Book of Heroes

Guild vs merc: time to decide

Guilds vs merc

I know a few of these surfaced, but I'm going to make this very specific in nature.

Guilds are useless, and Mercs have too many incentives. 

This game needs to make a decision and that decision is to make players choose between Mercs or guilders and provide pros and cons for both.

Guilder pros:
Scheduled raids, friendships, guild bonuses, guild vs guild battles (if that's ever coded)

Guilder cons: takes 24 hours to switch guilds so no more jumping ship, inactive guild means find a new one better for your needs, less frequent raids unless guild is properly managed.

Mercs pros: many more powerful raids, freedom to choose.

Mercs cons: no guild vs guild (if ever engineered), 24 hours to switch to guilder, no guild bonuses, need to stay x amount of time in guild before switching again (min 1 hour, max 5 before auto removed) (this is to ensure even Mercs have some sort of restrictions and require careful raiding partners)

Guilds have no purpose. Their power and prestige is pointless because it doesn't actually reflect their guild it reflects a loose system with no structure. 

Mercs will be specially coded as Mercs and guilds will have a "allow Mercs option" for raids in which a merc can join but will receive no guild bonuses and has a time a limit (3-5 hours) an are barred from leaving until raid is complete or abandoned. 

Game is too easy with no structure, no benefits, and no clear cut decision making. This will make guilds require more organization and skill rather than this free for all garbage. Raids are too easy and as of now, pointless compared to what they should be. Power and prestige mean next to nothing now and same with game loyalty. There is very little competition and it's too loose of a system. It's why many lose interest. The best RPGs require choice, a choice that has consequences and benefits. We have little choice in this game with direct results because of it. 

Structuring the guild system will also make Mercs needed because with a structured system raids and benefits become harder. That means Mercs will be needed adding skill and diplomacy to our broken system. Mercs will feel important cause they are because REAL Mercs take the best offer not just any offer and with a structured merc system their decisions reflect their freedom (ex: join an inactive raid you're required to stay x amount of time) meaning balance to the merc structure. 

One last clear cut con that should be considered for a merc is the Pvp system. Guild bonuses should reflect Pvp and if a merc, you have no bonuses. We need decision making and consequences for those decisions but we also need to rebuild the guild system so there are clear cut benefits to guilders for those who actually stay loyal. Pros and cons....we are missing them and the game won't  grow if it's chaotic. Thanks for reading. ~ej PS: I'm a full merc.

Bj_Knows

ModeratorThu Nov 8, 2012 12:55 pm
Ejayrazz wrote:

Mercs cons: no guild vs guild (if ever engineered), 24 hours to switch to guilder, no guild bonuses, need to stay x amount of time in guild before switching again (min 1 hour, max 5 before auto removed) (this is to ensure even Mercs have some sort of restrictions and require careful raiding partners)

Several times, CJ has call me and say "Guild X needs help". If available, I will log in with BarbSpice, my highest Kill Per Minute (KPM) character. Other Mercs with Guild X will often say "we came from Guild Y, we are also failing a Raid". The most Raids I have helped save in this manner is 5 different Raid/ Guilds in 2 hours.

With the above restrictions, I would have to pick which of the Guilds I was going to help before knowing all the Guilds that needed help. I don't need Squire Valor(sqV), but I can make the most difference in low level Raids, do I help them? Knight Valor(KV) will help with v1.5, but I can make the least difference in high level Raids, do I help them?

If I understand it correctly, the above restrictions will also invalidate my trick "Help the Squires". I will join a Squire Valor(sqV) Raid with BarbSpice, run out of energy, quit the Guild, rejoin the Guild, recharge energy, repeat. Since I do not need the Squire Valor(sqV) [currently BarbSpice has 9.8 million Silver Coin which buys Tier 6 Items and Tier 2 Gems just like Squire Valor(sqV) ], this lets the Guild I am helping get all the RPP while BarbSpice gets the Silver Coin and Hero Score.
BjofCJandBj wrote:
Ejayrazz wrote:

Mercs cons: no guild vs guild (if ever engineered), 24 hours to switch to guilder, no guild bonuses, need to stay x amount of time in guild before switching again (min 1 hour, max 5 before auto removed) (this is to ensure even Mercs have some sort of restrictions and require careful raiding partners)

Several times, CJ has call me and say "Guild X needs help". If available, I will log in with BarbSpice, my highest Kill Per Minute (KPM) character. Other Mercs with Guild X will often say "we came from Guild Y, we are also failing a Raid". The most Raids I have helped save in this manner is 5 different Raid/ Guilds in 2 hours.

With the above restrictions, I would have to pick which of the Guilds I was going to help before knowing all the Guilds that needed help. I don't need Squire Valor(sqV), but I can make the most difference in low level Raids, do I help them? Knight Valor(KV) will help with v1.5, but I can make the least difference in high level Raids, do I help them?

If I understand it correctly, the above restrictions will also invalidate my trick "Help the Squires". I will join a Squire Valor(sqV) Raid with BarbSpice, run out of energy, quit the Guild, rejoin the Guild, recharge energy, repeat. Since I do not need the Squire Valor(sqV) [currently BarbSpice has 9.8 million Silver Coin which buys Tier 6 Items and Tier 2 Gems just like Squire Valor(sqV) ], this lets the Guild I am helping get all the RPP while BarbSpice gets the Silver Coin and Hero Score.
It's the idea of formalizing the system. The system can be different than I propose but it's te idea of pros and cons. Allowing complete freedom is of course a choice that We could consider however the perks need to be what we consider equal to guilders because balance is everything. Allowing Mercs complete freedom may be too much as many have multiple accounts. If you choose to raid you should e obligated to finish it like a real merc, of another idea is if you abandon you're not welcomed back in that raid. There needs to be a balance and with that comes perks and repercussions.
I believe there should be more things to do in a guild and more values to stay in à guild. Just penalizing mercs will only hurt the game. Gamewize you can easily do all quests without the guilds anyway.

No, stop thinking about ways to hurt mercs. Invent new stuff that promotes guilds instead.

You should also consider one more thing. The ability to merc lets the casual player also join raids. Hindering mercs Will also hinder the casual player...

TragicksLoveChild

Thu Nov 8, 2012 4:12 pm
If not able to merc, i would quit the game. Im a working mom that plays when i can. If not allowed to change guilds during the same 24 hours i would only be raiding once a day. I get wanting bonuses for guild loyalty. Thats great. But i enjoy helping a guild thats struggling with my 20 mins that i can play. I know others would feel the same.
Don't be so dramatic. "Gotta take a stand", "You must choose sides", "Tastes great! But is less filling!" Blah, blah, blah

I'm with KimmyJo and Nick ... I want to raid when I want and how I want. And something that is not being acknowledged is that we are dealing with a market economy here. There are limited resources; gold, silver, valor, energy, slots for players, raid types, raid qualified players, etc! If you tool with one aspect of this economy, you risk blowing things up.

Anyone who sees this as protect the guilds! Doesn't understand the impact of their caterwauling. My favorite guild lost lots of players and we sent each other lots of emails about why we were leaving and no one ever said, "I'm over-merced. I done had too much fun."

They left because real world priorities changed or they tired of losing or they got bored with the game play.

Kiss my grits.
Nick wrote:I believe there should be more things to do in a guild and more values to stay in à guild. Just penalizing mercs will only hurt the game. Gamewize you can easily do all quests without the guilds anyway.

No, stop thinking about ways to hurt mercs. Invent new stuff that promotes guilds instead.

You should also consider one more thing. The ability to merc lets the casual player also join raids. Hindering mercs Will also hinder the casual player...

That is also very true. Keeping Mercs the same could be beneficial so long as guild meaning is restructured. The problem is allowin too much freedom between those jumping between guild and merc. It should be a decision that requires time to change.

As for chon I have no idea what the hell you're talking about but stop the crying I never said this is killing the game completely in saying it needs restructuring. Your tears are delicious however
I think a much simpler system is to have people declare a home guild and either time lock them for some period of time (24 hours?) or require GS to change home guilds. If you are raiding in your home guild, you get a better payout than if you are a merc.

Or another possibility is that if you are in your home guild, you get the favors. If you are a merc, you don't.
[quote/]As for chon I have no idea what the hell you're talking about but stop the crying I never said this is killing the game completely in saying it needs restructuring. Your tears are delicious however[/quote]

Of course you don't know what I'm talking about. You're wrapped up in game play, imagining a world where BoH is strictly a guild thing rather than a once enjoyable turn based, role playing game. Go try a game of hide-&-go-f#€¥-yourself.