Book of Heroes

Venan you need to re-evaluate dodge and block for Justicars.

I have a fairly high level Justicar in a top 5 guild. All the top Justicars in our guild are becoming increasingly frustrated with the dodge and block mechanics in this game. It is especially bad during the Onslaught raids. My mid 7k might SW can outperform my 9300 might Justicar easily. That shouldn't happen. The issue is all the dodging and blocking. There is nothing more frustrating than having attacks blocked or dodged 2 or more times on the same enemy and that happens frequently. Beyond that there are just too many blocks and dodges for a Justicar to play efficiently and no mechanic in the game to reduce it. It's is totally random and to get decent RPP on a round requires pure luck, there is no skill involved. We have Justicar players considering moving to another class or just quitting the game entirely. Please make some adjustment to the game to make things more fair for Justicars.

I never had a major issue with blocking and dodging until after the Felmarsh addition. As the game progresses now, and especially with the higher level raids, it just seems to be getting worse and worse. I am also considering switching to my SW even though, until now, I have really enjoyed my Justicar the most.

FreyaYuledottir

ModeratorSun Aug 5, 2012 2:52 pm
Even as an sw, I'd like see new stat or some old stat adjusted so, that it'll rise character change to hit, or more likely prevent enemies dodging or blocking player's attacks.

Celestial_Cavalier

ModeratorSun Aug 5, 2012 3:12 pm
I agree with this one. After 1.4 came out I noticed my Justicar is missing and being blocked/dodged quite a lot. The worst was yesterday when I missed 7 straight times while fighting Ironhaven Collossus.
I don't have that problem cause I'm a SW that mostly uses magic but when I'm not using magic I get annoyed by it so I can only imagine how frustrating that would be for a justicar it really needs to be changed
I understand that some might argue that physical attacks being dodge-able is necessary for balance issues. However, isn't the best test for balance amongst the classes an assessment of performance of similar might chars in say the new onslaught raids? Apparently 7k might sw/wm can EASILY achieve a min of 750rpp bonus in the first 2 waves. In fact, it is usually more like 900-1050 being the average. On the other hand, 7k might justicars have it way harder, doing more like 600/750-900 on average. In "bad luck" cases when your attacks keep getting dodged, it might even be lower. This "random-ness" of dodge-able attacks prevents justicars from enjoying onslaught as a test of "skill", but rather of "luck". :(
Another "balance issue" is that it appears to me that while the sw/wm can use the same build for all phases in the shadow comes raid, justicars have to choose between getting the aoe skills for first two phases, or getting smite for the boss phase. In other words, justicars have to choose between performing better in the first two phases, or during the boss phase. That said, I do not claim to be the most knowledgeable justicar around, and if any justicar has had a different experience in the onslaught raids, I beg of thee, do please share with us your secret to success! Thanks ;)
My main is a 'walker, but I agree that justicars have a legitimate complaint. A trainable stat, perhaps with an associated yellow or red gem, is called for - something like "accuracy" to reduce dodging, or "overwhelm" to negate blocks, or both.
I have lv 25 SW and he is great. Trying to level my Justicar (lv21) and it is so annoying. The blocking and dodging from monsters at higher levels is very frustrating. It has definitely sapped all the fun out of the Justicar, especially since I know how good a SW is because I used him first. I will get him to lv 25 eventually, but I won't enjoy it.
I'm not sure if this how combat ingame goes already, but perhaps having Crit take priority over enemy Dodges/Blocks would fix this. Like have the game first check if it will be a Critical attack, if so Crits always hit; if not a Critical attack, then checks enemy dodge/block to see if attack is dodged or blocked, if so then gets blockss or dodged, if not then continue as regular attack and lands. Should result in more hits when it counts, without having to add content or completely eliminate Dodge/Block mechanics.

Bj_Knows

ModeratorSun Aug 5, 2012 6:52 pm
Bojun wrote:I agree with this one. After 1.4 came out I noticed my Justicar is missing and being blocked/dodged quite a lot. The worst was yesterday when I missed 7 straight times while fighting Ironhaven Collossus.

Bojun,
I took your advice and got rid of half my Melee gems and replaced by Magic.

With 200+ Bonus Damage from Magic Stat, Radiant Light rank 1-3 does decent damage, always hits and has a short cool down.
Zuur went from very blocky & dodgy (CJ's words) to mincemeat as I use Divine Power rank 3, Radiant Light, Stunning Blow, Smite, Siesmic Slash rank 3, Defend, Radiant Light, Heroic Will rank 3, Divine Power rank 3, Radiant Light, Stunning Blow, Smite

The 200+ Bonus Damage also helps with Runes in Onslaught since they have zero combat time to use.

Bj_Knows

ModeratorSun Aug 5, 2012 7:00 pm
Marney wrote:My main is a 'walker, but I agree that justicars have a legitimate complaint. A trainable stat, perhaps with an associated yellow or red gem, is called for - something like "accuracy" to reduce dodging, or "overwhelm" to negate blocks, or both.

In v1.2 Melee attacks appeared to be a contest between dodge of the attacker & defender. The higher your dodge, the more often you successfully dodged an attack or hit a high dodge opponent.

I like the idea behind a dodge contest (even if I could not get a confirmation) because Crit & Dodge gems are both yellow, so you had to choose between more hits or more damage per hit.