Bbbb wrote:I think a much simpler system is to have people declare a home guild and either time lock them for some period of time (24 hours?) or require GS to change home guilds. If you are raiding in your home guild, you get a better payout than if you are a merc.
Or another possibility is that if you are in your home guild, you get the favors. If you are a merc, you don't.
Bbb very valid points. Like I said of you check suggestions many want some sort of change within the system. How we go about it I'm all ears.
As for chaos or whatever your name is, you mad bro? I hear kv raids will soon drop tissues as loot
Please keep the discussion civil.
Ejayrazz wrote: The problem is allowin too much freedom between those jumping between guild and merc. It should be a decision that requires time to change.
The real problem is when people start speculating that freedom is a problem.
So, Ejayrazz, you are free to stay in your guild for more that 24hrs, maybe forever, the choice is yours. Now, why do you want me to stick with your guild for at least 24 hrs if I dont want to? You seriously believe this is going to be good for both of us?
I agree power and prestige mean nothing nowadays. I remember when 1.3 was first introduced, for several months until 1.4, there was no such thing as merc. There was no auto-accept option. All players had to file application first before GM or Officers decide to accept them into the guild. There were competitions back then where power and prestige actually reflected how strong guilds were. It was fun and competitive. Good old days. Now, with mercs roaming around freely, guilds are advertising for mercs just so they can finish raids on time. Power and prestige mean nothing
Celestial_Being wrote:I agree power and prestige mean nothing nowadays. I remember when 1.3 was first introduced, for several months until 1.4, there was no such thing as merc. There was no auto-accept option. All players had to file application first before GM or Officers decide to accept them into the guild. There were competitions back then where power and prestige actually reflected how strong guilds were. It was fun and competitive. Good old days. Now, with mercs roaming around freely, guilds are advertising for mercs just so they can finish raids on time. Power and prestige mean nothing
I was mercing back in those days too and so were others. I was in Goats and would go over to Bladeworx regularly (back when they were an unknown guild). Yeah, they would have to accept me but I would go in for one raid and then leave again.
I do agree that power and prestige are currently worthless though.
Grnm wrote:Ejayrazz wrote: The problem is allowin too much freedom between those jumping between guild and merc. It should be a decision that requires time to change.
The real problem is when people start speculating that freedom is a problem.
So, Ejayrazz, you are free to stay in your guild for more that 24hrs, maybe forever, the choice is yours. Now, why do you want me to stick with your guild for at least 24 hrs if I dont want to? You seriously believe this is going to be good for both of us?
Mercs do not need to stay 24 hours. A set time is prevent excessive hopping. Without regulatin it, choosing is pointless and being in a guild has no clear cut benefits
Here are a few ideas, brainstorming on the topic of how to make guilds more attractive or meaningful.
Appealing to quest-oriented players, make quests that can only be completed by a guild. You could even require a minimum number of guild members to be online in order to open or complete the quest. It might be thought that guild challenges fill this role, but they feel anemic when it comes to storyline and cohesion of the plot.
Appealing to players that like buffed characters, apply guild favors only to Members and above. Mercs come in as Recruits, but cannot play with all the extra perks, since they have not attained Member status. Meanwhile, guild Members and above can play like superheroes.
In the same vein, make guild favors more attractive. Some new favors might be a favor that shatters a hard stat cap, a favor that gives a more advantageous stat curve, and a favor that increases the percentage of loot drops.
Appealing to gear-oriented players, allow guilds to design custom gear for their members to wear. A sash, medallion, or belt might be good options. These do not have to be give-aways, either. Guilds might have to complete challenges to earn the right to design the gear, then further earn the materials to craft the gear, one player at a time.
Other ideas?
Bbbb wrote:I think a much simpler system is to have people declare a home guild and either time lock them for some period of time (24 hours?) or require GS to change home guilds. If you are raiding in your home guild, you get a better payout than if you are a merc.
Or another possibility is that if you are in your home guild, you get the favors. If you are a merc, you don't.
I think that's the best. Giving a better payout when you're in your home guild wouldn't penalize mercs as compared to now, but would finally provide an incentive for being in a guild. It'd balance things a bit as currently, you tend to earn more as a merc than as a regular member. Then, if I want to leave my home guild to help another one on a raid, I know I'll get less rewards in that other guild, but will go back to bonus reward when I come back home.
Mmm.. The issue of mercs not getting guild favors was discussed a number of times. It looks like as a result a guild could actually penalize itself as this effectively lowers the efficiency of the ppl helping with the raid. After all, on many occasions this is a question whether the raid succeeds or not. Apart from valor hunting mercs (regular or ad hocish) do actually help saving raids..
On the other hand, lets be realistic, apart from crit and haste other guild favors are not really that big of a deal, especially to high lvl mercs.
Having a home guild (with a bigger payout for raids) sounds like an interesting idea indeed, but again, realistically, a few extra valor/tokens are unlikely to solve the problem completely..
I would still advocate some form of GvG.. or Guild competition. A lot of ppl will have to decide where they loyalties are, hehe
It's actually harder to be part of a guild and to be part of a team than to be a merc. Members in a guild don't just do things for themselves, you work toward the benefit of your guild. Merccing is easy. You can sit out in no guild and come back in whenever you want. For this fact alone, there should be some further reward for the extra efforts guild members go to. This being said, you cannot escape the fact that guilds need Mercs and Mercs need guilds. There are some good suggestions out there, but ultimately you cannot limit the benefits of Merccing without losing some Mercs from the game and in turn the services they provide to countless guilds. I think more value does need to be created around a guild spot. I know that at anytime, I could leave my guild and get nearly any raid I want at any time I feel like playing. And then i could rejoin my guild again at pretty much anytime. Venan, why don't you limit the number of players to guild ratio? Make the spaces count for something. Make them more valuable, make them scarce. If Mercs were abundant, relative to available guild spaces, there would probably be no merc problem.