Book of Heroes

Changes to raids

I've got a couple suggestions on raids. First, I think that a failed raid should still give a small fraction of the valor (depending on how far along the guild got). It is very frustration to put hours into a raid and have it fail at the last minute. While the reward should be a small amount compared to a completed raid, it should be something.

Second, I think that stronger characters should be more useful on raids. Other that having more initial energy due to Sigils, and being able to kill a bit faster, they don't make as big a difference on a raid as they should. I don't know exactly what changes would be good, but I really think a lvl 25 player should be of more value to completing a raid than a lvl 15 who has the same Sigils.
BlackTao wrote:I've got a couple suggestions on raids. First, I think that a failed raid should still give a small fraction of the valor (depending on how far along the guild got). It is very frustration to put hours into a raid and have it fail at the last minute. While the reward should be a small amount compared to a completed raid, it should be something.

Second, I think that stronger characters should be more useful on raids. Other that having more initial energy due to Sigils, and being able to kill a bit faster, they don't make as big a difference on a raid as they should. I don't know exactly what changes would be good, but I really think a lvl 25 player should be of more value to completing a raid than a lvl 15 who has the same Sigils.

Firstly, the point of making the raids 'do or die' is to encourage guilds to coordinate better and recruit more. Secondly, in the upcoming update the onslaught mode will allow stronger players to spread their wings and get more rewards from their energy :)
Grr. Hate when it crashes and loses my long comment entry. Sigh.

Anyway, onslaught sounds good. Can't wait to try it out and see how it plays!

I still disagree on do-or-die/all-or-nothing. Giving a small (10%?) valor for a failed raid would not significantly impact the desire to win raids. It would actually help raid participation, as some ppl will not join a raid that "looks likely to fail". Or will stop contributing to it. After all, why spend your valuable real world time on grinding that isn't rewarded.

Another option would be to give partial valor for each complete phase of a raid. For example, in a 3phase raid, phase 1 gives 25%, phase 2 gives 25%, phase 3 gives 50% (25% + completion bonus of 25%). So, we get some reward for participating, but much more if we are in all phases and the raid is successful.

Obviously, %ages can be tweaked, this is just a basic example.

And, I'll wait to see how onslaught changes things. Maybe it will become moot, if the stronger players can have more impact on raid success. :-)

-BlackTao