There's another solution that's a bit less drastic that I already proposed to Kal and he's looking into that would essentially eliminate farming. Have all mats earned in a raid be banked until the completion of the raid. If the raid is cancelled, you receive nothing earned from that raid, if it fails you only receive 25%(or so) of what you earned. I'm sure more than a few will find this wildly unpopular but it will encourage people to join active guilds or participate in raids that are actually trying to be completed.
Now that everyone had benefited from farming.
No consideration for other players thats still growing?
All of a suddend farming is being frown upon?
No offense to anyone here.
Somethings can be easily solved and still keep everyone happy.
guild can always do open raids , why force someone to join another guild ?
For your own selfish needs of guild points?
1) removal of the penalty in points for guild that open merc slots
2) increases merc slots for the raids
Top players max enchanting may not need to farm as they will need the new valor to grow.
But pls do consider newer/growing players that still need to farm to get max enchantments.
Not that i need those farming raids anyway.
But do think of others too.
Thank you