Book of Heroes

Update 1.5 - December 20, 2012 · page 4

Bj_Knows

ModeratorWed Dec 19, 2012 9:34 am
Philc wrote:

So, where did I miscalculate?

I hate to jump to conclusions before seeing v1.5, but in the past when they added Siesmic Slash and Smoke Bomb with Monster Knock back, it took 11 days and 4 reseting of abilities (through Server Updates) to balance out class abilities.

Just a quick glance at your work.

Edit: removed in favor of Little_Mike's official reply ( Update 1.5 - December 20, 2012 )

Disclaimer: I am not affiliated with Venan in any way. So far I am 0 for 3 (predicted no level Raise, predicted no new items, predicted no new Valor). I blame my failures on Venan rolling 3-5 smaller updates into one large update as they say "Hey, if we change this, we have to change that", repeat. Very similar to v1.3 update.

Little_Mike

Site AdminWed Dec 19, 2012 9:49 am
Philc wrote:Hi,

I was so excited by the update that I started planning my builds. However, I made my calculations, and it seems to me that the War mage is much stronger than the other two, especially for onslaughts (I hope I am mistaking!). Let me explain:

Justiciar:
-Passive: +30%dom with frenzy&weapon focus. If you count that:
-Mass attacks: Cleave 182%, Seismic 78%, Radiant light 104%
-Individual attacks: Smite 260%, Brutal strike 208%

Shadow walker:
-Passive: Dual wield means approx +20%dom. If you count that:
-Mass attacks: Acid spray 96%, Poison cloud 120 %
-Individual attacks: Toxic blade & Piercing strike 180%

War mage. Fire track for instance:
-Passive: Inner focus plus fire mastery +75%dom (!!!). If you count that:
-Mass attacks: Flaming pyre 245%. Better than 2 mass attacks from the others!!!
-Individual attacks: Incinerate 306% & Fire blast 210% on a burning target

Plus burning does more damage than bleeding and occurs more often.

So, where did I miscalculate? Of course, there is many things I did not take into account (great ideas like Riposte and Backswing), but the difference in damage (and so efficiency in onslaught) is overwhelming.

Doesn't mean I don't love 1.5. You really stopped clones. There is many different builds for each class. Plus passives are Great!

Just a few things: You forgot to calculate in Justicar's Weapon Focus passive. Also, the War Mage is still undergoing balance changes, so expect to see some of those numbers come down. You have to also take into account of cooldown times, activation times, rotations, and procs. We balanaced the classes to the best of our ability, but we really need to just push this out to live and then analyze the numbers from the hundreds of users to really be able to see how things are. Expect to see some additional changes in 1.5.1.
Bj_DWR wrote:I blame my failures on Venan rolling 3-5 smaller updates into one large update as they say "Hey, if we change this, we have to change that", repeat. Very similar to v1.3 update.

You are absolutely correct in this. Everything in the game is intertwined, so if we make one change, it cascades to other systems in the game. That's why it took quite a long time to roll this out.
I see no changes to Onslaughts. Is that because Venan thinks they are correctly balanced now?
Will be very interesting to try the new structure out, making some preliminary plans for my warmage. I just hope there will be some enemies with higher level than 30 to provide a serious challenge (even in SP) with maxed out level.
The only thing that gave me a real scare was the hard cap on haste, 90%!!!!. I hope anything close to this in practicality is unatainable otherwise that might be hard to balance.

Lady_Katy

Site AdminWed Dec 19, 2012 11:16 am
Peter34 wrote:I see no changes to Onslaughts. Is that because Venan thinks they are correctly balanced now?

With the number of changes to player abilities, we want to see how those balance before making changes to onslaught again. I wouldn't be surprised to see modifications to abilities, onslaught, or both in the 1.5.1 patch.

Little_Mike

Site AdminWed Dec 19, 2012 11:45 am
High_Auger wrote:The only thing that gave me a real scare was the hard cap on haste, 90%!!!!. I hope anything close to this in practicality is unatainable otherwise that might be hard to balance.

The hard cap of haste is 90% but you will never see that.
Little_Mike wrote:
The hard cap of haste is 90% but you will never see that.

So are you switching to a more curved diminishing returns function, insteda of the abrupt two-step function that has been in use so far?
Lady_Katy wrote:With the number of changes to player abilities, we want to see how those balance before making changes to onslaught again. I wouldn't be surprised to see modifications to abilities, onslaught, or both in the 1.5.1 patch.

Okay. My main problem is that with 6 seconds of time, there's not much variation in outcome. You'll kill either 2 waves, or 3 waves. If the time is increased to 7 or 7.5 seconds, it'll be possible to achieve 4 wave-kills, which means that skilled players playing skilled characters can actually excel at Onslaughts. (Not necessarily saying I'm a skilled player myself, or that my SW has had a very good skill point allocation.)

Bj_Knows

ModeratorThu Dec 20, 2012 2:25 am
Peter34 wrote:

that with 6 seconds of time, there's not much variation in outcome. You'll kill either 2 waves, or 3 waves. If the time is increased to 7 or 7.5 seconds, it'll be possible to achieve 4 wave-kills

The more over powered your character the more Combat Encounters(ce) per 6 combat seconds your character gets. This is why they put a limit of 7k Might Rating on "Crypt of Corruption" for the Glenfort Games. My 9.55k Shadow Walker could get 7- 8ce in "Crypt of Corruption". My 9.55k Justicar would get 4ce per 6 seconds in Phase 4 of "War of Fellmarsh". Characters with 14k+ Might Rating would do significantly better.