Book of Heroes

Guild Member Badges of Honor

I think badges of honor would be a good way to reward guild members that are particularly helpful. Specifically, I would like to see one badge for top-ten performance and another badge for raid attendance. The badges would be awarded and taken away on a weekly basis, based on the previous week's raids.

For the top-ten badge, the server would calculate the percentage of succesful raids in which each raider participated where they finished in the top ten. The percentages for all the guild members would be lined up, and those characters above the median percentage would be awarded the top-ten performer badge.

For the attendance badge, the server would keep track of which Might-capable raiders did and did not participate at the time of each raid in the guild. At the end of the week, it would calculate the percentage of guild raids for which the player was Might-capable that they attended. Again, the percentages would be lined up, and those above the median would win a badge for the week.

Here is an example. Let's say that my guild ran 20 raids last week, but I only had sufficient Might at the time to be eligible for 18 of them. I actually joined 12 raids, and 10 of them succeeded. I placed in the top ten on 8 of the 10 successful raids. My top-ten performer score is 8/10, or 80%. My attendance score is 12/18, or 66%. The medians for my guild are, say, 50% for top-ten performer score and 75% for attendance. I would earn a top-ten performer badge for the week (80%>50%), but not an attendance badge (66%<75%).

As conceived, this system works best for guilds with stable membership that raid regularly. I am not sure how the calculations would work for mercs or for people that shuttle between two or more guilds, such as farm teams. I also am not sure that the badges would be as useful for guilds that raid less than a minimum number of times a week.
More than just rewards, these badges could be instrumental in guild management. They divide the guild population into four categories:

* Guild members that have both badges are the core of the guild. If any of them leave, the guild will suffer.

* Characters with just the top-ten badge are the eagles that swoop in for victory and then are gone. They are either mercs or people that the GM should talk with about raid schedule conflicts.

* Characters with just the participation badge are the steady turtles. With mentoring, they have the best chance of becoming core members.

* Characters that consistently do not have either badge should reevaluate whether they are a good fit for this particular guild.
I like this idea, as it would give guildmasters more readily available information on members and their performance, which at present is difficult to assess (unless one were to keep track of RPP totals outside the game for up to 60 people, which would be a significant undertaking in itself). As with my own ideas on similar themes, however, the difficulty would lie in how to handle mercs and merc-ing, if that's a word. :) A 24-hour grace period might be one way.

Another thought would be to allow the guildmaster to give out an additional badge, at his own discretion, for saving a raid; this badge could move around from player to player depending on who was the last one to be critically important in that respect.

These badges could also show up when a person's name is tapped in chat, as little icons. Bragging rights reign supreme among some segments of any MMO, and this mechanic would prove no different in that regard.