/dodge
Derrin_Watson wrote:
3. Toons trying to stretch out the last bit of performance. For those I would focus on red and yellow gems and not use blue t8 gems. The penalty to the melee/magic gems is not worth it.
If you are buying a Tragick Dodge gem with 100% GS (spending GS to buy candy hearts), the Black Market currently has it cheaper (180 GS vs 400 GS)
Bj_Knows wrote:
If you are buying a Tragick Dodge gem with 100% GS (spending GS to buy candy hearts), the Black Market currently has it cheaper (180 GS vs 400 GS)
My goodness. Why on earth would you spend 400 gs on any of these? Hearts will go away. Use it or lose it. But not for gs. This comes from a man who has a lot of empty wagons parked in back of the house. 400 gs will buy 50 large e pots, 1200 e.
Go back to my list of those benefitted by these gems. If you have level 5 or level 4 gems and want a fast buff for gs, spend 150 gs and get an unbroken t7 from the black market. If you're trying to stretch out the last bit of performance for an already well equipped toon, 400 gs just isn't worth it. And if that one gem is all that stands between you and 102,203 might, I guess you can revel in your completion, but at such a cost! What price vanity?
Derrin_Watson wrote: And if that one gem is all that stands between you and 102,203 might, I guess you can revel in your completion, but at such a cost! What price vanity?
I'm sitting at a few hundred thousands experience points and 9 blue unstables from maxing I think. No way I am spending any GS on any blue regardless of the price just for the vanity.
I wonder what's the max useful might. Around 90K now? I don't have enough lucky gems to know exactly.
Derrin_Watson wrote:Bj_Knows wrote:
If you are buying a Tragick Dodge gem with 100% GS (spending GS to buy candy hearts), the Black Market currently has it cheaper (180 GS vs 400 GS)
My goodness. Why on earth would you spend 400 gs on any of these? Hearts will go away. Use it or lose it. But not for gs. This comes from a man who has a lot of empty wagons parked in back of the house. 400 gs will buy 50 large e pots, 1200 e.
If you are just starting a character, buying a Tier 6 Gem, Seasonal Tier 7 Gem or Seasonal Tier 8 Gem can save you lots of silver, GS and Valor since you do not have to purchase the lower Tier Gems:
Bj_Knows wrote:Question: What should I buy with my IAP GS?
MY PERSONAL OPINION
Answer:
If you decide to us In App Purchase to get Gold Shields, I recommend the following priorities
[$$$$] Wallet Warriors
I understand and agree BJ. But can you justify for such a player the differential between paying 150 GS for a t7 and 400 GS for an unstable t8? I cannot.