"A little competition is good for the soul."
- Captain Enrique Montoya
This idea is the result of a combination of thoughts from a discussion with my guildmate SirHumble, one of Pfaff's posts regarding the expansion of "guild roles" in 1.4, and the GPP mechanic from my very first post.
Currently, all members of a guild receive the full benefit of all favors earned, regardless of how much or how little they contribute. Grading individual members within the guild by raid participation would allow for an interesting new dynamic, motivating players to show up for raids, and promoting a healthy sense of competition.
GPP (Guild Participation Points) would be the total RPP earned by a character, decaying over time in the same way overall guild power does currently (though perhaps less frequently, once a week instead of once a day, to cushion work requirements and weekend playtime). Guild members would be divided up into three tiers: lowest 50% (Squires), 50-75% (Soldiers), and top 25% (Knights), and favors would be reduced in some way for Squires and Soldiers. This could be done in two ways:
1) Divide Favors into the same tiers. Squires would get half the favors the guild has earned, Soldiers would get three-quarters, and Knights would get them all, starting from the first favor earned, the health bonus. Each tier would have at least one more favor than the last tier, if possible, but working backwards: thus, in a guild with only two favors, Knights and Soldiers would have the benefit of both, while Squires just got the first.
2) Squires, Soldiers, and Knights would all get the same favors, but they would work at a lower effectiveness for Squires and Soldiers: a +5% bonus for Knights would be a +3% bonus for Soldiers, and a +1% bonus for Squires. This is less appealing than the first option, as guild members would have to tune gem allocation to a more finicky degree as they moved up (or down) the tiers.
Further tweaking could add a consideration of guild roles: the guildmaster would be rated as a Knight regardless of actual GPP; officers would be rated as Soldiers unless they qualified to be Knights, Veterans and regular members would simply be rated as their GPP required, and Recruits would be unable to rise above Squire (or Soldier).
Of course, as GPP would have to be reset to zero when a character joined another guild, this would drastically decrease merc availability - barring a decision by Venan to recognize mercs in-game and provide a mechanic for helping with a raid without leaving one's own guild, as Jetras suggested. A workaround could involve a delay of 24 hours in a GPP reset, or earning GPP in a new guild.
- Captain Enrique Montoya
This idea is the result of a combination of thoughts from a discussion with my guildmate SirHumble, one of Pfaff's posts regarding the expansion of "guild roles" in 1.4, and the GPP mechanic from my very first post.
Currently, all members of a guild receive the full benefit of all favors earned, regardless of how much or how little they contribute. Grading individual members within the guild by raid participation would allow for an interesting new dynamic, motivating players to show up for raids, and promoting a healthy sense of competition.
GPP (Guild Participation Points) would be the total RPP earned by a character, decaying over time in the same way overall guild power does currently (though perhaps less frequently, once a week instead of once a day, to cushion work requirements and weekend playtime). Guild members would be divided up into three tiers: lowest 50% (Squires), 50-75% (Soldiers), and top 25% (Knights), and favors would be reduced in some way for Squires and Soldiers. This could be done in two ways:
1) Divide Favors into the same tiers. Squires would get half the favors the guild has earned, Soldiers would get three-quarters, and Knights would get them all, starting from the first favor earned, the health bonus. Each tier would have at least one more favor than the last tier, if possible, but working backwards: thus, in a guild with only two favors, Knights and Soldiers would have the benefit of both, while Squires just got the first.
2) Squires, Soldiers, and Knights would all get the same favors, but they would work at a lower effectiveness for Squires and Soldiers: a +5% bonus for Knights would be a +3% bonus for Soldiers, and a +1% bonus for Squires. This is less appealing than the first option, as guild members would have to tune gem allocation to a more finicky degree as they moved up (or down) the tiers.
Further tweaking could add a consideration of guild roles: the guildmaster would be rated as a Knight regardless of actual GPP; officers would be rated as Soldiers unless they qualified to be Knights, Veterans and regular members would simply be rated as their GPP required, and Recruits would be unable to rise above Squire (or Soldier).
Of course, as GPP would have to be reset to zero when a character joined another guild, this would drastically decrease merc availability - barring a decision by Venan to recognize mercs in-game and provide a mechanic for helping with a raid without leaving one's own guild, as Jetras suggested. A workaround could involve a delay of 24 hours in a GPP reset, or earning GPP in a new guild.