I'd like to add random gems from lockboxes to this thread. 100 shards take a long time to earn. Out of 6 lockboxes I've opened among my 3 toons, I've gotten 0 gems that I wanted. 2 T4 resist gems (I wanted crit power) and 2 T3 melee gems on my Mage, and 1 each T3 health gem on my Justicar and Shadow Walker (wanted melee and melee/magic respectively). I'd gladly pay 200 shards per gem for the ability to choose the gem I wanted as I have the worst luck. Oh yeah, when my mage also finally got a T4 gem from the Holiday Goblin, it was a health gem. I don't gem for health.
It's possible to buy the exact gem you want for silver, shields, or valor, though. There's no way to get flux or elite drops without the RNG playing the biggest role.
But I understand your frustration. Mages have been complaining (justifiably, in my opinion) about melee gems - well, the melee stat, really - ever since we switched over, and I never use health gems either.
You can't buy T3 and above gems with silver. I don't buy gs but I do do the free gs offers; however, the offers are limited and also shared among all your toons, so I'm very selective on what I use gs for. My guild is not doing KV raids yet, so can't even but T4 gems.
Trask costs 10 e to enter, with an average shard drop rate of 5 shards per dungeon. That's 20 runs or 200 e just for a shot at a blue T4 lockbox. Goblin King costs 20 e to enter with the same average shard drop rate. So that means 20 runs or 400 e just for a shot at a red T4 lockbox. Haven't gotten to Lord of Blades yet, but I assume it's the same as GK, so that's another 400 e for a shot at a yellow T4 lockbox. Now that the flux drop rates have improved, I think the chances of getting 5 each of the 3 fluxes is a lot better than getting the gem you want from a lock box. Going back to my previous post, I've spent 1200 e between my 3 toons and not gotten a single gem I want. In 1200 e, you would have gotten almost all if not all the fluxes needed for the quest.
Point being, a mechanism does exist to get the gems you want without relying on luck. :) Whether you're willing (shields) or able (valor) to take advantage of it is another matter entirely.
No such mechanism exists for flux/rare drops.
Update. Another T3 health gem from lockbox on my Justicar. So 7 lockboxes, 1400 e and 0 gems that I want.
Whether or not there are other mechanisms for purchasing T3 gems and higher is irrelavent. Also, there now exists a way to convert 1 each of 2 other fluxes into one of the third type of flux. If you spent 1400 e killing vile, you will likely get all the fluxes you need for the quest or for conversion to complete the quest. I seriously doubt, even with a random number generator, that you will not have gotten a single flux or even just a few flux after spending 1400 e. There is no way to convert a gem into another type of gem or even to give it to one of your other toons, so I've currently spent 1400 e and not gotten a single gem I want. I don't count XP or silver as you get those in the portal as well.
I believe that the flux is worse because of the randomness of portals themselves, then couPled with the low drop rate makes things more frustrating because you have full energy and a quest to complete, but no way to do anything, and you want to save the energy if a portal appears.
Gemma wrote:Whether or not there are other mechanisms for purchasing T3 gems and higher is irrelavent.
Actually, the fact that there aren't non-luck based mechanisms for getting flux/rares is precisely the point of this entire thread. What is not is the fact that you want better gear than you
currently have reliable access to. I suppose that's a pity, but it's really not a structural problem with a questline; as you and your guild advance in the game, it will change.
Let's try to focus on the problems mentioned in Rabid's original post, rather than whether a member of a guild which doesn't do KV raids should have access to KV gems.
Ozmund wrote:I believe that the flux is worse because of the randomness of portals themselves, then couPled with the low drop rate makes things more frustrating because you have full energy and a quest to complete, but no way to do anything, and you want to save the energy if a portal appears.
There is a
post containing a pretty reliable portal schedule, but yes, the need to conserve energy to use at a specific time is a concern, clashing as it does with raids.
The focus of this thread is progress based on luck. Whether it's quest progress or gear/gem progress, progress is progress. After all, gear/gem progress is what increases your might which even allows you to complete higher level content without dying, whether in quests or raids, in the first place. For example, I finally got to level 4 once in a volatile portal but kept dying because my might wasn't high enough. Made getting to level 4 worthless to me. Sure would like some higher gems to increase my might.
As mentioned, there is a portal schedule, so you can plan when to conserve energy. There's even a post stating that volatile portals are the ones you should focus on as you can get to levels 2 and 3 faster than in the unstable and wavering portals. As for portals conflicting with raids, guilds can always schedule their raids around portals. My guild tries to do that whenever possible. I suppose it's a pity if a guild can't or won't schedule their raids around portals, because I don't think there is a structural problem with the quest line now that the flux drop rate has been upped. If you think about it, all quests rely on luck, whether it's the dropping of quest items or the spawning of a certain type of mob you need to kill. It just so happens that the flux quest also requires scheduling around portals and has a lower drop rate than earlier quests. Harder, but nowhere close to impossible.
2 of my 3 toons got the fluxes they needed under 1000 vile kills. Assuming an average of 2 vile per wave, and each wave costing 2 e, that's 500 waves which equals 1000 e. I should mention that that both toons got about 2/3 of their fluxes before the flux rate was upped, so you're now actually looking at less than 1000 e for the quest. My third toon is 3 fluxes away from completing the quest and has about 950 vile kills. I should also mention that I mainly focus on the volatile portals so I can get to levels 2 and 3.
As for wanting access to higher gems when my guild is not at that level yet, if Venan didn't want that, they would not have added shards for lockboxes to the game. Let's not even take into account gs as you can't even buy T5 gems with gs. All I'm saying is that in 1000 e and with planning around the volatile portal schedule, you will likely complete the flux quest. Whereas in 1400 e, I haven't gotten a single gem I want. As mentioned before, I'm willing to work for it. So 200 shards or even 300 shards for the ability to choose your gem is fine with me.
I apologize if this came off rude, but I think my point about the luck of gem lockboxes goes hand in hand with the luck of flux drops. As mentioned above, progress is progress.