I was going to post a feature suggestion, but I fear my suggestion is flawed (or just wishful thinking). So maybe we can discuss and refine it?
IDEA:
1) For any player with a VenanID (and presumably a name, like 'aiyardana' is my name), there can be an email target like "[email address removed]" that can receive email. So, I could open my standard email on my iPhone and address an email to my officers by their emails (derived from their names).
2) Emails sent to such a name would actually forward to the user's real world email account.
3) If I opened my real world email client and sent an email to a "boh_venan.com" email from an account that was tied to my VenanID, by the time the recipient got my message, my "from" name would translate into my VenanID name, so my privacy is still ensured. (e.g., the "from" says "[email address removed]")
4) The system can either ignore bad emails, or bounce everything that either comes from an unrecognized email, or is directed toward an invalid user.
Problems/challenges:
[not including technical implementation challenges, which I assume are non-trivial]
- Do these messages show up in game? I think not (ever).
- What about spam issues? Forcing senders to be valid VenanID holders would help.
- What about stalkers? Hmmm..
- Right now, you can edit your name, does that mean your boh_venan email changes? I think yes. It's not a "real" account. It's just a pass through. Any inbound emails to that address would just be lost.Tough cookies.
- Lost emails -- after all, you're talking three steps, the inbound, the translation, and the outbound. Chances of failure increase. Do we worry about these?
- Folks without VenanID? Yeah--seems like they're out for now, or they receive email with their Userxxxxxxxx name...
- Server down time -- after all, it's not a freaking email service!
WHAT DOES THIS SOLVE:
- Email just your officers (as long as you can type in their names). Not 100% helpful, but at least you'd have a workaround.
- This allows the in-game email to serve as more of an "announcement" function as well as a way to get updates about guild status, raids, and raid rewards. Keeps it simple. The devs should focus on the game, right?
- Developers don't have to replicate all the various complex requirements most people expect from email.
- User can use regular ol' email.
VARIATIONS:
I can think of tons of variations and ideas. But I'd be curious to know what others think. There seems to be a strong desire for a few features, like being able to email just guild officers. This would solve that. If there's really no other burning desire, this is overkill.
Thoughts?
IDEA:
1) For any player with a VenanID (and presumably a name, like 'aiyardana' is my name), there can be an email target like "[email address removed]" that can receive email. So, I could open my standard email on my iPhone and address an email to my officers by their emails (derived from their names).
2) Emails sent to such a name would actually forward to the user's real world email account.
3) If I opened my real world email client and sent an email to a "boh_venan.com" email from an account that was tied to my VenanID, by the time the recipient got my message, my "from" name would translate into my VenanID name, so my privacy is still ensured. (e.g., the "from" says "[email address removed]")
4) The system can either ignore bad emails, or bounce everything that either comes from an unrecognized email, or is directed toward an invalid user.
Problems/challenges:
[not including technical implementation challenges, which I assume are non-trivial]
- Do these messages show up in game? I think not (ever).
- What about spam issues? Forcing senders to be valid VenanID holders would help.
- What about stalkers? Hmmm..
- Right now, you can edit your name, does that mean your boh_venan email changes? I think yes. It's not a "real" account. It's just a pass through. Any inbound emails to that address would just be lost.Tough cookies.
- Lost emails -- after all, you're talking three steps, the inbound, the translation, and the outbound. Chances of failure increase. Do we worry about these?
- Folks without VenanID? Yeah--seems like they're out for now, or they receive email with their Userxxxxxxxx name...
- Server down time -- after all, it's not a freaking email service!
WHAT DOES THIS SOLVE:
- Email just your officers (as long as you can type in their names). Not 100% helpful, but at least you'd have a workaround.
- This allows the in-game email to serve as more of an "announcement" function as well as a way to get updates about guild status, raids, and raid rewards. Keeps it simple. The devs should focus on the game, right?
- Developers don't have to replicate all the various complex requirements most people expect from email.
- User can use regular ol' email.
VARIATIONS:
I can think of tons of variations and ideas. But I'd be curious to know what others think. There seems to be a strong desire for a few features, like being able to email just guild officers. This would solve that. If there's really no other burning desire, this is overkill.
Thoughts?