Markonian put it much more eloquently than I originally did... I am looking for an incentive for people to have guild loyalty, not a penalty for mercing. This is meant to address the imbalance for people who prefer to stay in-guild.
Yes, I realize one can merc and return... Yes, I realize guild buffs help... But one can join ANY open door guild to take advantage of buffs for farming...
Here's one obvious disadvantage, currently: A guild member who is responsible for a raid cannot leave the guild unless they are sure they will be repromoted in time to start it. This is in fact a punishment for being a guild officer. Yeah, I hear you already:"coordinate with the GM, have an alt as veteran..." These are band-aids for a broken guild-system. Well, not broken, but bent a little.
I don't know what the "one-true-solution" is, but I am hoping someone will unbend this crimp for the guilds.
Yes, I realize one can merc and return... Yes, I realize guild buffs help... But one can join ANY open door guild to take advantage of buffs for farming...
Here's one obvious disadvantage, currently: A guild member who is responsible for a raid cannot leave the guild unless they are sure they will be repromoted in time to start it. This is in fact a punishment for being a guild officer. Yeah, I hear you already:"coordinate with the GM, have an alt as veteran..." These are band-aids for a broken guild-system. Well, not broken, but bent a little.
I don't know what the "one-true-solution" is, but I am hoping someone will unbend this crimp for the guilds.