Book of Heroes

Portals vs Raids vs Quest · page 2

Looks like there is divided opinion on this issue, should make for some interesting discussions.

I agree 100% with the OP. Portals appearing at unknown or random intervals is a step away from the casual or "pick up and play" nature of BoH. For some I am sure this is a good thing - but for others this is an aggravation. I don't mind if something takes a long time or is grindy, but the inability to reliably plan my playtime is frustrating and not fun. Maybe once we get over the initial hurdles this won't be such an issue - but considering that the incursions are a barrier to the main quest line, it may take some people a LONG time to get over the hurdle of being in the right place at the right time.

Knowing the portal schedule as the OP suggests would help. Another idea would be to allow each player to activate their own portal instead of having it be a server wide event. To prevent portal farming, the number of activations per day could be limited (similar to how daily bounties work now). A compromise that might make both groups happy: allow a player to choose between entering random portals OR activating a device to create their own portal. If creating their own portal, the player would be barred from entering random portals for a time (e.g. 24 hrs). In this way, players who use the random portals have the opportunity to gain more resources than those who create their own portals; yet those who create their own portals will still see continuous progress at their own pace.
Lodel wrote:Looks like there is divided opinion on this issue, should make for some interesting discussions.

I agree 100% with the OP. Portals appearing at unknown or random intervals is a step away from the casual or "pick up and play" nature of BoH. For some I am sure this is a good thing - but for others this is an aggravation. I don't mind if something takes a long time or is grindy, but the inability to reliably plan my playtime is frustrating and not fun. Maybe once we get over the initial hurdles this won't be such an issue - but considering that the incursions are a barrier to the main quest line, it may take some people a LONG time to get over the hurdle of being in the right place at the right time.

Knowing the portal schedule as the OP suggests would help. Another idea would be to allow each player to activate their own portal instead of having it be a server wide event. To prevent portal farming, the number of activations per day could be limited (similar to how daily bounties work now). A compromise that might make both groups happy: allow a player to choose between entering random portals OR activating a device to create their own portal. If creating their own portal, the player would be barred from entering random portals for a time (e.g. 24 hrs). In this way, players who use the random portals have the opportunity to gain more resources than those who create their own portals; yet those who create their own portals will still see continuous progress at their own pace.


In my opinion, this is a highly attractive option, definitely something worth looking at Venan! :-) I agree that the randomness has brought new life to the game, but not fair to feel like you're slacking if you step away from the game, for fear of missing a random event! the thought behind the portal events is great, we just need to make it more workable
Lodel wrote:Looks like there is divided opinion on this issue, should make for some interesting discussions.

I agree 100% with the OP. Portals appearing at unknown or random intervals is a step away from the casual or "pick up and play" nature of BoH. For some I am sure this is a good thing - but for others this is an aggravation. I don't mind if something takes a long time or is grindy, but the inability to reliably plan my playtime is frustrating and not fun. Maybe once we get over the initial hurdles this won't be such an issue - but considering that the incursions are a barrier to the main quest line, it may take some people a LONG time to get over the hurdle of being in the right place at the right time.

Knowing the portal schedule as the OP suggests would help. Another idea would be to allow each player to activate their own portal instead of having it be a server wide event. To prevent portal farming, the number of activations per day could be limited (similar to how daily bounties work now). A compromise that might make both groups happy: allow a player to choose between entering random portals OR activating a device to create their own portal. If creating their own portal, the player would be barred from entering random portals for a time (e.g. 24 hrs). In this way, players who use the random portals have the opportunity to gain more resources than those who create their own portals; yet those who create their own portals will still see continuous progress at their own pace.

I'm sorry but portal is necessary for main quest. If you haven't completed other quests other than portal quests then you shouldn't do portal quests until completion of other quests
Bj_DWR wrote:Subject:
Portals vs Guilds or Leaderboard Rewards Debate Pt 2
doodllz wrote:
I envision these portals will have a negative impact on guilds scheduled raids and success rates will become difficult to achieve due to members & mercs becoming undecided on which to take part in.


Except for a few quests, you do not need the Portals until you have all Tier 12 or Tier 14 Gear. You need Guild Raids to get Valor for these items and Tier 5 Gems.

Unlike Augment Gems, Runic Enchantments are not easy to swap out or move. Rumor has it, they are intended as End Game Content. Runic Enchantments require huge amount of Essence & Flux, just like the higher level on Tomes/ Hero Training were +8 to Stat requires 500 Hero Tokens (for an idea of scale 500 Hero Tokens equals 33% of the total Guild Rewards for “Cursed Keep”, 12% of the total Guild Rewards from “War of Fellmarsh” or 45 Gold Shields if you buy them at Majerio’s Shop).

It gives Uber Level Characters something to Farm besides Mercing “War of Fellmarsh”.

Guild Proponents have been bemoaning Mercing taking away from Guilds while Merc Proponents champion Mercing for a way to get Valor while your Guild is asleep. Portals lets your high Might Rating characters, who have spent Gold Shields on Tier 4 Gems, further improve their characters while the Guild is alseep.

High Level Guilds should like Portals even more. You already have all 9 Guild Favors (which also help in Portals) and discourages your members from Mercing in Middle Level Guilds lower “Crypt of Corruption” and “The Shadow Comes” for high Hero Score (and to avoid the long Cool down of Onslaught Raids).

Portals are in Beta, just like Onslaught. Unlike Onslaught you cannot cheat the cool down by Mercing another Guild.

Lord_Venan has officially stated that the easiest way to get Valor is Mercing, which is broken. However Mercing is a valid option. Officially Venan wants to reduce Mercing by giving players a choice between staying in the Guild (and all its perks) and Mercing for more convenient Raid times.

( Update 1.5 Design Notes - Part 2 )
Lord_Venan wrote:
Regarding Guilds and Mercs

Well, I don't have a definite answer here yet, other than that we want to see less mercing, so making mercing easier is not necessarily going to be something we allocate a lot of resources to. We see mercing as a user solution to some design problems with raids and guilds, and the best way to fix this is through some design/rule changes so that people who want to merc are definitely making a tradeoff of some sort versus those who want to stay in one guild. Currently it is just the defacto best way to get valor, and that is a bit broken.

Deathwing Radiers(DWR) plans to temporarily reduce Raiding while people reach Level Cap since the new curves (except Magic, Melee & Haste) gives a huge advantage to characters at the Level Cap. Even after people reach Level Cap, this will give Guild members on a different schedule something to do while the Guild is asleep.
You make a valid point -which I will take into view as my guild grows; however, I am blessed to have an active guild. So this brings my initial concern back to light, when members reach the higher levels and want to focus on farming items for enchantments in portals and it conflicts with a scheduled raid, the guild raid is likely to suffer.

Reducing raids is an option; however, as most GM's know not everyone lives in the same timezones. For guilds wanting to progress forward and join the top 10 less raids is not the way forward. This is a huge learning curve for all, I'm interesting to see how this pans out.

Thank you for taking the time out to respond.
Lodel wrote:Looks like there is divided opinion on this issue, should make for some interesting discussions.

I agree 100% with the OP. Portals appearing at unknown or random intervals is a step away from the casual or "pick up and play" nature of BoH. For some I am sure this is a good thing - but for others this is an aggravation. I don't mind if something takes a long time or is grindy, but the inability to reliably plan my playtime is frustrating and not fun. Maybe once we get over the initial hurdles this won't be such an issue - but considering that the incursions are a barrier to the main quest line, it may take some people a LONG time to get over the hurdle of being in the right place at the right time.

Knowing the portal schedule as the OP suggests would help. Another idea would be to allow each player to activate their own portal instead of having it be a server wide event. To prevent portal farming, the number of activations per day could be limited (similar to how daily bounties work now). A compromise that might make both groups happy: allow a player to choose between entering random portals OR activating a device to create their own portal. If creating their own portal, the player would be barred from entering random portals for a time (e.g. 24 hrs). In this way, players who use the random portals have the opportunity to gain more resources than those who create their own portals; yet those who create their own portals will still see continuous progress at their own pace.
Sounds like an interesting option. Something along this line would help -especially with casual players -and those that are time limited to play BoH. This current update is very suited for players who can devote a lot of time to BoH -those with limited time would be stuck in limbo to which to prioritise if a random portal has opened -quest? Raid? Portal? -and what if they never stumble across a portal due to their limited gameplay? Is it fair they lose out too? There were suggestions in global to have a portal notification for such players -which could work. I'd be interesting to see how often a portal pops up during 24 hours -that may help me gague a better schedule if Venan is unlikely to be forthcoming with a hint of a portal schedule.

I'm not knocking the new update -I LOVE it; but Venan should realise not all players can play BoH 24/7 -it's not the norm, we all have a life and commitments outside of BoH. I'd appreciate if that is acknowledged and this is looked into and tweaked for casual players & those with guild commitments too.

Thank you to everyone who has taking the time to respond to this post, I really appreciate it.

~doodllz