Book of Heroes

Incentive for guild loyalty

There is a great incentive for mercs in that they can find a raid most anytime. But what is the reward for guilds? Just look at all the posts in global practically begging for mercs... It makes holding a guild together dependent on mercs... Maybe a feature where guild buffs don't kick
In until 24 hours after joining, or some completely different feature, so long as it gives an equality to the decision to either merc out or stay put in a guild. At the very least it would allow guild officers to have more fun rather than posting in global. And it would leave global a little more open to the social butterflies who are scared to talk to live people on the flesh, and prefer e-chat.
The reward for the guild is a finished raid with valor for members, power for their rating and prestige.

Swashbuckling_DrarrrrrrgonChick

ModeratorMon Oct 22, 2012 10:19 am
What makes you think that people who chat on global are afraid to talk to people in real life? Seems a bit of an odd thing to say...

Celestial_Cavalier

ModeratorMon Oct 22, 2012 11:06 am
I believe japster already started a thread about this one. Mercs are not the problem rather it's the lack of new / endgame contents. Guilds have the option whether they want to accept mercs or not.
[quote="Celestial_Cavalier"]I believe japster already started a thread about this one. Mercs are not the problem rather it's the lack of new / endgame contents. Guilds have the option whether they want to accept mercs or not.[/quot

Where's the like button for this comment?
Well, one incentive for guild loyalty is continual access to the guild favors while questing and farming.  I think far better (though less tangible) incentives are the feeling of accomplishment of helping to
build something, and the sense of belonging one gets from being in a
close-knit guild.  My guild is home and family to me.

But it’s not for everyone.  Some people need more freedom with their play schedule and why shouldn’t they have it?  I would have become a merc myself originally if I had realized that it would be a viable option.  As it is, I still merc occasionally when my guild is not raiding to help others out and build my might, and I think a good percentage of mercs are actually guild members that are mercing in off-guild hours.

I am strongly opposed to any penalties being placed upon the merc community (I know this is ostensibly an incentive for guild loyalty, but it could and I think would be perceived as a penalty on mercs). Mercs help keep raids viable for guilds that can’t always field the number of people required.  And I don’t see the benefit.  Does the original poster suppose that this would force mercs to give up their freedom and choose a guild?  I think it would instead cause many to leave and find a game that lets them play the way they want to play.
A Simple and Easy-to-Implement Incentive for Guild Loyalty would be to Pay Members for staying & sticking with their Guild.
It would work like this: For each day that a player stays in the Guild, they "Earn" Pay (GS would be easiest form of payment). However, they only get paid for a week at a time, meaning they must stay in the Guild for 7 Consecutive days, before getting paid. If they LEAVE the guild, at ANY time in the 7 day period, they Forfeit that week's pay.
This would allow players to HONESTLY "Try" a Guild for a week, and if it didn't work out, they could collect their pay and go, no hard feelings.
This simple system would make it Advantageous to stay Loyal and stick with a guild, without the "Perception" of "Punishment" to those who wander.
In addition, there would be a "Bonus" at the end of a month, wherein those Loyal Guild Members who had been in the Guild all month long, without leaving, would receive additional "Pay", either Bonus GS or perhaps even Valors.
The System would be easy for Venan to implement, by tying it into the Timeline for the Leader Boards in the Inn. The "Week" would start on the same day/schedule as when the Leader Boards reset.

Overall, this Plan would do what it sets out to do: Reward those Players who stay Loyal to their Guild, with no "Punishment" to the wanderers.
If those individuals feel "Left Out" of getting the extra GS, then perhaps they might rethink the wandering life....
However, I'm pretty certain their Priority is Knight's Valor...so a few more GS to Loyal Guild Members shouldn't be a concern for them.

Hopefully Venan will Consider this Plan, as those Players who Choose to stay Loyal to their Guild are Few and Far Between, and they need all the help they and their Guilds can get, as the vast majority of players do not opt for True "Original Concept" Guild Loyalty, and much prefer their temporary Raid Tents.

Hachiman_Defender_of_Oda

ModeratorWed Oct 24, 2012 3:30 pm
The guild should be enough to inspire loyalty. Loyalty shoul dbe earned by the leadership of the guild, not some system from the devs in my opinion.

Celestial_Cavalier

ModeratorWed Oct 24, 2012 4:51 pm
Jetras_of_Eld wrote:The guild should be enough to inspire loyalty. Loyalty shoul dbe earned by the leadership of the guild, not some system from the devs in my opinion.

I also agree with this because why should we be receiving rewards for playing the game the way Venan designed it to be. If you are in a guild and you are not happy with the number and/or quality of daily raids then there are other guilds to choose from. As I said before mercs are not the problem and I believe that even when 1.5 comes out mercs will still be there because of the fact that some people don't like the confines of a guild.

Ultimately it boils down to choice. IMO the question is not to guild or not to guild rather it is to guild or to merc because I believe there are very few if any active players that do not belong to a guild and do not merc at the same time.
UnionsBuildMiddleClass wrote:There is a great incentive for mercs in that they can find a raid most anytime. But what is the reward for guilds? Maybe a feature where guild buffs don't kick
In until 24 hours after joining, or SOME COMPLETELY DIFFERENT FEATURE (emphasis added), so long as it gives an equality to the decision to either merc out or stay put in a guild.

Blinders. Wonderful invention! Works GREAT on Horses! Not so good for Humans! ;-(

I was merely responding to the Original Post, seeking to Address the Issue of Equality in the Decision to either "Merc out" or "stay put in a guild".

Really, it's NOT a Question of Lacking Leadership, but a Question of Numerable Equality. And, of course, the Peer and/or Political Pressure to engage in the Vagabond Lifestyle versus choosing to remain Loyal to a Guild, such being done at one's Peril ("Punishment" for Refusing to Bow to the Will of the Loudest).

The Original Post sought to address the Pecuniary Imbalance that currently exists when one Chooses to be Loyal to a Guild and remain with them. While the Monetary Benefits of Choosing the Vagabond Lifestyle are well-known, the Endless Acquisition of Valor, primarily Knight's Valor, the Decision to Remain Loyal and stay with a single Guild, currently does not offer such a Financial Assurance. I believe the Original Post was meant to Address this Imbalance.
I see no reason why ANYONE would have an Issue with making the Game Fair & Balanced...unless they PREFER to "Keep the Rebels down", a Statement many a Dictator and Tyrant has uttered....

In short, I know MY Post was merely Positing a Possible System whereby the Current Numerable Inequality between the Vagabond Lifestyle and the Lifestyle of a Loyal Guild Member, which is currently so wildly out of Balance, could possibly be Remedied. Again, WHO could POSSIBLY Object to "Fairness and Equality" for all?

To Paraphrase another Old Adage concerning Horses, "You can Lead a Horse to water, but you can't make him THINK."

Peace Be with You. :-)